Yes, but a debian version from several years ago (with gnome!) is also still very useful and would probably not demand more resources than xp.
The question was - why is it legitimate in this argument to use an old version of windows but nut an old version of linux?
Re:Putin Orders Russian Move to GNU/Linux
by acqq on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @09:17AM
(#2048721)
> why is it legitimate in this argument to use an old version of windows but nut an old version of linux
Again, please don't change the topic, we are talking about Gnome, not about Linux in general. Linux kernel runs on my router with 16 MB RAM without any problems. Gnome is simply made without enough attention for configurations with limited resources, it's just so. There are other managers, of course. That's why huertanix mentioned XFCE.
See also:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_X_Window_System_d...
Footprints (at the time of the writing): GNOME: ~180 MB, Xfce: ~15 MB
We argument here if Gnome needs "too much" memory so that you need a relatively new computer to use it, and I gave the arguments for that, narrowing down the amount of memory needed and comparing it with still very useful and widely used XP.