News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by mcv on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @08:24AM (#20343641)
It's an extreme situation. I'd assume that, given more hurdles for women than for men, the women who do make it are likely to be more qualified than men, not less.

When the few women you can find are less qualified, you should ask yourself why. Why are the more qualified women avoiding you? If either your company or your industry had developed a reputation for being toxic and sexist, I can totally see why qualified women would avoid it. Giving more money to women is not going to solve the real problem here. It's also possible that your culture has somehow decided this is not a job for women. I work at a Dutch company that employs plenty of female developers, but all the female developers are from India. I don't think I know even a single female Dutch programmer here, which is weird. Why is this?

Those are the real issues we need to figure out. Simply occasionally throwing money at people, even if it's a lot, is unlikely to fix the structural problems here.

Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by mafribe on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @10:18AM (#20344470)

   Why is this?
Intuition pump for the curious: why doesn't Melania Knauss work as a programmer?
Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by zeveb on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @08:43AM (#20343779)
> I'd assume that, given more hurdles for women than for men, the women who do make it are likely to be more qualified than men, not less.

Sure — ashelmire's point was that right now there are more hurdles for men, which leads to men being more likely to be more qualified than women, which perpetuates and amplifies a stereotype.

Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by mcv on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @10:23AM (#20344516)
Maybe in some very specific situations there are indeed more hurdles for men than for women, but in general, in STEM in particular, there are clearly more hurdles for women than for men, as evidenced by the fact that more men than women make it through.

Though I don't think the solution is to compensate by creating more hurdles for men; we need to identify and remove the hurdles for women. And whatever hurdles remain for men.

Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by DuskStar on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @12:27PM (#20345824)
> there are clearly more hurdles for women than for men, as evidenced by the fact that more men than women make it through

This has three very large assumptions:

1. Men and women share the same distribution of relevant abilities

2. Men and women share the same distribution of relevant interests

3. Men and women share the same distribution of societal expectations and external opportunities

A lot of people seem to assume that either #1 or #2 are false, and there's research to support #2 being false. #3 being false also seems intuitively obvious to me, given that it's stereotypically more acceptable to be a housewife than a househusband (as one example of many).

Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by mcv on Thursday July 04, 2019 @01:54AM (#20351925)
3 is the big one. I once heard Neil DeGrasse Tyson talk about how every time he said he'd want to become an astrophysicist, people would ask him if he shouldn't become an athlete. He was a good wrestler, wasn't he? Athlete is a socially acceptable career for black men. I can't help but wonder how many potential astrophysicists became athletes instead due to such social pressure.

Social expectations can be a real hurdle.

Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by gurkendoktor on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @04:49PM (#20348633)
A couple of links related to these assumptions, which have somehow become truisms in our culture.

Re: 1, the Variability Hypothesis[1] argues that men have a different, "wider" distribution than women in many categories, including intelligence.

Re: 2, this Slate Star Codex article[2] is full of relevant pointers.

Discrimination sucks and we must push back when we see it, but not every difference in representation is automatically a sign of discrimination.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Variability_hypothesis#Modern_...

[2] https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/08/07/contra-grant-on-exagge...