News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by xvilka on Monday July 22, 2019 @11:10AM (#20498715)
Hopefully, Krita[1], GIMP[2], and Inkscape[3] will get a similar amount of support.

[1] https://krita.org/en/support-us/donations/

[2] https://www.gimp.org/donating/

[3] https://inkscape.org/support-us/donate/

Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by anchpop on Monday July 22, 2019 @02:04PM (#20500555)
Has GIMP meaningfully improved in the last 5 years? Every time I've had to use it I've been confused by the lack of features and strange UI.
Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by meruru on Monday July 22, 2019 @02:50PM (#20501053)
2.10 was a big release that came out last year. So yes: https://www.gimp.org/release-notes/gimp-2.10.html

There's some good stuff on the roadmap for 3.0 and 3.2 as well: https://wiki.gimp.org/wiki/Roadmap

Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by tripzilch on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @04:29AM (#20513248)
I've been running into the problem that 8 bits per colour channel is just too little in 2019. You get banding so quickly after certain combinations of operations, I can just feel the bits getting lost in the noise. You can see it by the histogram getting gaps and spikes. Especially with colour curve corrections.

It's getting harder to get modern quality images out of GIMP.

Also some tools that are available in Photoshop, like the many ways to smart select, or to crisp up a selection.

I almost only use GIMP any more for cropping and scaling, anything else, even if the feature is available simply lacks in quality of result.

I used to think the curve bend effect was pretty neat, to do certain types of distortions. But it doesn't do subpixel/anti-aliasing. Then WHY is it still even in there? It's not really that useful and it uses an ancient processing technique that really leaves wanting a lot in image quality.

I haven't tried the other tools mentioned in this thread, but I'm going to give them a try, hopefully they are better.

Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by Miraste on Monday July 22, 2019 @02:51PM (#20501064)
They recently redid the interface to behave much more like Photoshop by default. It's a lot better.
Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by jszymborski on Monday July 22, 2019 @09:14PM (#20503685)
I had much the same experience as you, but the new UI update is similar to the Blender UI update in that it's incredibly more usable.
Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by tripzilch on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @04:30AM (#20513251)
How long ago did GIMP get a UI update?
Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by wetpaws on Monday July 22, 2019 @01:18PM (#20500138)
Krita is amazing, I switched to it from Gimp and it was a breath of a fresh air. Can't really say the same about the Gimp though, it is a bit redundant given how dated its UI is and how mature Krita is already.
Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by hdfbdtbcdg on Monday July 22, 2019 @01:31PM (#20500262)
Don't they do different things? GIMP is for general image editing. Krita focuses on painting?
Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by p1necone on Monday July 22, 2019 @02:53PM (#20501082)
Correct - GIMP is (largely) focused on photo editing, while Krita is (largely) focused on digital painting. Although GIMP/Photoshop definitely support a digital painting workflow with custom brushes and the like - it's just not the primary focus.
Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by wetpaws on Monday July 22, 2019 @01:35PM (#20500308)
I would not say so. Gimp is (arguably) a very long evolution of an mspaint that copyied many tools and workflow from a Photoshop, Krita is an attempt to re-implement Photoshop from scratch.

I wouldn't say Krita is not suitable for general editing, because Photoshop is also dual purpose tool - it is an industry standard both for digital artists and general photo manipulation.

Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by tialaramex on Monday July 22, 2019 @01:50PM (#20500419)
"Arguably" in the sense that you just decided to claim something that has no relation to reality? Like Ghostbusters 2 was "arguably" the highest grossing movie ever made in Albania by a crew of chipmunks?

Gimp starts off as an emergency last minute replacement project for two undergrads at Berkeley that does basically the same thing as Photoshop. It wasn't ever anything like Microsoft's Paint.

Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by wetpaws on Monday July 22, 2019 @03:20PM (#20501362)
I am not sure why of all my entire comment you decided to lash at a single word.

My argument still stays, gimp never was and still nowhere is near the Photoshop level. Krita excels both as painting and photo tool.

Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by corwin7 on Monday July 22, 2019 @07:17PM (#20503169)
You're right, the quality of Gimp is nowhere near Photoshop. Photoshop has tons of rounding errors and the results never look as good as Gimp.
Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by tialaramex on Monday July 22, 2019 @06:53PM (#20503032)
Here's a concrete example, something completely absent from your "argument":

Old Photoshop from that era defaults to a single RGB layer. To turn it into an RGBA layer (e.g. for drawing objects with a transparent background) you need to rename the layer. Not very intuitive but Photoshop users learned to do it. In early Gimp 0.x releases how do you turn the initial single RGB layer into an RGBA layer? You rename it. This is not a coincidence.

In contrast in mspaint there are no layers, there is no RGBA mode.

Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by wetpaws on Monday July 22, 2019 @08:36PM (#20503509)
Notice that I did never attacked you directly, but you keep making subtle personal attacks with snarky quotes and nitpicking. (Is it some kind of religious anger? Are we in a holy-war territory?).

Gimp is a classic old open source project in it's bad and good. It has a preset for toilet paper rolls, but it took it like a decade to support a single window mode, it has an option to rename a layer to switch to rgba mode but there is still no support for generic keyboard layouts from other software other than importing configs and resolving to third party tools (something that krita and most modern IDE routinely do)

Gimp is an emacs of photo editing that stuck in old conventions and never wants to really move forward, I could not use it a decade ago and still can't use nowadays.

Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by siphon22 on Monday July 22, 2019 @08:48PM (#20503571)
I always say that gimp is so shit it comes with toilet paper. -GIMP user since 2008
Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by meruru on Monday July 22, 2019 @02:53PM (#20501085)
They have different focus, but both are raster editors. They do compete with each other.
Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by chronogram on Monday July 22, 2019 @11:40AM (#20499025)
I love those drawn looking animation videos for games like The Burdens of Shaohao https://g.co/kgs/419Tq1 but are there any video game examples where those tools would be beneficial? My video game knowledge is not wide enough. Blender I can definitely see.
Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by babuskov on Monday July 22, 2019 @12:15PM (#20499435)
Any 2D game basically, and some assets for 3D games as well.

For examples of 2D games with great graphics, take a look at: Mark of The Ninja, Hollow Knight, Limbo, Stardew Valley, Rayman Legends.

Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by WorldMaker on Monday July 22, 2019 @12:53PM (#20499850)
The amount of hand-drawn animation that went into Cuphead is a marvel.

There a bunch of really interesting examples just using Ubisoft's UbiArt framework such as Rayman Legends, Child of Light, and Valiant Hearts.

Speaking of Ubisoft and open source, Ubisoft originally announced UbiArt as an engine/framework intended to be open sourced. It's a shame that Ubisoft never followed up on that promise.

Supposedly it hasn't been used for a game since 2015 because it was "hard to use", but that seems more of a reason to open source it, perhaps to see if community interest could help where internal-only work struggled. A lot of open source starts hard to use and takes a village to make it better. (Blender, also mentioned here, might just be a poster child of that, too.)

Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by gambiting on Monday July 22, 2019 @04:36PM (#20502087)
As far as I know it's still used for Just Dance series. It definitely was when I worked on JD2016 and I don't think the engine was changed after that. And yes, in my (personal) opinion UbiArt was extremely difficult to use compared to some other engines within Ubisoft nowadays.

And yes, speaking of Ubisoft and open source - Sharpmake is a build management solution used by a lot of projects within Ubisoft and it was open sourced some time ago. Worth having a look.

Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by p1necone on Monday July 22, 2019 @02:50PM (#20501050)
Having grown up during the heyday of (good and terrible) flash games I can't stand the kind of vector art style that games like Hollow Knight have - it looks unprofessional to me, to the point where I'd rather play a worse game with pixel art.

I know Hollow Knight is fantastic, but it reminds my brain far too much of amateurish flash games.

Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by Qwertystop on Monday July 22, 2019 @11:57AM (#20499256)
Yes? 2D art is useful in both 2D and 3D games (billboard sprites, UI, textures).
Re:Ubisoft joins Blender Development Fund to support open-so... by codetrotter on Monday July 22, 2019 @02:07PM (#20500574)
In addition to that, a lot of concept art is made with 2D drawing and painting software.