News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cato Institute: The Case Against Net Neutrality by zdw on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @09:10PM (#2033278)

    No firm or industry has any sort of “bottleneck control” over or market power in the broadband marketplace; it is very much a competitive free-for-all
Uh, last I checked, I had one viable, reasonably priced internet provider (local cable company) - all the others are either much slower (DSL) or much more expensive for equivalent service (ptp wireless).

Seriously, I'd be willing to give up "network neutrality" in a heartbeat for a free market system, provided that I get plenty of viable, competitive choices for the last mile to my house, which I think would solve additional problems rather than just the one being discussed...

Re:Cato Institute: The Case Against Net Neutrality by akozak on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @10:36PM (#2033416)
So then are you willing to give it up in the wireless space? Because there appears to be plenty of competition there.
Re:Cato Institute: The Case Against Net Neutrality by zdw on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @10:42PM (#2033424)
Sure, as long as the competition is:

1. An equal playing field - ie, no one carrier has a technical or legislative advantage over any others.

2. Carrier lock-in is eliminated - any device allowed on any network, no long term contracts.

3. There are little to no barriers for new carriers to enter the market.

This would increase competition, in the favor of wireless customers.

Re:Cato Institute: The Case Against Net Neutrality by num1 on Thursday December 23, 2010 @12:25AM (#2033614)
1) Technical advantages are welcomed, just not legislative. 2) Arguing from the perspective of the Cato institute, who are you to place restrictions on the phones carriers sell? The root issue is whether providers have a monopoly or not. But keeping a distinguishing feature just as phones to yourself is just good business. 3) Completely agreed.

This paper (circa 2004) was written from the perspective that internet service is not a monopoly. In this situation the answer is clear; (to a libertarian) government has no business dictating how we should do business.

A large debate within libertarian circles is what to do when monopolies happen. The reflexive answer is no government interference allowed no matter what, the market will figure it out. Obviously in certain situations that doesn't work too well, as far as I know it's still an open question.

Re:Cato Institute: The Case Against Net Neutrality by wtallis on Thursday December 23, 2010 @04:16AM (#2033977)
Would you count patent protections as technical or legislative? Patents are supposed to be used only to encourage technological progress, but all too often they screw up the competitive landscape on an entire market in ways that are obviously unfair. If we could reform our patent system to get rid of software patents and raise the bar for physical inventions, then it might be okay to say that technical advantages [protected by patents] are fair.
Re:Cato Institute: The Case Against Net Neutrality by Symmetry on Thursday December 23, 2010 @08:45AM (#2034351)
This is sort of a divisive issue for Libertarians. On the one hand, patents extend the reach of Capitalism into new places, which some libertarians who are reflexively pro-Capitalism like. On the other hand, patents are government restrictions on what you can do with your property, so more consistent (imho) Libertarians tend to be against them.
Re:Cato Institute: The Case Against Net Neutrality by num1 on Thursday December 23, 2010 @07:36PM (#2036278)
I would personally list patent protections as legislative. There was an article posted to HN recently about patents and what I took away was that they do little to protect someone who isn't a large corporation. I believe this is related to http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2034262 , patents (in any form not just software but also physical) are just another way to prevent a free market from forming. And libertarianism is based on a firm belief in the free market.
Re:Cato Institute: The Case Against Net Neutrality by shrikant on Thursday December 23, 2010 @10:46AM (#2034683)
IMO, the presence of (3) from that list will go a long, LONG way in eliminating (1) and (2).

Given an easy way for competitors to enter the market, carrier lock-in wrt devices and features will decrease dramatically. Citation: See the UK and (to an extent) Indian telecom markets.

Re:Cato Institute: The Case Against Net Neutrality by natch on Thursday December 23, 2010 @12:49AM (#2033657)
Wow. The idea that profit-motivated corporations would voluntarily do what you describe is an idealistic fantasy. That's why some regulation is needed.
Re:Cato Institute: The Case Against Net Neutrality by zdw on Thursday December 23, 2010 @01:15AM (#2033696)
Exactly - everywhere there's a natural monopoly, it should be regulated into being a common carrier, when possible.

This allows innovation to flourish on top of a commodity service - fundamentally, the only thing that this kind of provider offers is the last mile, just like the water or electric company.

Re:Cato Institute: The Case Against Net Neutrality by jpadkins on Thursday December 23, 2010 @07:33AM (#2034238)
Can you give examples of natural monopolies?

The only ones I can think of government granted (including US broadband, because of the local city/muni exclusive contracts purchased).

Re:Cato Institute: The Case Against Net Neutrality by zdw on Thursday December 23, 2010 @10:15AM (#2034580)
See here:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_monopoly

Personally, I think their definition is a bit broad - I tend to think of natural monopolies are where the universe's physical limitations cause obvious problems either physical or practical for competition.

For example, in a totally libertarian society where you would pay a toll to drive on any road, you wouldn't want hundreds of companies trying to making their own roads between points A and B - it wouldn't be an efficient use of space, and just imagine that turnpike.

Still, someone needs to manage the road to your house, power/cable/telephone/etc. thus the government manages the companies that manage that service.

The reason that these monopolies are "natural" is that there's a physical limitation involved - it just also happens to be codified with a contractual agreement.

