Nuclear power was invented. A few nuclear accidents happen. The solution was to put more regulation in place. Regulation increases costs and limits reactor designs (large plants, conservative / pre-existing design).
End result? It's impossible to build "safer" reactors, because they're economically uncompetitive under the regulatory burden designed for older reactors. And the regulations never change because no one builds anything but old-style reactors.
I understand the DoE and other similar organizations have prototype programs, but from results evaluation they seem to have gaps in the path to production.
Essentially, we're letting 1960s nuclear fear of 1960s reactor designs write our regulations instead of science.
If you want nuclear, you want punitive carbon taxes, or carbon trading with low caps.
I think this is the crux of the issue. Carbon-emitting plants get a free pass on safety and long-term environmental costs, while for nuclear all those things are examined with a fine-tooth comb, then compared to the cost of alternatives without those things.
In any regulatory regime that punished carbon emission the same way it did nuclear waste, nuclear contamination, etc, then coal plants would be unthinkable.
I was going to say "then nuclear would be obvious", but I'll hold judgement there because I don't know how that would compare to other non-carbon-emitting sources (hydro, solar, etc).
That doesn't mean they are less bad than nuclear plants but the claim that they are unsafe is just wrong.
By shifting the regulatory cost from focusing on lesser risks to catastrophic ones, you could make fundamentally safer reactor designs economically competitive while still retaining the primary political goals (avoidance of major event).
I'm concerned but not running around screaming if a reactor leaks tritium. I'm very much the latter if a reactor goes prompt critical.
In the same way I wouldn't offer SR-71 insurance.
That feels like a dodge on the part of regulators.
https://www.versicherungsforen.at/portal/media/forschung/stu...
Thanks for the pointer! Will be an interesting read.
This is fairly cheap, a few hundred million, and in terms of safety it's a no brainer, because the US already has nuclear waste that needs long-term storage.
If this can't be solved, it seems almost pointless to dream of new reactors.
I have to wonder why burial was being pushed so hard, so early. Maybe they were worried surface repositories would be targets for ground burst nukes in WW3?
Left on its own, halted thermal reactor generates hundreds MW of heat after shutdown. That heat destroys cladding of fuel, generates explosive Hydrogen and causes meltdowns of former core.
It is believed that ATF, core catchers and electricity-independent passive cooling will reduce risk of this types of incidents, commonly called LOCA - Loss of coolant
The engineers were very optimistic about selling this even as small municipal thermal power plants (for heating water) very close to city centers. The idea of passive safety is quite beatiful, but it seems no PIUS reactors were produced. Rosatom seems to have had some success.
More info about PIUS can be found at
https://www.iaea.org/sites/default/files/publications/magazi...
https://www.euronuclear.org/e-news/e-news-17/nps-kth.htm