News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Attorney general: Americans should accept security risks ... by anbop on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @02:20PM (#20508932)
That’s not a logical argument by Franklin, it’s his opinion. There’s no axiomatic reason why Ben Franklin’s opinion is more correct than anyone else’s, even William Barr’s.
Re:Attorney general: Americans should accept security risks ... by salawat on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @03:45PM (#20509625)
Says the rhetoritician; cleverly trying to blur the issue. Opinion or no, the principle is consistent through much of the intellectual environ's of the time. If both statememt's are read as opinion's neither wins. If both are construed as statements of fact, Franklin's still holds the more portentous conclusion. Namely that the being willing to sacrifice his capacity to guide himself to live longer , will inevitably result in neither goal being attained. Everyone dies.

So that's really a bit of a non-starter. I would say that Franklin has more credibility however; if only because of the man's legendary common sense.

I'll also point out, Franklin's sentiment can be traced back to the principle that "Vigilia aeterna est pretium libertatis". A consequence of which is, sorry Mr. Barr. Tell your police to do some actual investigative work. It is not the job of the populace to relinquish essential liberty to make tyranny in the making that much further realized.

It is what we do with our Liberty that elevates us as angels, or drops us to the level of daemonic debasement.

Law enforcement needs to understand their job should never be made trivial as their very existence in and of itself is as the sole means to rescension of that which culturally we value most; hich should absolutely be as burdensome a process as possible in the light of what is being taken.

Never mind that making unbackdoored encryption illegal just adds a token charge to a long list of other charges, which to me is an absolute anti-pattern, of the same level as most firearm regulation in light of the second amendment; which I'll admit to being a bit of a hard-liner on.

My 2 cents.

Re:Attorney general: Americans should accept security risks ... by ratmice on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @06:31PM (#20510819)
Your comparison to the second amendment is not just "on the same level", but entirely accurate.

To this day the United States Munitions List, classifies cryptographic devices under Category XIII Materials and Miscellaneous Articles.

All the way back to the pre-constitution 1784 Virgina General Assembly, to some extent recognizes the need for secure communications channels in a militia. "There shall be a private muster of every company once in every three months", and setting forth those in charge of initiating and communicating the time and place of the muster.

People often focus on the first amendment right to encryption. But I at least feel that the second amendment right is equally strong, with the governments own position on arms control behind it, legal interpretation should if anything not tolerate it's own inconsistency.

Re:Attorney general: Americans should accept security risks ... by tbirrell on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @03:17PM (#20509381)
Benjamin Franklin is a Founding Father and has been generally accepted as an authority for more than 200 years, especially on the subject of freedoms and rights. He was a renown political theorist, politician, civic activist, statesman, and diplomat in his own day, not to mention the fact his reputation has stood the test of time.

William Barr is none of these thing.

Re:Attorney general: Americans should accept security risks ... by EpicEng on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @03:42PM (#20509605)
So... Appeal to authority then?
Re:Attorney general: Americans should accept security risks ... by noja on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @03:52PM (#20509673)
Can you call it that though?

One is a person with a well-earned a reputation, the other.. well you get the point.

Re:Attorney general: Americans should accept security risks ... by EpicEng on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @03:59PM (#20509738)
>Can you call it that though? >One is a person with a well-earned a reputation, the other.. well you get the point.

Yes

>An argument from authority, also called an appeal to authority, or argumentum ad verecundiam, is a form of defeasible argument in which a claimed authority's support is used as evidence for an argument's conclusion

You're not defending the point logically; you're only supporting argument is that someone with a good reputation supports it as well.

Re:Attorney general: Americans should accept security risks ... by kryogen1c on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @05:02PM (#20510169)
> You're not defending the point logically;

He absolutely is

The annoying thing about "logical fallacies" is that if anyone season argument they disagree with that resembles a "fallacy", that quote it and act like theyve won.

He is not saying that everything Benjamin Franklin has ever said is true. Obviously. However, if a well renowned and respected Authority has an opinion that some evil schmuck disagrees with, it provides evidence as to who is more likely to be correct. That's not what an appeal to Authority is

Re:Attorney general: Americans should accept security risks ... by EpicEng on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @05:12PM (#20510248)
>He absolutely is

Show me where that happened.

>The annoying thing about "logical fallacies" is that if anyone season argument they disagree with that resembles a "fallacy", that quote it and act like theyve won.

That is annoying and I agree, but that's not what's going on here.

>He is not saying that everything Benjamin Franklin has ever said is true.

No one said he was.

>However, if a well renowned and respected Authority has an opinion that some evil schmuck disagrees with, it provides evidence as to who is more likely to be correct.

