News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sacked by a Google algorithm by EGreg on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @02:32PM (#2049859)
While Google's customers ARE the advertisers and their first priority is to make sure they are protected, Google would sit up and do something if more website PUBLISHERS would complain. It's a business.

However, as a practical issue, I fail to see any practical reason to disable the guy's revenue from YouTube videos, based on clicks from an unrelated site. Just stop counting the clicks on the site, Google!

Re:Sacked by a Google algorithm by gscott on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @04:01PM (#2050150)
He has control over those youtube videos, he should take them down, create all new accounts with his wifes information and then put up the truck videos and pretty soon youtube will put him back into advertising mix. For his other site, if I were him I would run Adbrite.com ads instead of Adwords ads.
Re:Sacked by a Google algorithm by anigbrowl on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @04:39PM (#2050264)
Correct, and it's quite possible that Google is undermining its own interests by presenting such incentives.
Re:Sacked by a Google algorithm by jamesaguilar on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @05:12PM (#2050360)
> However, as a practical issue, I fail to see any practical reason to disable the guy's revenue from YouTube videos . . .

Really? I have thought about it for about two minutes and came up with several.

1. Google might assume that someone who has committed click fraud in the past might do so again, and preemptively remove other facets of that person's ability to harm the system.

2. Google might want to discourage people from committing piecemeal fraud by ensuring them that there is no way to risk just part of your account with Google. By disabling all of this guy's ability to make money from Google, they are sending the signal, "Hey, don't think you can pull a fast one and still keep any part of your business with us, even if the site is unrelated."

3. Maybe there was some undisclosed badness going on with the Youtube account that we are not seeing in the account given in this article.