Re:The world needs topsoil to grow 95% of its food – but it'...
by m0llusk on Friday July 12, 2019 @09:28AM
(#20420507)
Topsoil loss is a major problem for the environment, but it is worth pointing out that we do not need topsoil to grow food. We have hydroponics and aeroponics and a range of other solutions that do not use land in traditional ways. There is also reason to believe that an increasing fraction of our food will be grown in this way rather than on the land if only because the vast majority of farmable land is already farmed.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The world needs topsoil to grow 95% of its food – but it'...
by jasonlaramburu on Friday July 12, 2019 @10:21AM
(#20420929)
Only crops that are mostly water (lettuce, tomatoes) can be economically grown hydroponically. We need topsoil to grow cereals (corn, wheat etc).
Re:The world needs topsoil to grow 95% of its food – but it'...
by aliswe on Friday July 12, 2019 @11:20AM
(#20421327)
It's not the water content per se I think, most herbs thrive in this medium as well. Most probably the crops' price and growing speed are the deciding factors.
Oh, and check this anecdote out: https://www.thenational.ae/uae/from-paddy-fields-to-uae-dese...
Re:The world needs topsoil to grow 95% of its food – but it'...
by randyrand on Friday July 12, 2019 @12:49PM
(#20422120)
Once topsoil is depleted, the economics change drastically.
Point is, we won’t starve. But we will need to expend more resources gathering food.
Re:The world needs topsoil to grow 95% of its food – but it'...
by DocTomoe on Friday July 12, 2019 @10:27AM
(#20420979)
Given that cereals tend to not be too good for us ... maybe we should limit them anyways?
Re:The world needs topsoil to grow 95% of its food – but it'...
by jasonlaramburu on Friday July 12, 2019 @11:06AM
(#20421226)
Perhaps but we also use cereals and row crops to feed livestock (corn), make vegetarian protein (soybeans, canola, wheat) and make our clothes (cotton). None of these can be grown hydroponically.
Re:The world needs topsoil to grow 95% of its food – but it'...
by wampwamp on Friday July 12, 2019 @01:14PM
(#20422353)
Hemp gives you all those things and grows extremely well hydroponically.
Re:The world needs topsoil to grow 95% of its food – but it'...
by nate_meurer on Friday July 12, 2019 @04:17PM
(#20424099)
More importantly, hemp grows well in poor soils.
Re:The world needs topsoil to grow 95% of its food – but it'...
by pizzazzaro on Friday July 12, 2019 @09:49AM
(#20420690)
Where do you think the plants' nutrients come from in those growing methods? Petrochemical plants also set to run out of resources. You're adorable.
Look at permaculture food forests and how they rebuild topsoil. While we still can.
Re:The world needs topsoil to grow 95% of its food – but it'...
by aliswe on Friday July 12, 2019 @11:22AM
(#20421343)
That's exceptionally snarky... Btw, are you implying that the aquaponic nutrient additives come from topsoil?
Re:The world needs topsoil to grow 95% of its food – but it'...
by pizzazzaro on Friday July 12, 2019 @08:06PM
(#20425636)
Mostly? We mine minerals and refine them with:
Petrochemical sources.
Which, you might also worry about running out of, in about as short order as topsoil.
There was another commenter here with more expertise on actually growing things this way - they suggested that leafy greens were the only thing we could grow efficiently with this method. Which does have a certain air of "truthiness" to it.