The whole point is that a decentralized storage network can add such features on top of the 1TB refurbished hard drive.
The refurbished drive may not be reliable, but if you replicate your data amongst many separate drives with independent failure (geographically distributed; different providing entities) then you can create a system with greater reliability. By using erasure coding schemes (similar to RAID5/6), it's possible to reduce the storage overhead which supports reliability to a fraction of the principle amount. Thus, providing 1 TB of storage to the network could earn slightly less than 1 TB of reliable storage in return.
Comparatively, a single cloud provider has the disadvantage that, because they are a single legal entity, they can decide for whatever reason to not continue your service.
The line that is annoying me and probably others is this:
> Buyers are essentially paying Amazon each month the entire cost of the hard drives used to store their data
...They're not. Because redundancy. Because electricity, CPUs, network, software development, etc.
The comparison establishes the fact hat Amazon's price is not coming from the physical storage HW itself, its the everything around it. Then you can move to discussing how to get other parts cheaper.
I think the comparison with a $20 1TB hdd is perfect. Cloud providers, and phone makers, have convinced you to have your photos, music, data, online, always. Like a bank. Among other things, its much easier to mine your usage patterns that way and enforce DRM of other cloud services.
I have my IDE PC drive from 20 years ago. It still works. I can burn a CD if im that worried about failure. I dont need the redundancy of a billion user website, a networking api, access control, all that other crap you use in enterprises that comply with ISO standards.
Before cloud providers, people didnt take their photos to Apple and tell them to store them. The only reason u do it now, is because of marketing and service integration.
This may lead people to think cloud storage is a waste of money, which I personally think is untrue (though Sia certainly may be able to do it for cheaper than cloud storage, too. Both things can be true.) While the cost to us is certainly more than the cost to the provider, the cost for us to replicate what a cloud provider offers is certainly greater at small scales where we benefit less from amortization and volume pricing.
A good point may be that we don’t actually need to replicate what a cloud provider does to offer a compelling alternative for various use cases. This I would probably agree with. It is certainly cheaper for me to have my own NAS and offsite backups than it would be to pay for cloud storage, though it is still surprisingly expensive (at least to the uninitialized. Check out what a fully loaded Synology 8 bay would cost! Multiply by number of backup sites. A lot of storage, but definitely not cheap.)
> This may lead people to think cloud storage is a waste of money, [...]
But that is exactly the argument being made -- that a trustless distributed system can substitute and obsolete cloud storage.
Then I respectfully disagree. I don't think cloud storage is always the best use case, but I do believe it is a good value for what it actually offers you. Backblaze B2 is my ideal marker for what a 'good value' in cloud storage should look like. At $5/mo per TB[1] it easily crushes the metric of monthly cost being less than equivalent non-redundant refurbished storage media.
> that a trustless distributed system can substitute and obsolete cloud storage.
OK, I have literally no qualifications to say that this isn't true. After all, what I am NOT claiming is that it can't be done for cheaper. What I AM claiming, is that without a service like Sia, it is certainly not going to be cheaper for common use cases of end users. I'm talking about comparing harddrives to services.
> Buyers are essentially paying Amazon each month the entire cost of the hard drives used to store their data
I still think though, that a compelling case could be made without bad comparisons or hyperbole. Which makes this more frustrating than it needs to be imo.
[1]: https://www.backblaze.com/b2/cloud-storage-pricing.html - Assuming I am not deeply mistaken.
The Author could have done it as the cost (for ownership) of a brand new NAS with 2x2 TB disk (which can be - just checked on tiger direct) around 350+65+65=480 US$ vs 6 months of 4 TB cloud storage 6x4x20=480, but the overall message would have been the same.
Imagine that you rent a car for 6 months and during the 6 months you pay rates equating the price of the car brand new.
And more importantly, if you're focused on storage then don't pay for features you don't need.
Sia is able to provide, at 1/10th the cost of Amazon, high throughput, high reliability, high redundancy, geographically distributed cloud storage, and it can do that without high reliability drives or datacenters.
There's no way refurb drives are cost effective for these environments.
Not saying you shouldn't, I'd probably do so as well. Curiously, there's no 6GB HGSTs over at Backblaze.
Also, very anecdotal, I know.
Because of such plagues, data-centre operators often mix drives of different manufacturers, models, batches and ages. Running heterogeneous devices in a redundant array helps makes the failure distribution more random so that the safety margin is less likely to be suddenly overwhelmed by correlated failures.
What a refurbished hard disk does not give you:
- Redundant storage
- Redundant power/network/etc.
- Geographic distribution
- A network API
- Any networking, or uplinks at all
- Access control
- A team ensuring the reliability and security of your data
- Global network of datacenters and pops
- Integration with other cloud services
All that and Amazon et al. do not store your 1TB of data in a single refurbished hard disk. This is beyond non-sense.
Sure, some of these costs are amortized, but I still think this is a lame comparison. If all you wanted was at-cost block storage with crappy reliability and speed, you could probably accomplish that in easier ways.