News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Putin Orders Russian Move to GNU/Linux by xentronium on Monday December 27, 2010 @02:04PM (#2043310)
There have been numerous attempts to move to open source in Russia. Most of them failed.

Example: Linux in schools.

1. Teachers don't know much about linux

2. Computers aren't fast enough to work with GNOME (which is default in most packages they install)

3. Kids don't get it. Open office is the only familiar-looking application there.

4. They won't be able to apply their skills anywhere

add: 5. Microsoft makes some generous discounts. Simply because something is worth more than nothing. Piracy is very widespread here (this part is changing on corporate level, though).

Re:Putin Orders Russian Move to GNU/Linux by huertanix on Monday December 27, 2010 @02:14PM (#2043344)
I can see those being setbacks, but on each point:

1. I'm not sure on the situation in Russia, but in the US, a lot of teachers don't know much about Windows or OS X either, but unless something breaks they wouldn't have to.

2. Gnome's memory footprint is rather large, sadly. Depending on whether the Russian authorities roll their own custom distro or image though, they could use XFCE instead.

3. As things move more towards the cloud, I think that kids would mostly just have to learn how to use a web browser. Those are mostly the same on all modern platforms.

4. Having to learn something new is not a useless skill. Being able to use more than one platform demonstrates the ability to adapt to change. That's a useful skill to have.

Re:Putin Orders Russian Move to GNU/Linux by sudont on Monday December 27, 2010 @02:34PM (#2043396)
I've worked in education, and if something in Windows breaks the teachers wouldn't know what to do anyway.

From Neal Stephenson:

Prospective station wagon buyer: "I know what you say is true...but...er...I don't know how to maintain a tank!"

Bullhorn: "You don't know how to maintain a station wagon either!"

Re:Putin Orders Russian Move to GNU/Linux by xentronium on Monday December 27, 2010 @02:38PM (#2043400)
Yup, every point is solvable. Thinking of how life changed between 2007 and now, I can imagine how in 2013 we'd have linux in bigger cities, but not earlier.

1. I believe you still need someone to maintain the system and someone to teach how to use it. This makes a requirement of at least one unix specialist (informatics teacher) per school. Takes a lot of time to train them but not impossible.

2. Probably faster hardware and unix specialists could make a distro fast enough for education (is edubuntu such a distro?)

3. Most schools have some crappy connection, though (128 kbit/s). Some schools don't have internet at all; however, those aren't very well equipped with computers anyway.

4. You're right. However, some people expect a person out of school to have some computer literacy and experience with whatever they use at work. And most of "them" use microsoft solutions for office.

5. I added a point to the initial comment. It is probably cheaper to have microsoft products now. Especially, considering support and retraining costs for open-sourced software.

Re:Putin Orders Russian Move to GNU/Linux by bad_user on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @10:23AM (#2045652)
1. we had a Linux specialist in a small town high-school in Eastern Europe in 1998, a time when we barely had Internet access

5. I never saw a comprehensive costs analysis of Windows versus Linux that wasn't sponsored by Microsoft, which makes me believe this is a myth perpetuated by people too conservative to change even small habits (if it wasn't for the social factor, I would home-school my child)

Re:Putin Orders Russian Move to GNU/Linux by ido on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @06:09AM (#2045179)

    2. Gnome's memory footprint is rather large, 
    sadly. 
It is?

I do quite a bit of work inside an ubuntu installation on VirtualBox that is setup for a maximum of 1gb ram and it seems to work fine (I haven't seen a computer with less than 1gb of RAM installed in years, but I've also never been to a Russian school, so who knows).

A default ubuntu installation with the gnome desktop loaded up shows about 800mb free out of that 1gb, and I am sure a nice chunk of those 200mb include stuff other than gnome.

Pretty sure it would be a bit sluggish at times, but it would probably still be very usable even if you only had 512mb of RAM.

Re:Putin Orders Russian Move to GNU/Linux by badwetter on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @01:20PM (#2046205)
Yeah I keep hearing this too, but it's not accurate now and probably hasn't for some time. I run Gnome/Debian on a Toshiba Laptop Satellite 1600 with 384 Mb of SDRam with Gnome running and Chromium WebBrowser v10, HTop shows 267/384 Mb being used. This is with Gnome/Metacity. With Gnome/Openbox it's even less.
Re:Putin Orders Russian Move to GNU/Linux by acqq on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @05:55PM (#2047153)
On my 256 MB notebook I wasn't able to install Ubuntu with Gnome. I could be that 384 MB is enough, as I had better luck with 512 MB computer. As far as I know Windows XP can install on 64 MB, that's six times less than 384 MB.
Re:Putin Orders Russian Move to GNU/Linux by ido on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @06:15PM (#2047230)
Yes, but practically how many of us use a computer with 64mb of ram (or even 256mb)?

