News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Groupon Authorizes $950 Million Series G by mmt on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @06:41PM (#2047323)
Google can't exist outside of the power company.

I doubt very much that Google doesn't generate at least some of their own power.

I'm quite confident that they can exist outside of any single power company.

Does the analogy hold after this premise is eliminated?

Re:Groupon Authorizes $950 Million Series G by philwelch on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @12:16AM (#2047999)
The analogy does hold up, because it doesn't rest on the specific quibbles you brought up--namely that Google has more of a monopoly on web advertising than Google's power company has on power. It rests on the fact that a company's dependence on another company's services says nothing about which company is bigger than the other.
Re:Groupon Authorizes $950 Million Series G by mmt on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @10:58AM (#2049043)
I understand the point, which could very well hold up, but does the analogy?

Saying that the analogy (argument) rests on "the fact that..." pretty blatantly begs the question.

Is there a case where one company is both bigger than and wholly[1] depends on another, single company's services?

I would be unsurprised if the answer is "no" and that this is the case because dependents are invariably absorbed or killed off by the "parent" before they can grow larger.

[1] If the issue is monopoly, then my "quibble" is that, to Google (or any other electricity consumer beyond a modest size), no company has a monopoly on power.