Re:Cato Institute: The Case Against Net Neutrality by kiba on Thursday December 23, 2010 @02:09AM (#2033782)
Regulatory capture.
Re:Cato Institute: The Case Against Net Neutrality by hristov on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @11:29PM (#2033520)
Not really. As far as the bandwidth, latency and reliability required for a decent desktop connection the current competition is none at all. I had a friend that had one of those services where you use wireless internet for the house, she did nothing but complain.

Of course there are things in the future, there is 4g and all of that, it is yet to be seen whether 4G will be doable if everyone in your building is using 4g at full speeds.

Re:Cato Institute: The Case Against Net Neutrality by nickpinkston on Thursday December 23, 2010 @01:07AM (#2033681)
I was actually expecting a net-neut. sucks because we need a freer market - this paper is just ridiculous. Sounds more like the Federalist Society to me...

I agree though that a better market is preferable to NN and the current system. The issue here is how to solve the network effects / physical monopoly problems that plague the industry.

On the one hand, no one is going to run a fully parallel system - even the incumbents didn't. They bought it from companies who bought it from companies that went bankrupt in the process of doing it.

This means we'd need to either nationalize the existing system or put it into some type of co-op with the internet users as the voting group (via the gov't) - or less drastically we could mandate a certain bulk rate discount (w/ indexing to some of the known variables) so that new players could instantly begin competing without needing to overcome the massive infrastructure issues.

...or we could just do net neutrality which is a good stop gap - which is what it seems is the current pragmatic solution. Let's hope a better market-based system can eventually replace the monopolies, but until now it seems like NN is the way to go.

Re:Cato Institute: The Case Against Net Neutrality by wtallis on Thursday December 23, 2010 @04:10AM (#2033970)
What kind of benefits would we expect a magical solution to the inefficiency of the broadband market to provide as compared to what a comprehensive net neutrality law would provide? Or, to put it another way, if we get a good net neutrality law passed, what techniques are left for the cable/dsl duopoly screw us with? We already have laws against price fixing, so if those are enforced in addition to net neutrality, most consumers would get pretty close to the quality of service they would get out of a properly competitive market. I would be wary of the government trying to indirectly prevent the shady practices net neutrality would outlaw --- it could too easily end up providing screwed up incentives the way agricultural subsidies do.
Re:Cato Institute: The Case Against Net Neutrality by nickpinkston on Thursday December 23, 2010 @10:26AM (#2034611)
I think this is a question that isn't discussed enough.

So you've formed the question as: "how can they screw us through X more", and that's certainly part 1 of the question, there's also the second part of "how can this reduce innovation - and screw us in the long term".

I approach this from the incentive alignment that drives politics. I assume that both big biz and gov't are in

Part 1: Corporations influencing the law

Laws are written by/for lobbyists on each side. Making a new law will inherently draw out the lobbys of each side (certainly has here). If corporations are allowed to play with the laws regulating them - you can imagine that they'll try to gain as much power as possible. Think about the banking regs and how the banks just raised the fees on other things instead - same problem.

Part 2: Law Slowing Innovation

Even if NN didn't have the influence issues, it'd still be regulating the way the internet is today - not how it might be. Just as we've seen in banking, when you put restrictions on the bad guys, you also hurt the good guys. Look at what happened to Prosper.com, etc. when they tried something innovation in banking. Look at how there are no progressive banks - only progressive services using the banking system. I'd like to avoid this issue at well so the internet so can further refined.

By regulating the source of the issue, the natural monopoly of the fiber network itself, can we allow innovative firms to get in the market quickly and have incentives to innovate - or at the very least encourage the big guys to keep up.

Re:Cato Institute: The Case Against Net Neutrality by specialist on Thursday December 23, 2010 @02:36AM (#2033828)
> Sounds more like the Federalist Society to me...

Bingo.

Re:Cato Institute: The Case Against Net Neutrality by marknutter on Thursday December 23, 2010 @10:09AM (#2034565)
I think you've lost perspective. You have chosen the product that best suit your needs from a variety of different products. You have your opinions about what "reasonably priced" means, but don't mistake that as meaning that a "reasonable price" actually exists. There are different levels of quality for all products. You don't see people calling for legislation to regulate Google search because its competition isn't as good.

Most people don't mind slower/cheaper DSL service, so long as they can access email and Facebook. As far as I can tell, the free market has worked really well up to this point. Here in Saint Paul, MN, I have a wide variety of options to choose from: Comcast, Qwest DSL, dial-up service, AT&T 3G wireless, Verizon/Clear/Sprint 4G wireless, satellite internet, etc. I do business with Comcast because they offer the fastest connection I can get and at a price that I consider "reasonable."

Re:Cato Institute: The Case Against Net Neutrality by isleyaardvark on Thursday December 23, 2010 @11:02AM (#2034754)
> You have chosen the product that best suit your needs from a variety of different products.

But there's no competition within the product categories themselves. Say there's only one breadmaker allowed to make bread in your city. The fact that you can still buy potatoes or pasta doesn't mean that you're dealing with a free market.

Re:Cato Institute: The Case Against Net Neutrality by marknutter on Thursday December 23, 2010 @12:42PM (#2035130)
The way I see it, the product category we are dealing with here is "internet access."
Re:Cato Institute: The Case Against Net Neutrality by juiceandjuice on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @10:19PM (#2033389)
FYI, the paper was written in 2004.