Re:Developers don't understand CORS
by icebraining on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @03:23PM
(#20405482)
On the contrary: CORS is what enables other sites to use your resources (in a way allowed by your policy). It was created because, by default, browsers don't let you do that.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I think what GP commented is a very common misconception. CORS is not the source of the developer trouble (that would be cross-origin restrictions), it is a way around them. But it is perhaps understandable where the confusion comes from... Browsers always mention CORS headers as part of error messages, after all.
+1 - This is a large part of the trouble. It leads to a lot of stuff being defined as the inverse of some other behavior - behavior that the developer does not have control or understanding of.
But only one domain at a time. The lack of a way to specify multiple domains in a header makes it absurdly painful to actually implement when you want to make your content available to a specific set of domains.
I’m personally at the point where I’d rather handle unnecessary request authentication than trying to do anything with CORS.
Re:Developers don't understand CORS
by icebraining on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @08:31PM
(#20408014)
I'm curious, why was it painful? We just had a middleware do an Origin check and copy the header if it matches.
90+ microservices with 5+ environments. Mostly a matter of scaling a solution across a rather large surface area and across a number of languages and teams.
Re:Developers don't understand CORS
by icebraining on Friday July 12, 2019 @06:50AM
(#20419685)
Fair enough; seems like it could be done using a gateway like Kong, but if you're not already using one, it wouldn't be worth adding it just for that.