News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Updates Air, Pro Laptops, Kills Off the MacBook by SilasX on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @07:08PM (#20397695)
I also hate that MacBook Pro touchpads are oversized and easy to touch with your thumbs by accident. I had one issued for a job and had annoying, error-inducing swipes about three times a day.
Re:Apple Updates Air, Pro Laptops, Kills Off the MacBook by farisjarrah on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @07:12PM (#20397711)
You complained about the best part of the Macbook, the trackpad! I wish I could get that Mac trackpad on my thinkpad x1
Re:Apple Updates Air, Pro Laptops, Kills Off the MacBook by pcr0 on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @07:22PM (#20397785)
As a user of both the Macbook Pro and the X1 Carbon, I have to agree. The MBP touchpad handles gestures and palm rejection really well. On the other hand I get accidental swipes every hour with the X1 Carbon that I can only bear using its keyboard in an emergency. FWIW I have oversized hands.

However, I do overshoot and tap the MBP touchbar now and then, which can be annoying.

Re:Apple Updates Air, Pro Laptops, Kills Off the MacBook by SllX on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @07:24PM (#20397795)
Unless you are really good at keeping your hands off the trackpad when you rest your hands, the previous generation trackpad was overall better in day to day use, and anything bigger is better as an external peripheral.

The problem is, Apple’s palm rejection tech just isn’t good enough, and if you have to write fancy software to cover a deficiency in the size of a piece of hardware, then you’re better off going with the smaller size. I’m assuming without the palm rejection, it would be an even bigger issue, and I wouldn’t trust any OEMs to get that right.

That said, it is only comparatively worse than the previous generation of Apple’s laptop trackpads which was already enormous, and arguably enormous enough. Compared to other laptops from other vendors, I could definitely see the appeal.

Re:Apple Updates Air, Pro Laptops, Kills Off the MacBook by hombre_fatal on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @07:56PM (#20397981)
The palm rejection tech is so good that I can't recall a single time I ever accidentally triggered it. In fact, it was so good I didn't even consider that it had palm rejection tech until I read about it, I just never considered that it was a problem.
Re:Apple Updates Air, Pro Laptops, Kills Off the MacBook by geerlingguy on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @09:56PM (#20398567)
Ditto. Every time I use someone else’s laptop, or my Dell XPS, I feel like either I turned into some giant, or the trackpad got zapped by a shrink ray. The giant trackpad is probably the best thing about the recent MBPs.
Re:Apple Updates Air, Pro Laptops, Kills Off the MacBook by asdff on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @10:20AM (#20402170)
YMMV. People have different palms. Sometimes when it's cold or my hands are a little clammy not even my index finger registers on the track pad or my phone.
Re:Apple Updates Air, Pro Laptops, Kills Off the MacBook by jchb on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @09:16PM (#20398381)
> Apple’s palm rejection tech just isn’t good enough

Must be something wrong with your palms ;) I have never thought about this issue, but reading these comments I tried it out. I can't move the mouse cursor with my palms, it is virtually impossible. The "Apple palm rejection tech" is really good. Data point from a Mac Book Pro, 2017.

Re:Apple Updates Air, Pro Laptops, Kills Off the MacBook by SilasX on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @09:02PM (#20398318)
>The problem is, Apple’s palm rejection tech just isn’t good enough, and if you have to write fancy software to cover a deficiency in the size of a piece of hardware, then you’re better off going with the smaller size.

Subtle jab at the Boeing 737 MAX?

(Just noticed I have a similar username.)

Re:Apple Updates Air, Pro Laptops, Kills Off the MacBook by b212 on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @07:22PM (#20397783)
But they were perfect until 2015, making them bigger is a downgrade IMO as well. What’s the point of huge trackpad on a 13–15 inch screen?
Re:Apple Updates Air, Pro Laptops, Kills Off the MacBook by doctat on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @07:18PM (#20397751)
Maybe if they centered the damm thing with regard to where your hands rest, vs the center of the laptop.

As it is now, the trackpad is shifted significantly to the right - so much so that my right Palm is constantly triggering it.

I’m basically forced to use a mouse and disable the trackpad while the mouse is connected.

Yet another aesthetic choice that screws up functionality..

Re:Apple Updates Air, Pro Laptops, Kills Off the MacBook by jchw on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @08:13PM (#20398079)
I can’t stand using Any trackpad, but the huge Mac one literally deters me from buying a Macbook. I am very much sold on Trackpoint, which I find to be all of conveniently positioned, not nearly as accident prone, and quite precise. Some also don’t realize this, but if you hold the middle button while pointing the trackpoint, it scrolls, which is super useful; I hardly have to move my hands to operate the pointer. A lot of people with aversion to trackpoint can be seen doing odd things, like scrubbing across it like its a mouse or trackpad. Once you get past these issues, which unfortunately does represent a learning curve, it’s quite good in my opinion.