No it doesn't. It absolutely _does not_. Reputation isn't irrelevant in so far as it lends credibility to a person's statements, but the discussion doesn't stop there. If you're going to defend a quote then defend it. Saying "this is true because X is trustworthy and Y is an 'evil schmuck'" is not an argument.

If this is not a prime example of Appeal to Authority then show me why it's not and provide an example. You're just throwing out your opinions as if they were fact.

Re:Attorney general: Americans should accept security risks ... by tbirrell on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @06:04PM (#20510639)
This is not an example of Appeal to Authority because Ben Franklin is an accepted authority. If all parties agree on the reliability of an authority in the given context it becomes a valid inductive argument. Otherwise every Citation or Source or Bibliography would be a "logical fallacy". An Appeal to Authority would be if the quote was attributed to someone like James Polk. Sure he was president, but he has no authority on this sort of subject.
Re:Attorney general: Americans should accept security risks ... by EpicEng on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @06:15PM (#20510705)
>This is not an example of Appeal to Authority because Ben Franklin is an accepted authority.

...huh?

>If all parties agree on the reliability of an authority in the given context it becomes a valid inductive argument.

No, it doesn't. Why do you believe that? How do you feel about quantum mechanics? Do you realize that Einstein fought tooth and nail against it for years?

>Otherwise every Citation or Source or Bibliography would be a "logical fallacy".

Citations link to works, not authorities. A citation may link to, say, an academic paper which provides evidence to support its assertions. No one is linking to random comments made by so-called authorities, that would never be accepted (unless the citation was to literally show that a quote is legitimate, i.e., made by the person claimed to have made it.)

Re:Attorney general: Americans should accept security risks ... by anbop on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @08:06PM (#20511294)
But given a hypothetical question like “What play should a football team run when they are on 2nd down and 3 with 2:19 in the 3rd Quarter while leading by 3 points” — wouldn’t a professional NFL coach’s opinion be given more credence than mine? Einstein may have been wrong on quantum mechanics but if you had 1000 physics question it would be hard to think of a better person to ask.
Re:Attorney general: Americans should accept security risks ... by EpicEng on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @08:58PM (#20511520)
You're proving my point. When examining an argument you should do so based on the merits of said argument. That's literally the basis of Appeal to Authority. It doesn't get more clear cut than this.

I'd also like to point out you have yet to provide a single fact in support of anything you're saying.

Re:Attorney general: Americans should accept security risks ... by anbop on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @11:19AM (#20516106)
I’m not the person you’ve been talking to earlier
Re:Attorney general: Americans should accept security risks ... by EpicEng on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @02:59PM (#20518461)
Sorry, lost track. Doesn't change my point though.
Re:Attorney general: Americans should accept security risks ... by kryogen1c on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @09:59AM (#20515312)
>Saying "this is true because X is trustworthy and Y is an 'evil schmuck'" is not an argument

Great! I didnt say that and neither did the gp you originally replied to. Whats your point?

Re:Attorney general: Americans should accept security risks ... by EpicEng on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @03:01PM (#20518482)
>However, if a well renowned and respected Authority has an opinion that some evil schmuck disagrees with, it provides evidence as to who is more likely to be correct.

That's you as you seem to have forgotten.

Re:Attorney general: Americans should accept security risks ... by kryogen1c on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @10:22PM (#20522076)
Providing evidence towards the likelihood of truth, as I said, and saying "this is true because X is trustworthy and Y is an 'evil schmuck'", as you said, are not equivalent.

Are you actually trying to argue you can't tell the opinion of children and subject matter experts apart because gathering evidence based on reputation is a logical fallacy?

Re:Attorney general: Americans should accept security risks ... by zknz on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @03:59PM (#20509732)
And yet he owned slaves.
Re:Attorney general: Americans should accept security risks ... by onetimemanytime on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @04:48PM (#20510057)
and...? For example, you can be a Nazi and a great mathematician or be a pedophile and a great philosopher....etc etc
Re:Attorney general: Americans should accept security risks ... by raverbashing on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @03:09PM (#20509305)
Correct, I just roll my eyes whenever this is quoted

But if people disagree they can go ride a bike without a helmet, people in the transplant list will thank you.

Re:Attorney general: Americans should accept security risks ... by dang on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @04:45PM (#20510032)
If you keep posting unsubstantive comments and flamebait here we are going to ban you. I don't want to do that, because you've also posted good comments. Would you please fix this?

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Attorney general: Americans should accept security risks ... by raverbashing on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @01:58AM (#20512689)
Agreed, I could have expressed my concerns with that quote differently.