Technological answer: This just sounds like proof of work with extra steps. It isn't inherently any more efficient or faster, and it's vulnerable to centralization in all the exact same ways.
However, to your point, it does replace a dependence on ASICs with a dependency on the HDD supply chain.
All these efforts to limit bitcoin’s energy expenditure seem environmentally motivated, which is good. But the arguments seem equivalent to praising a safe’s security but criticizing how hard it is to open. Those features are linked.
Yes proof of stake or some other algorithm may take over eventually but we don’t know if they are as secure yet. Proof of work is the good idea that made the whole bubble possible and it remains to be seen if any of the other ideas can beat it.
Rather, my original question was why Proof-of-Capacity has not seen stronger adoption given that it appears to provide similar security guarantees with better decentralization properties due to a lower $/W/block cost profile.
Ok, but a "block" is not a set amount of value or effort, is it? The way I thought Bitcoin and anything similar works is that the resource requirements are adjusted in a feedback loop. If some other scheme is 10x more "efficient", then whatever the operation is that is required, it will just be done 10x as much.
I may be misunderstanding, but it sounds to me like saying "company A uses much less electricity to generate a share of stock than company B".
PoC feels more efficient than PoW (I'm not familiar with the details though) but still requires a massive amount of physical resources and computation compared to PoS.
I'm still wondering how it would choose who gets to make the next block. If 8 people have huge storage and one needs to be picked to make the next block who wins? All 8 of them would presumably get the "answer" right immediately right? One of the highlights of proof of work is that it mathematically keeps block times at 10 minutes. I don't fully understand how this system works.
Schemes vary on certain details, but the gist on PoC is that you precompute answers to puzzles that take up a bunch of space on a disk and miners search their disks for the best answers to mine a block. It's hard to compute the solutions during the window for the next block on the fly, so precomputation and storage are required. Everyone's answers are different because the miner's account identity is part of each solution. This approach seems strong from an efficiency, transaction rate, and decentralization standpoint, but it hasn't taken off, and I'm at a loss to why.
(Like I said, this space is full of scams, so it's hard to ask a question honestly without sounding like a shill. Maybe I shouldn't have bothered asking.)