Re:The Story of Metal Gear Solid’s English Translation
by benrbray on Monday July 22, 2019 @09:57PM
(#20503841)
Regarding your second point--I don't believe that e.g. Japanese cultural references can be replaced with something that has the "same meaning" to Western audiences. If I don't understand a reference, I try to look it up later. I see it see as an opportunity to learn more about the experiences of people who are different from me. It's frustrating to me when e.g. "onigiri" is translated as "hamburger" in an anime.
Re:The Story of Metal Gear Solid’s English Translation
by fenomas on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @09:22AM
(#20506493)
By cultural reference I meant things like a character quoting a JP movie or saying the catchphrase of a JP comedian - where if translated directly the line would be understandable, but not actually meaningful, to non-Japanese speakers.
But I think there's a second-order thing going on, where audiences who consume a lot of anime/JRPGs/etc are used to a certain kind of translation, and dialog that's too colorful or expressive winds up not sounding "proper" because one isn't used to anime characters talking that way. E.g. when an anime character makes a cultural reference that will be incomprehensible to non-Japanese audiences, I think a lot of anime fans will expect that to be translated "faithfully" (i.e. incomprehensibly), rather than be replaced with a reference they're familiar with (even if the replacement conveys the same meaning to them that the original conveyed to JP audiences).