News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google's Project Dragonfly 'Terminated' in China by whatshisface on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @12:13PM (#20461050)
You're assuming that Google would act as a mole, implementing the censorship in bad faith. Why wouldn't they advance the state of the art for censorship, making it even more effective in an attempt to please the Chinese government? In fact, if China is allowing them in, the party must have some reason to believe the second one will come to pass instead of the first.
Re:Google's Project Dragonfly 'Terminated' in China by sandworm101 on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @12:27PM (#20461224)
Or china quietly takes direct control over the machines biult and run by google. Google then, from the user's perspective, has become that problem governmemt.
Re:Google's Project Dragonfly 'Terminated' in China by khc on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @12:43PM (#20461393)
They could. Do you know that's the case? China allows a lot of foreign investments and to think that the only reason is to further their censorship is silly.
Re:Google's Project Dragonfly 'Terminated' in China by inferiorhuman on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @01:42PM (#20462074)
They could. Do you know that's the case? China allows a lot of foreign investments and to think that the only reason is to further their censorship is silly.

And to think that Google would never submit to Chinese censorship in earnest is naive. Yahoo![1], Google, Microsoft, Cisco, AOL, Skype, and Nortel all willingly partook in aiding the censorship apparatus. Yahoo! even went so far as to out journalists and political targets for the Chinese government. Why wouldn't Google do the same?

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_Yahoo!#Work_in_th...

Re:Google's Project Dragonfly 'Terminated' in China by dirtyid on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @02:04PM (#20462317)
The question is not whether they would do the same - but whether they would the practice to other regions. Did Microsoft, Cisco, AOL, Skype, and Nortel?
Re:Google's Project Dragonfly 'Terminated' in China by inferiorhuman on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @02:20PM (#20462502)
The question is not whether they would do the same - but whether they would the practice to other regions. Did Microsoft, Cisco, AOL, Skype, and Nortel?

Well AOL, Skype, and Nortel don't really exist as independent entities anymore. Microsoft already censors Skype globally (for profanity) the last I checked. Unfortunately censorship in other countries outside of China doesn't seem to get as much attention, but none of those tinpot dictatorship seem to have any trouble getting their hands on censorship technology from the west.

That Google already went down the road of developing a censorship platform with Dragonfly reveals their willingness to aid in government censorship.

Re:Google's Project Dragonfly 'Terminated' in China by unholythree on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @02:29PM (#20462585)
Cisco's been accused of have assisted China in identifing members of Falun Gong.

The first news story I came a across searching (it seems fairly unbiased): https://m.sfgate.com/technology/dotcommentary/article/Cisco-...

Re:Google's Project Dragonfly 'Terminated' in China by dirtyid on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @02:39PM (#20462689)
In China.
Re:Google's Project Dragonfly 'Terminated' in China by filoleg on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @09:40PM (#20465900)
Ah, it happened in China, so that makes it totally cool and justified.

I am not the kind of person to swing the morality flag pretty much ever, but if you don’t see what’s wrong with this, then I don’t know what else to say.

Re:Google's Project Dragonfly 'Terminated' in China by dirtyid on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @10:36PM (#20466204)
It's an appraisal of the article in relation to the original comment. What western companies do in China so far seems to be siloed from what happens in other regions, just like what happens in EU, given sufficiently incompatible regulations. Especially ones that are costly to enforce. It doesn't make it cool or justified, it just makes these appealing slippery slopes arguments not grounded in evidence.

As for the moral flag, I think in context of Sino-US topics, that ship has sailed long ago. It's more useful to contextualize these decisions in a geopolitical / great powers competition lense. Having Google in China is good soft power opportunity for the US. Chinese people are eager for a baidu alternative. I'm not going to pretend that more engagement with China is going to lead to liberalization in the short-term, but I do think it goes a long way towards preventing future hostilities. And I think google being incentivized to operate in China and becoming proficient in bridging the Chinese-open web is a net good.

Re:Google's Project Dragonfly 'Terminated' in China by bduerst on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @02:38PM (#20462680)
What exactly does "submit to chinese censorship" mean in this case? China is already blocking these censored websites- linking them in search results isn't going to magically allow the website to load in the browser.

Even in the example you linked, Yahoo! said "it must respect the laws of governments in jurisdictions where it is operating." How is complying with this different than complying with a U.S. Government subpoena?

Re:Google's Project Dragonfly 'Terminated' in China by T-A on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @02:55PM (#20462837)
> China is already blocking these censored websites- linking them in search results isn't going to magically allow the website to load in the browser.

Unless the user clicks the little down arrow next to the URL, which opens the popup menu with "Cached".

And even if that were also censored, the titles, URLs and the first couple of lines of text returned by Google would speak volumes about what's going on. Imagine googling Tiananmen and getting page after page of search results which all turn out to be inaccessible. What would that tell you?

Re:Google's Project Dragonfly 'Terminated' in China by bduerst on Thursday July 18, 2019 @02:38PM (#20472754)
How many users browse the internet through Google's cache? Splitting hairs over cache vs. linking the dead website is ignoring the point.
Re:Google's Project Dragonfly 'Terminated' in China by T-A on Thursday July 18, 2019 @11:45PM (#20476019)
> How many users browse the internet through Google's cache?

A more pertinent question is how many Chinese users would gladly browse the internet through Google's cache, if it were available to them.

A fair guess is a number at least as large as the number of Chinese users who used to browse the internet through VPNs before the government cracked down on those (nearly 1 in 3 of all Chinese internet users, according to [1], i.e. hundreds of millions).

> Splitting hairs over cache vs. linking the dead website is ignoring the point.

The point, which you appear to have missed, is that you can't expect the censorship to work as implied by the statement I responded to. Google wouldn't be allowed to simply serve up the same search results as outside China. It would have to remove them entirely.

[1] https://www.goldenfrog.com/blog/china-cracks-down-on-vpn-use...

Re:Google's Project Dragonfly 'Terminated' in China by inferiorhuman on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @02:57PM (#20462855)
How is complying with this different than complying with a U.S. Government subpoena?

Are you asking how censorship and subpoenas are different?

Re:Google's Project Dragonfly 'Terminated' in China by grimjack00 on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @12:51PM (#20461478)
Of course there are other reasons, such as co-opting foreign technology.
Re:Google's Project Dragonfly 'Terminated' in China by cwkoss on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @03:07PM (#20462932)
Foreign corporations have to give up a lot of control to do business in China.