News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla has a lab trying to build its own battery cells by makomk on Monday July 01, 2019 @05:50PM (#20330102)
Those are certainly the things they've been claiming as their advantages, but the battery tech is mostly bought in and their original in-house motor tech has basically nothing in common with the motors used in the Model 3.
Re:Tesla has a lab trying to build its own battery cells by stcredzero on Monday July 01, 2019 @05:58PM (#20330158)
Those are certainly the things they've been claiming as their advantages, but the battery tech is mostly bought in

The battery pack, control systems, and cooling systems are something you can get really right, or quite wrong. The cells themselves are important, of course. Given that they're a cost driver, a vertical integration move would be to bring them in house. Even if Tesla ultimately fails at cars, it might still have a future as a battery pack manufacturer.

Re:Tesla has a lab trying to build its own battery cells by m-ee on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @12:24AM (#20332120)
Cells manufacturing is a totally different animal, and I wonder if Tesla is willing to burn money long enough to get as good as Panasonic and the other big players. Being colocated with Panasonic at the gigafactory is a huge leg up, but its still a very long term play that I'm not sure matches up with Elon's patience or Tesla's cash reserves.
Re:Tesla has a lab trying to build its own battery cells by tw04 on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:32PM (#20331059)
>their original in-house motor tech has basically nothing in common with the motors used in the Model 3.

What point are you trying to make here? The model 3 uses a different motor because the target price band and performance requirements are different.

If you buy a Cruze from GM it comes with a cheaper, less performant motor than a CTS-V.

Re:Tesla has a lab trying to build its own battery cells by maxerickson on Monday July 01, 2019 @10:01PM (#20331499)
They are saying that if you don't put your different motor in your mass market product, then your mass market product isn't using your motor as a differentiator.
Re:Tesla has a lab trying to build its own battery cells by zaroth on Monday July 01, 2019 @10:16PM (#20331571)
The Tesla motor(s) that Tesla puts in the Model 3 are considered the best in the field and significantly better in terms of performance and efficiency than the competitors. This has been shown through tear-downs as well as in the end result.

I’m really not sure what the OP is trying to say. The TM3 motor is absolutely a differentiator.

Re:Tesla has a lab trying to build its own battery cells by tw04 on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @11:46AM (#20336224)
I guess define "different motor" - both the Model 3 and Model S/X motors were designed in-house by Tesla. It's not like they're ordering Model 3 motors from some Chinese ODM that makes the same motor for Tesla and Toyota and GM and Nissan and insert company.

The Ford Mustang and Chevy Camaro both have a V8. They both consider their motors differentiators due to the specifics of THEIR V8 implementation. Just because other companies might be using the same basic design principles doesn't mean that their specific implementation of that design isn't a differentiator.

Re:Tesla has a lab trying to build its own battery cells by makomk on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @08:52PM (#20340734)
The Model 3 motor works on a fundamentally different principle to the ones in all Tesla's previous cars, but it's very similar to the motor technology used by all the other modern electric cars. The best analogy I can come up with is that it's like a company which has only produced diesel cars claiming their engine experience gives them an advantage over all the other car manufacturers who've been producing petrol cars for a while when announcing their first petrol car. (It's not a perfect analogy - a car manufacturer which did that could probably reuse a lot more of their existing engine tech and experience than Tesla could.)

More specifically, Tesla's big advantage was that they had very sophisticated drive technology for using AC induction motors in electric vehicles. That's even where their name came from - this kind of motor was invented by Nikola Tesla originally. No-one else had this tech. With the Model 3, they abandoned this in favour of permanent magnet brushless motors very much like the ones all the other manufacturers were already using. Because of the very different way in which those motors work, they require completely different drive algorithms, pose entirely new engineering and materials challenges to manufacture, and give very different perforrmance characteristics. Tesla basically took all of the motor work that was supposed to give them a headstart, abandoned it, and started almost from scratch where the other manufacturers were years ago.

Re:Tesla has a lab trying to build its own battery cells by xbmcuser on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:58PM (#20331483)
Tesla is buying the batteries but make the battery pack themselves. For the China factory they are planning to use Chinese batteries for the packs.