My take: I think the touchbar and giant touchpad are both symptoms of Apple’s aversion to put a touchscreen on the Mac. With many Thinkpads and other PC laptops, you may not get quite as good of a touchpad experience (though Microsoft Precision Touchpad is a pretty good experience I would argue,) but my touchscreen experience with even Linux has been pretty good in recent years, and it has ended up being a useful, if not quite killer, feature to have.

Touchbar makes little sense to me. Power users don’t look down at their keyboards. I think the same reason Valve dropped the screen on the Steam controller applies to keyboards, and is probably part of the reason why similar visual keyboard utilities have largely not sold well. Interestingly, ones that have, like the Streamdeck, are often designed to be positioned on a much more convenient angle. On top of all of this, it didn’t seem worth getting rid of the useful fixed-position keys for a programmable bar.

And on top of everything... I don’t even think Apple has made the most compelling innovative designs in this space anyways. PC laptop manufacturers have been trying arguably more interesting and possibly even more useful concepts for a while to varying degrees of success. For example, MSI has a keyboard where the number pad is a programmable touchscreen. I believe ASUS has a laptop where instead of a touchbar, you get 3 small desktops that you can pin things to. Granted, none of these things are likely to stick in the long term, but I also believe the touchbar won’t either.

I think I get why Apple does not want to put a touchscreen on Mac: the interface isn’t really designed for it. But as much as I have a strong dislike of Windows 10s propensity to install Candy Crush without my consent, I will also concede and say it does a seriously excellent job handling a touchscreen on a desktop. It’s a shame that it will take so long to clean up decades of UI cruft, but even with it, Windows turns out to be a good experience with a touchscreen so as long as you have another precise pointing method simultaneously.

So after all is said and done, and contrary to probably many people’s sensibilities, I actually think the PC laptop market is doing peripherals better, even if the touchpad drivers can be a bummer.

Re:Apple Updates Air, Pro Laptops, Kills Off the MacBook by fossuser on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @08:27PM (#20398154)
Apple's trackpads are in a class of their own and their large size is a feature given how good they are.

I also liked the trackpoint when I had a thinkpad, but I think Apple's trackpads are better. The trackpoint is nice, but can hurt your knuckle after a while (and I'd argue it's not quite as fast).

Re:Apple Updates Air, Pro Laptops, Kills Off the MacBook by jchw on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @09:50PM (#20398543)
Actually, it’s simpler than that: I really mean I can’t handle trackpads. Something about the angle causes me weird issues, especially with multitouch gestures; it’s a weird kind of hypersensitivity. This is even despite that Apple trackpads are glass.

I don’t have any issue with trackpoint hurting my knuckle, though I will concede it may not be as fast. I still have a surprisingly good time hitting precise targets with it, though.

Re:Apple Updates Air, Pro Laptops, Kills Off the MacBook by skyyler on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @07:20PM (#20397763)
It absolutely boggles my mind that people can't keep in mind that everyone has different preferences.

It's not the best part of the Macbook, it's your favourite part of the Macbook.

There very rarely is an objective best in anything. There is only what you like and need.

Re:Apple Updates Air, Pro Laptops, Kills Off the MacBook by hombre_fatal on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @07:57PM (#20397990)
Right, but they were already making that point themselves. The comment they responded to literally hated the feature. They pointed out, okay, but it's my favorite feature.
Re:Apple Updates Air, Pro Laptops, Kills Off the MacBook by truncate on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @08:05PM (#20398033)
So, I use Dell XPS 13 personally, and when I got MacBook Pro 15 2018 model, I was super unhappy with size of trackpad. It took a while, but I got used to it and now prefer over my XPS-13 trackpad.

The trackpad was always amazing (force touch, sensitivity, palm detection and all), but I think the extra size makes doing gestures super smooth. As in, my fingers don't feel constrained.

Re:Apple Updates Air, Pro Laptops, Kills Off the MacBook by asdff on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @10:23AM (#20402205)
That's probably the one common mbp gripe you can actually fix yourself. Tape up the perimeter and enjoy your brand new regularly sized trackpad.
Re:Apple Updates Air, Pro Laptops, Kills Off the MacBook by pcr0 on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @07:19PM (#20397755)
Does this happen while typing? Do you touch-type?
Re:Apple Updates Air, Pro Laptops, Kills Off the MacBook by NeedMoreTea on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @07:23PM (#20397792)
It used to happen constantly to me whilst touch typing on a 2016, yet is extremely rare to never on the 2015 MBP I replaced it with. So annoying to keep having something trigger whilst just typing something.

It was 2 broken keyboards in 6 or 7 months that had me sell and replace it though, but damn that massive touchpad was awful.

Re:Apple Updates Air, Pro Laptops, Kills Off the MacBook by SilasX on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @07:31AM (#20400928)
Yes and yes.