News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Model 3 deliveries beat Wall Street targets, shares... by Y-bar on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @05:46PM (#20339677)
A general observation/question related to this style of headline we see here: “[...] beats [analysts] target”

Why do we write like that? Wouldn’t it make more sense to write “[analysts] misses [...] target”? It feels to me like writing “Weather rains more and beats meteorologists’ expectations” when “Meteorologists underestimates rainfall” would be more true.

Re:Tesla Model 3 deliveries beat Wall Street targets, shares... by scribu on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @05:57PM (#20339745)
Because you want the most salient piece of information at the start.

Otherwise, the front page of a financial site would look like this:

  * Analysts miss target regarding Tesla
  * Analysts are optimistic about Q2 returns for Boeing
  * Analysts etc.
Re:Tesla Model 3 deliveries beat Wall Street targets, shares... by losteric on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @06:10PM (#20339849)
Nothing wrong with that, but it won't happen when analysts are the ones writing most of the material for those financial sites... of course they're going to claim Tesla "beat expectations" rather than "analysts underestimate Tesla"
Re:Tesla Model 3 deliveries beat Wall Street targets, shares... by staticautomatic on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @06:03PM (#20339788)
Maybe it should look like that.
Re:Tesla Model 3 deliveries beat Wall Street targets, shares... by thereisnospork on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @06:00PM (#20339761)
Here Tesla is the active agent, whereas the weatherman is the active agent in that scenario because rain is 'dumb' compared to a company. One wouldn't write 'the target avoided being hit by the archer' in a more hyperbolic example. Not that the other way around is wrong per say, just that the emphasis changes.
Re:Tesla Model 3 deliveries beat Wall Street targets, shares... by jodrellblank on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @06:25PM (#20339947)
Tesla is "dumb weather" in this scenario, it's not building cars to chase analyst targets and then being pleased when it hits them, it's building and shipping cars - as many as it can - regardless of what analysts say.

Analysts are trying to predict how many cars Tesla can build, and if they understand the company really well, their prediction will be accurate. With this result, you haven't learned much about Tesla, but you have learned that the analysts did not predict Tesla very well - so they don't understand it very well, and their reports might be wrong in the same way for other companies.

Re:Tesla Model 3 deliveries beat Wall Street targets, shares... by thereisnospork on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @12:02AM (#20341502)
When the Patriots[1] win a game where they are the underdogs[2], does the Boston Herald[2] headline read 'NFL analysts fail to predict outcome of football game'?

[1]A team of people, trying to create as many points as possible, who don't give a damn what the analysts are saying. When they win, are we learning about the Patriots or the talking heads (who probably haven't changed much in the past week)?

[2]A guy can dream.

[3]Sportsbook digest, if that is a publication, might have that headline.

Re:Tesla Model 3 deliveries beat Wall Street targets, shares... by jodrellblank on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @01:40AM (#20341896)
Would the headline read "Patriots deliver more touchdowns than analyst targets, bets up 7%"?

Do people talk about "targets" rather than "predictions" or "odds" in American Football analysis? "We set a target of X game wins for the Patriots this season". "Patriots beat analyst targets".

No, it would say "Patriots beat Otherteam!", "Patriots win championship!". Analysts wouldn't get a mention. Phrasing it like Tesla is a team playing against Wall Street analysts is a bit weird, now that commentor mentions it.

Re:Tesla Model 3 deliveries beat Wall Street targets, shares... by peaktechisnow on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @06:10PM (#20339844)
This is the correct answer.
Re:Tesla Model 3 deliveries beat Wall Street targets, shares... by 40acres on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @05:54PM (#20339727)
"X beats Y's target" makes sense to me due to the nature of the stock market, and how expectations are "baked into" the share price.

Quarterly earnings are all about performance relative to expectation, while it is accurate to say that the analysts are wrong in this instance, the market gives so much "trust" to analysts that we expect their targets to be expressed in good faith (I sense an SEC violation otherwise), so when a company beats expectations we view that as a decent proxy for performance.