Also, if you're ok with installing an older version of windows there is nothing stopping you from installing an older distribution of linux (I used linux on a 100Mhz Pentium with 16mb ram just fine back in the day).

Re:Putin Orders Russian Move to GNU/Linux by acqq on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @07:23PM (#2047448)
> there is nothing stopping you from installing an older distribution of linux

We argument here if Gnome needs "too much" memory so that you need a relatively new computer to use it, and I gave the arguments for that, narrowing down the amount of memory needed and comparing it with still very useful and widely used XP.

Re:Putin Orders Russian Move to GNU/Linux by ido on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @04:02AM (#2048338)
Yes, but a debian version from several years ago (with gnome!) is also still very useful and would probably not demand more resources than xp.

The question was - why is it legitimate in this argument to use an old version of windows but nut an old version of linux?

Re:Putin Orders Russian Move to GNU/Linux by acqq on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @09:17AM (#2048721)
> why is it legitimate in this argument to use an old version of windows but nut an old version of linux

Again, please don't change the topic, we are talking about Gnome, not about Linux in general. Linux kernel runs on my router with 16 MB RAM without any problems. Gnome is simply made without enough attention for configurations with limited resources, it's just so. There are other managers, of course. That's why huertanix mentioned XFCE.

See also:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_X_Window_System_d...

Footprints (at the time of the writing): GNOME: ~180 MB, Xfce: ~15 MB

Re:Putin Orders Russian Move to GNU/Linux by badwetter on Thursday December 30, 2010 @12:31AM (#2051353)
Should have tried Debian; they have an optional text based installer that probably would have enabled you to complete the install.
Re:Putin Orders Russian Move to GNU/Linux by trurl123 on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @03:56AM (#2045024)
1. There are many news about linux installation in schools. I don't mean Moscow. Most installation done in regions.

2. There are special packages for slow computers.

3. Kids are learning linux

4. Many entrepreneurs start to use linux on their companies. I saw it in shops and banks.

5. Microsoft is evil

Re:Putin Orders Russian Move to GNU/Linux by forgottenpaswrd on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @04:28AM (#2045067)
1. They don't know much about Windows, either.

2. If they are fast enough for Windows, they are fast enough for GNOME. If not, you can use light desktops like enlightenment.

3. Kids learn way waster than adults(I have worked with kids and Linux at the same time).

4.????? If things continue the way they are, Windows users are those that won't be able to apply their skills, you will need UNIX skills.

5.Also do Linux, who came almost free.

6. When your computer runs Windows or mac, NSA and three letters foreign agencies(for Russians) could tap any computer they want to steal industrial, military and political secrets as they are strategic interest for America.

7. Energy prices are going up, that means Russian economy is going up for the next 2, 3 years, they have money to do what they want.

Re:Putin Orders Russian Move to GNU/Linux by jawee on Monday December 27, 2010 @02:21PM (#2043363)
A country-wide move would make Linux being learnt in school much more useful. However, if the systems used in school are low powered and using software like, say, LXDE and then moving to Compiz-powered GNOME in situations where the specs work, would anything be accomplished?
Re:Putin Orders Russian Move to GNU/Linux by jackolas on Monday December 27, 2010 @03:31PM (#2043563)
Depends if real learning happened or just point and click zombification.
Re:Putin Orders Russian Move to GNU/Linux by ilya_b on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @10:21AM (#2045647)
January 1st, 2011 most of Microsoft products used in Russian schools will expire their licenses. No deals were made to prolong licenses.
Re:Putin Orders Russian Move to GNU/Linux by berntb on Monday December 27, 2010 @05:18PM (#2043824)
>>Microsoft makes some generous discounts. Simply because something is worth more than nothing.

Don't forget: The important part is to not open a niche for the use of an open O/S, where it can grow from.

(A historically good way to get really good rebates from MS has been to start talking about Linux. That might be what is going on here.)