meanwhile, coal powerplants are spewing out co2, heavy metals, and radioactive particles during normal operation.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-level_radioactive_waste_m...
> There is a debate over what should constitute an acceptable scientific and engineering foundation for proceeding with radioactive waste disposal strategies. There are those who have argued, on the basis of complex geochemical simulation models, that relinquishing control over radioactive materials to geohydrologic processes at repository closure is an acceptable risk. They maintain that so-called "natural analogues" inhibit subterranean movement of radionuclides, making disposal of radioactive wastes in stable geologic formations unnecessary. However, existing models of these processes are empirically underdetermined: due to the subterranean nature of such processes in solid geologic formations, the accuracy of computer simulation models has not been verified by empirical observation, certainly not over periods of time equivalent to the lethal half-lives of high-level radioactive waste. On the other hand, some insist deep geologic repositories in stable geologic formations are necessary. National management plans of various countries display a variety of approaches to resolving this debate.
We're the species that used x-ray machines in shoe shops, to sell more shoes than the other guy. We put the guy who discovered the usefulness of washing hands into an asylum, out of sheer pride and arrogance. So great, we have a bunch of "complex models", and that's what we want to gamble it on? The weather forecast also keeps getting more accurate, but few people would bet their own life on the forecast for even tomorrow. But we'll do it on behalf of people who don't get a say?
Meanwhile, nuclear waste can be buried in a mountain with today’s technology, taking up only a very small portion of our planet to house it. Nuclear disaster zones like Chernobyl have, after only a few decades, been considered to have turned into nature reserves where animals and plants are flourishing, while global climate change caused by the carbon dioxide released by coal plants is expected to have all sorts of bad effects on nature. http://www.bbc.com/earth/story/20160421-the-chernobyl-exclus...
Reactor tech is 40 years old. If your phone is 4 years old, one might consider it trash. Imagine how good they'd be if the industry innovated even as slow and conservatively as medicine. Oh, there's also liquid sodium and fast breeders.
FUD keeps the tech from advancing.
I'm talking about today and the facts, saying "we found a solution" is simply ignoring everything.
Source: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integral_fast_reactor
Ps. China heavly invests in this technology now and its not even new.
>Coal needs to go >Nuclear needs to go >High energy (even unsubsidized gasoline) is politically untenable >Economic deprrssion from 1 and 2 is not tolerable, also
Not in programming, building things, or running society.
This isn't some cost/benefit stuff. Single use plastics and building concrete urban blight isn't worth a mass Extinction and global dieoff event. Especially with things like carbon negative concrete available. Not the same thing
It's bad solutions, when good ones are available, at massive scale, to address things that either aren't problems or could be addressed in other ways.
Getting rid of them therefore won't cause economic depression, just affect the profits of specific well connected people, so they'll hang around longer than they should.
It's so prominent its given as an example on the Wikipedia page for regulatory capture.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture#Nuclear_R...
US is a net coal exporter. If we were 100% nuclear the mining would be the same and it'd be exported.
Not a solution.
Instead, Swanson's curve should have been accelerated pushing the cost economics of solar to have made it competitive at an earlier date. Then you wouldn't need global legislative compliance, it'd have been cheaper earlier
Also, there's more to power than coal and nuclear
For example Molten salt reactors have proved to be quite effective back in the 60s already. I wonder why this doesn't get more attention.
https://www.opensecrets.org/industries/indus.php?ind=E
That, and a lot of misinformation. Like believing that driving is safer than flying.
Certainly more than 500, since that's how many were conducted. We're still here.
A choice needs to be made, and I'd argue that we're better at mitigating Chernobyl and Fukushima than we are about mitigating global warming, or convincing everyone that we don't need industry.
Utterly wrong.
https://www.nrc.gov/about-nrc/radiation/related-info/faq.htm...
You get more radiation living in a brick house
http://www.neis.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Its-the-water...
But to be fair I only consider our inability to build reactors cost efficiently (less disruptive cooling systems cost more $$$) to be the major roadblock to nuclear power. Just look at every HN submission regarding nuclear power. The vast majority of posters are in favor of nuclear power. So where exactly is the political opposition? I only see coal dependent communities as roadblocks but every non coal technology shares this problem.
This is true in so many ways. This is why a lot of nuclear advocates are pushing for a non-pressurized water reactor designs like molten salt reactors. In addition to not needing to place reactors in locations with lots of water, we also reduce the damage to waterways from waste heat and water intakes.
Radiation is not a strawman if it's what preventing the technology from taking off due to pop fear.
And please don't tell me you plan to sell wind/solar to China/India
‘Safety’ has to be considered in the context of mitigation options as well as options to correct problems. It’s the latter that lets down nuclear - Chernobyl and Fukushima have shown we just can’t contain and correct the effects when things go wrong.
Until we as a race figure out how to do that, nuclear will remain dangerous in my view.