Re:Groupon Authorizes $950 Million Series G
by philwelch on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @12:16AM
(#2047999)
The analogy does hold up, because it doesn't rest on the specific quibbles you brought up--namely that Google has more of a monopoly on web advertising than Google's power company has on power. It rests on the fact that a company's dependence on another company's services says nothing about which company is bigger than the other.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Groupon Authorizes $950 Million Series G
by mmt on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @10:58AM
(#2049043)
I understand the point, which could very well hold up, but does the analogy?
Saying that the analogy (argument) rests on "the fact that..." pretty blatantly begs the question.
Is there a case where one company is both bigger than and wholly[1] depends on another, single company's services?
I would be unsurprised if the answer is "no" and that this is the case because dependents are invariably absorbed or killed off by the "parent" before they can grow larger.
[1] If the issue is monopoly, then my "quibble" is that, to Google (or any other electricity consumer beyond a modest size), no company has a monopoly on power.