* HFT firms will pay for it if the latency is lower
* Online gamers that play with other people around the globe would also probably be willing to pay to get their ping down.
* Maybe they could have a LEO CDN.
* People like me who travel a lot would be willing to pay for it. It would be especially sweet if I could somehow ditch my phone plan and just have global satellite coverage and use VOIP via Google Voice or something.
Your other points have nothing to do with my HFT specific comment.
StarLink doesn't exist yet, and when it does, it doesn't seem unreasonable to think that two satellite constellation providers could serve the HFT market and both be profitable.
It's going to be a bit more, for a bit better latency.
Your comments are predicated on the assumption that this internet service is going to be significantly more expensive than existing fiber subscriptions, and therefore needs many benefits to outweigh the increased cost. But I have seen no reason to believe that this will be the case. Every statement I've seen indicates that these services will be quite competitive on price.