News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Common mistakes made by beginner Python programmers by tempguy9999 on Monday July 01, 2019 @05:01AM (#20323611)
> This whole mutating or not mutating thing was a huge headache when starting python and still causes gotchas.

Well, I'd say 1) immutability is expensive[0] and 2) mutability is sometimes simpler and clearer than immutability for some algorithms IMO. So I'd want python to have both.

Today's passion for 'immutable everything' is going to burn out pretty quick as it's great but being used too much and without recognising its cost. IMO again.

[0] if naively implemented, and it so often is.

Re:Common mistakes made by beginner Python programmers by wodenokoto on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @01:56AM (#20332503)
R doesn’t have strict immutability. I’m not sure which data structures in R are mutable, but I’m sure it’s most, as a common operation is to change the values of a subset of a list/vector/dataframe.

So my point is not “python is hard because of mutability” it’s that pythons mutability really gets in the way of the beginner and causes lots of gotchas for even well experienced developers.

Re:Common mistakes made by beginner Python programmers by tempguy9999 on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @06:20AM (#20333729)
> So my point is not “python is hard because of mutability”...

ok

> ...it’s that pythons mutability really gets in the way of the beginner and causes lots of gotchas for even well experienced developers

So python is hard because of mutability? (well, harder anyway).

The fact is, if python had immutability it'd be semantically simpler. Unquestionably (I'd claim). But that comes at a performance cost, so mutability is allowed. That's when we get these confusions of what an operation does (because the semantics get non-simple). My point is either way we pay a price.

Anyway I have a feeling I may be misconstruing your point, sorry if that's so.

Re:Common mistakes made by beginner Python programmers by brianberns on Monday July 01, 2019 @11:52AM (#20326595)
I think mutability is fine, but there should be some syntactic difference in the usage to alert the user.