They could still withhold the interest until you provide the SSN in the uncommon case that both of those are satisfied, but that should be very uncommon indeed because if you have enough money to reach the reporting threshold, you would make more investing it in even low risk securities, so only foolish or extremely conservative people should ever have done that.
(And if we want to go into a different policy discussion, you wouldn't need SSNs at all if we would switch to VAT+UBI, because then there is no income tax, the UBI handles making it progressive, and the VAT is handled by the selling business, so there is no need to track anyone's personal dealings whatsoever.)
That would lead to the bank needing to get your SSN on an existing account when you made a deposit. That seems... messy.