News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On the Homogenizing Dangers of Easily Translated Literatu... by yorwba on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @08:45AM (#20391162)
The mentioned difficulties do not appear to actually be due to translation, but instead due to lacking the background to appreciate a given work as worth reading.

> Zoku meian [Light and Darkness continued], is a tour de force in which she creates a very plausible, stylistically pitch-perfect ending to Meian [Light and Darkness], the last, unfinished masterpiece by Natsume Sōseki, Japan’s most important modern novelist.

...

> As a fragmentary, dependent work, standing in relation to a classic text that is largely unknown outside Japan except to a handful of experts, it is, in effect, impossible to render into comprehensible English or, for that matter, any other language

If "Light and Darkness continued" had been written as a continuation of an English translation of Meian, it is likely that it would have failed to gather any significant readership except translated into Japanese as Zoku meian. That's simply due to targeting an audience that is already familiar with Meian and might pay attention to a well-written continuation.

A similar problem arises for Star Wars novelizations, without any translation involved. Being invested into the universe that serves as backdrop for the story is essentially a prerequisite for becoming a reader. If you tried to "translate" an English Star Wars novel for the English mass market, you'd fail the same as when translating a novel full of Japanese cultural references for the same market.

The "homogenizing danger" then isn't so much about writing to be translated, but about writing to be read by the largest possible number of readers, be it in translation or not. Other literature can exist, but you shouldn't expect it to get popular outside a small niche. Sometimes the niches are separated by language boundaries, other times they're not. I'd assume translated Star Wars novels to also appeal to Japanese Star Wars fans, for example.

Re:On the Homogenizing Dangers of Easily Translated Literatu... by nerdponx on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @09:24AM (#20391429)
Maybe this is just coming from my background as an academic and general nerd, but personally I would rather read a book that I don't fully understand, but had lots of notes and references to explain the context, than something that's been conceptually "translated".
Re:On the Homogenizing Dangers of Easily Translated Literatu... by Chestofdraw on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @10:55AM (#20392371)
As a general nerd I feel like this is a common experience and one that I've quite enjoyed when reading countless sci-fi/fantasy books.

You start of and many cultural references or things seem completely alien and only start to click once you're part way through.

Re:On the Homogenizing Dangers of Easily Translated Literatu... by gowld on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @12:12PM (#20393308)
Why not enjoy both? Son you enjoy the "flow" of reading a book that is within your grasp?