Try the Sansa clip. Literally half the price, or quadruple the capacity for the same price. And you even get the most premium of luxuries: a display.
Thing is, I don't want a display. My current shuffle (2 gens old) is completely beat to hell (visible scratches and gashes) but still works great at the gym, running, hiking, in the sauna, actually playing basketball with it on, etc... I'm pretty sure any display would have been cracked or destroyed by this point. The Sansa clip is also bigger than the shuffle.
I know I'm a very specific case, but for me the shuffle is exactly what I need.
I really like the matchbook, clip type shuffles for working out. They are super light, pretty much indestructible and have a built in clip.