This, of course, is an incredibly stupid rule. There’s not really a big difference between market making and proprietary trading in the first place.
Market making is offering public liquidity as part of a market function. They are designated market participants with rules and responsibilities.
They are not the same.
You buy low, and sell high, that's the end of the story, for both proprietary trading, trading for clients, and market making. There's no fundamental, categorical difference between these functions.
The difference between prop trading and market making is fundamentally about the time horizon of exposure. Market makers are aiming to zero out their exposure through frequent trading, while prop trading attempts to express a view on the market in the long-term (seconds for market making vs minutes/day/years for prop trading).
I'm a professional quant, and I don't see much of difference, at least as far as the government is concerned.
Consider the London Whale incident — the entire $6b shortfall was a giant prop position passed off as a hedge.
> “Part of the problem is that it’s too late to hedge interest-rate volatility, there’s not currency volatility to hedge. Speculators need volatility to hedge and enter the market.”
Sounds like a good thing to me.
> New rules limited lenders’ ability and willingness to make principal bets with their own money
Anyone know what regulation this is referring to?
One of Steve Mnuchin's stated goals was to reduce the domination of the 5 mega-banks and help bring back a healthy market of smaller banks that got squeezed out by new rules added after the financial crisis. Rules that were designed with the bigger banks in mind. So I wonder how the smaller players are doing.