News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Self-destructing mosquitoes and sterilized rodents: the p... by coldtea on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @04:48AM (#20400257)
Food shortages, ecosystem mayhem, huge disease toll: the promise of gene drives from an improvising rush-it-for-profit "science" that still e.g. can't eradicate the common cold and misses tons of basics (until recently they thought "junk dna" was useless) but is confident to play the sorcerer's apprentice...
Re:Self-destructing mosquitoes and sterilized rodents: the p... by TeMPOraL on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @05:49AM (#20400506)
> improvising rush-it-for-profit "science" that still e.g. can't eradicate the common cold and misses tons of basics (until recently they thought "junk dna" was useless) but is confident to play the sorcerer's apprentice

Do you seriously believe that? Do you completely ignore all the things the 'rush-it-for-profit "science"' done right in the past centuries, and the benefits you personally derive from that?

It's like saying that progress is bullshit because we still don't have hoverboards[0]. It turns out that some of the things we can easily conceptualize are hard, whereas some not immediately obvious things are easy, both in engineering and science.

--

[0] - the real kind, not the name-appropriating Li-Ion fire starters on two wheels.

Re:Self-destructing mosquitoes and sterilized rodents: the p... by coldtea on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @06:43AM (#20400723)
>Do you seriously believe that?

100%.

>Do you completely ignore all the things the 'rush-it-for-profit "science"' done right in the past centuries, and the benefits you personally derive from that?

Do you completely strawman my argument? Who said anything about me "completely ignoring"? Who said all science is "rush-it-for-profit"? Who said all science had the same amount of ignorance and potential dangerous impact?

For one, science was not as much a "for profit" endeavor back in the day, scientists were more often than not independently wealthy or unconcerned with industry (which was still underdeveloped anyway until the 20th century). Nowadays they are mostly salaried employees of major industries.

Second, earlier industrial uses of science had much smaller potential for rapid disruptive impact across the globe compared to custom gene editing of various species.

And even with that, there were still unintended consequences, from idiotic companies suggesting radioactive substances for toothpastes, soap, and other household items as beneficial [1], to the obesity epidemic (food science), to climate change.

If billions are displaced/die from climate change, the verdict of the ultimate utility of those generations living large off of the future, and the "greatness" of all those industrial uses, might still not be favorable.

>It's like saying that progress is bullshit because we still don't have hoverboards[0].

No, it's like saying things have a tradeoff, and blindly accepting everything shining because it's "made with science" is neither scientific nor wise. Science != technology, and science and technology != necessity for commercial applications.

We can study things and invent stuff, without necessarily making them into sellable products, or rushing them to make a profit without understanding their impact. Novel idea huh?

[1] https://www.popsci.com/scitech/article/2004-08/healthy-glow-...

Re:Self-destructing mosquitoes and sterilized rodents: the p... by nosianu on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @05:06AM (#20400330)
I'm not sure you want to eradicate the common cold.

I myself had had mercury poisoning (I wrote about that in other posts, treated with chelators with great positive effect). I noticed A) that the numbers of colds I had and their severity and duration are greatly reduced down to almost nothing. It was that just before I was diagnosed I was afraid of catching a cold in fall/winter because it would stay with me until May without ever going away.

During the recovery and treatment I noticed that every time I had a cold there was especially great activity exactly in the places where I had the most issues (in non-cold times), and that when it was gone I felt a lot better than before. I came to suspect, and now firmly believe after having gone through this a few times, that the colds helped the healing (and getting out whatever needed to get out). I think there are other indications as well that mild disease like the cold has beneficial impacts(?).

What if you eradicate a really mild inconvenience only to find out that that was actually a bad idea?

Re:Self-destructing mosquitoes and sterilized rodents: the p... by coldtea on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @06:45AM (#20400729)
>What if you eradicate a really mild inconvenience only to find out that that was actually a bad idea?

By "eradicate" in my argument one could easily substitute "understand the common cold".

My argument was basically about control and understanding -- I mentioned "have not yet eradicated the common cold" as a proxy for "doesn't yet even understand and control something so commonly occurring and heavily studied as that" (including not knowing whether eradicating it is good or not).

Re:Self-destructing mosquitoes and sterilized rodents: the p... by thrownaway954 on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @07:19AM (#20400879)
Thanos did nothing wrong. our population needs to be cut in half. it's simple... get a vasectomy (or your tubes ties) and don't have kids. in 20 years the problem will correct itself.
Re:Self-destructing mosquitoes and sterilized rodents: the p... by Communitivity on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @08:02AM (#20401115)
I don't think this will result in a good effect.

The people who are conscientious will not have kids, while the others will have kids. As a result the next generation will be more likely to be less conscientious due to nature, and nurture.

I think the solution is education, and specifically, education about ethics and conservation. If we make the next generation feel obligated to be stewards of the earth, and smart enough to act on that obligation, then the human race has a chance. But it has to happen with this generation being born now, or we won't have the time to save Earth without leaving it first - one way or another.

Re:Self-destructing mosquitoes and sterilized rodents: the p... by coldtea on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @08:56AM (#20401481)
>The people who are conscientious will not have kids, while the others will have kids.

That's easy to solve (technically):

a) enforce a "max 1 child per couple" policy for all couples (for as long as needed).

b) or force-sterilize half of the population but randomly (not by their own choice).

Re:Self-destructing mosquitoes and sterilized rodents: the p... by astazangasta on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @01:21PM (#20404119)
Thanos doesn't understand exponential growth. If you actually want to have an effect, cutting a population in half does nothing, it'll just grow back in whatever the doubling time is, probably on the order of decades; you need to decimate or eradicate.
Re:Self-destructing mosquitoes and sterilized rodents: the p... by coldtea on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @08:54AM (#20401470)
Well, 20% of the population (e.g. US and Western Europe say) has the 80% of environmental impact. Including e.g. Chinese factories population etc (most of the production there is for western consumers anyway).

And even 200% the current population could have 10% the current carbon impact (with the appropriate lifestyle adjustments, e.g. green energy, much less consumption, less planned obsolesce, less meat, less greedy corporatism, less international travel, etc.).

So, no, population is not really the problem at the moment (besides it's declining anyway).