Re:Tesla Model 3 deliveries beat Wall Street targets, shares... by rawrmaan on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @05:50PM (#20339703)
I'm trying hard to find a flaw in this argument but I can't. Good point.
Re:Tesla Model 3 deliveries beat Wall Street targets, shares... by swsieber on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @05:55PM (#20339734)
I think (I'm winging it here), it's because the market acts on the analysts predictions. The market turns the analysts predictions into expectations and acts on them.
Re:Tesla Model 3 deliveries beat Wall Street targets, shares... by rawrmaan on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @07:26PM (#20340296)
That’s the first argument I thought of, but people make plans based on the weather forecast too.
Re:Tesla Model 3 deliveries beat Wall Street targets, shares... by belltaco on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @06:04PM (#20339801)
Because way more people care much more about companies and their stock prices than play celebrity analyst.

Analysts predict value of a company based on a lot of public data, and usually the stock price reflects those expectations.

Who cares a hoot if analysts are wrong? Whereas Tesla beating expectations and their sales numbers are more important.

Re:Tesla Model 3 deliveries beat Wall Street targets, shares... by 4rd on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @06:03PM (#20339791)
Re:Tesla Model 3 deliveries beat Wall Street targets, shares... by whack on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @06:01PM (#20339767)
If you see companies as a force-of-nature that can only be marginally influenced by humans, then you're right that the only variable is the analyst's prediction accuracy.

But if you see companies as organizations made up of humans, that are capable of both overperforming and underperforming, then you have multiple variables. An analyst could provide an estimate for future-sales, and this estimate could be the best possible estimate given the information known at the time. And the estimate could still be wrong because the company's leadership/workers succeeded in turning things around.

TLDR: If you believe in free-will, then it's possible for someone to beat highly-accurate 3rd party estimates. If you don't believe in free-will, then any mis-estimates are purely due to analyst error

Re:Tesla Model 3 deliveries beat Wall Street targets, shares... by jodrellblank on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @06:46PM (#20340076)
TLDR: If you believe in free-will, then it's possible for someone to beat highly-accurate 3rd party estimates.

How can you call them "highly-accurate" if they aren't accurate? Yes they can be "best available, given the information known", but we're talking about predicting the future - it's impossible to have all the information; if your prediction is wrong, you don't get to call it "accurate".

If you don't believe in free-will, then any mis-estimates are purely due to analyst error

That doesn't make it analyst /error/. It tells you the analysts' understanding of Tesla as is not as good as they thought. If they had predicted the result spot-on, they would be excellent analysts working with excellent information. They didn't, so now you know one or both of those is not excellent, or both, or they made errors.

If you see companies as a force-of-nature that can only be marginally influenced by humans

To go down this route, you have to imagine Tesla didn't really want to produce many cars at all - all the incentives and motivation they have about making lots of cars, earning millions, paying debt back, the incentives employees have for bonuses, doing what the boss says, staying employed, all amount to virtually nothing, but the commentary from Jones of SomeBank is enormously influential and can turn the entire company round. That's so disproportionate, I can't just take it as given.

Re:Tesla Model 3 deliveries beat Wall Street targets, shares... by whack on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @08:47PM (#20340711)
You're squabbling over semantics and ignoring the larger point. Someone can put together the best-possible estimate today based on all the information available. And this estimate could still be wrong, through no fault of the analyst, because of human free will. This makes stock-analyst estimates fundamentally different from weather predictions.
Re:Tesla Model 3 deliveries beat Wall Street targets, shares... by jodrellblank on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @01:18AM (#20341791)
Why does it? You could put together the best-possible weather prediction today based on all the information available, and this estimate could still be wrong, through no fault of the meterorologist.

And what we'd learn is that the meteorologist cannot predict the weather and we shouldn't rely on their predictions as much in future.

We don't call the meteorologist "accurate" because they couldn't do better, we call them "inaccurate" because they were inaccurate.

Re:Tesla Model 3 deliveries beat Wall Street targets, shares... by whack on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @12:00PM (#20345484)
The fact that "weather" has no free will, but humans do, makes your analogy unworkable. If a meteorologist has all available information at time-T, as well as the computing power to crunch all the numbers and run a simulation, it's impossible for them to mispredict the weather.

The very definition of free-will means that the above is impossible for predicting human behavior. Even if you had perfect information, models and computing power, you still can't predict human behavior with 100% accuracy. A good analyst may be able to predict human behavior with higher levels of accuracy than others - but even a perfect analyst with perfect information will still make mistakes due to free will, which makes it qualitatively different compared to a meteorologist.