And this is one of those situations. There are multiple ways that the real Satoshi could prove their identity, but somehow, Craig Wright has either lost of of them, or they're locked up in some strange escrow with a super-secret board of lawyers or some such nonsense.
Occam's Razor. If ever there was a good application of the principle, it's here.
Also, Craig Wright doesn't have the technical understanding to have written the Bitcoin implementation. Listen to him speak. If you're honest with yourself, and if you code, you'll realize that he's likely never written much running code at all, much less a full implementation of a complex cryptographic and network protocol.
But these are the kinds of guys who unfortunately make it past interviews on the strength of their "dazzle'em with bullshit" approach to interviewing, and that have caused the current situation where most of us have to spend months reviewing our DS and algorithms notes before new interviews.
This is an important observation. Craig gives himself away every time he presents at a conference. His talks just throw up a bunch impressive technical jargon and graphics, but then completely fail to weave it all together into a coherent whole, leaving only a disjointed mess.
It fools people who aren't watching closely and thinking critically. But Satoshi Nakamoto being possibly one of the greatest connectors and integrators of disparate technical ideas in our time, Craig Wright he is not.
Most of his proof has been systematically proven to be forged or unverified.
> That seems to be the justification for hate.
You're confusing hate with lack of trust.
> What happened to innocent until proven guilty?
It's very much playing itself out in front of you. "Innocent" isn't the same thing as lack of accusation. In the court of public opinion: He's accused of making fraudulent claims. He defends himself. His arguments are shown to be invalid.
I'm sure Bernie Madoff had some good ideas and nice things to say.
> Most of his proof has been systematically proven to be forged or unverified.
If someone fails to prove A that does not mean that (not A) is true
> You're confusing hate with lack of trust.
You are right, hate is a very strong word that I should not have used in this context.
> It's very much playing itself out in front of you. "Innocent" isn't the same thing as lack of accusation. In the court of public opinion: He's accused of making fraudulent claims. He defends himself. His arguments are shown to be invalid.
I'm really not that interested in what the court of public opinion thinks, I'm more interested in the truth. The truth is that I don't know if he is Satoshi or not, neither do you or anybody else here. Yet everybody is assuming that without question. The word fraud occurs 21 times in this threat, in almost all cases without qualification. I would expect more from the HN community.
Here's a good analysis of Craig's own testimony from last week and the inconsistencies:
https://blog.wizsec.jp/2019/07/kleiman-v-craig-wright-part-3...
> I'm more interested in the truth
The only way he is telling the truth is if an enormous number of claims is a massive conspiracy theory.
> The truth is that I don't know if he is Satoshi or not
You don't know I'm not Satoshi. I don't have to prove it:
> If someone fails to prove A that does not mean that (not A) is true
> I would expect more from the HN community.
True. We do have a habit of hero worship (ie Jobs, Musk, etc) so perhaps we should similarly believe Wright just because he said to.
not to mention satoshi himself wished people wouldn't obsess over who he is, and rather think more about the larger team of people behind bitcoin's development, according to a post of his.
fraudulent proof is proof of fraud. you have to play mental mind games to believe there's a case for him being satoshi. all it takes is 30 seconds of basic logical thinking.
people who believe he could be satoshi are the reason the cryptocurrency community is so awful.
If I said I invented cold fusion, would you ask me to prove it first, or give me 300 million in venture capital?
He is not particular good in public appearances but to claim that he is an obvious fraud and he possesses no technical knowledge is just wrong. Also he did convince a few very knowledgable technical people.
Then there is his claim to be Satoshi. At this point, nobody knows if that is true or not. Yet everybody is acting as if they _knew_ he is a liar and a fraud. That seems to be the justification for hate. What happened to innocent until proven guilty?
My take is: I do not know if he is Satoshi or not. I also do not care. I listen to want he thinks about Bitcoin and I like what I hear.