News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jony Ive is departing Apple, but he started leaving years... by tempguy9999 on Monday July 01, 2019 @04:37AM (#20323504)
Do you consider Ive's later designs as 'successful'?

I don't know as I don't use apple but I heard of lot of grumbling off of those that do.

Re:Jony Ive is departing Apple, but he started leaving years... by bch on Monday July 01, 2019 @05:49AM (#20323840)
I think Jony Ive lifted an entire industry and perhaps a generation to “good design” (and brought a lot more attention to Dieter Rams[0][1][2]). That we’re here talking about it (for the 3rd(?) time on HN front page) is a testament to that. That said, I think humans got lost in the process, at least occasionally, but not just recently. I don’t recall which models, but sometime the MacBooks adopted really sharp edges on the bottom slab - I found it uncomfortable to sit at (did my piano teacher have input, as a final “keep your wrists up!” order?). Or the orientationally challenged hockey-puck mouse[3]... Compare with the (not problem-free, mind) Thinkpad, which may seem more designed and exciting when you see it’s got a singular inspiration that they seem to have honoured for years[4] (how brave is that, to not change?).

I wonder if Apple didn’t feel self-imposed pressure to keep asserting its design dominance, and therefore look for ways to change. We’re all just armchair quarterbacks here though. in the end I think Jony Ive did more good than harm.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dieter_Rams

[1] https://www.apartmenttherapy.com/apple-design-doesnt-fall-fa...

[2] https://youtu.be/YdVG4LcoY4Y

[3] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_USB_Mouse

[4] http://blog.lenovo.com/en/blog/the-japanese-essence-in-think...

Re:Jony Ive is departing Apple, but he started leaving years... by gxx on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:04AM (#20324469)
The sharp edges are a crystal clear example of Ive's pursuit of form over function. It's insane to have sharp edges that users may touch with their wrists, especially the sharp points on each side of the cutout below the trackpad. Ever since Macbooks had that "feature" I've been rounding off the edges with fine sandpaper and then polishing them. It's a wonderful improvement.
Re:Jony Ive is departing Apple, but he started leaving years... by ksec on Monday July 01, 2019 @10:29AM (#20325564)
Are they really "Sharp"? They don't cut me or hurt in anyway. Or is that the new 2016+ MBP? I am still on the best 2015 MBP at the moment.
Re:Jony Ive is departing Apple, but he started leaving years... by muro on Monday July 01, 2019 @01:51PM (#20327897)
My wrists hurt badly when I was using the 2015 MBP. I was probably "holding it wrong", but still, putting a sharp edge there...
Re:Jony Ive is departing Apple, but he started leaving years... by tvanantwerp on Monday July 01, 2019 @10:59AM (#20325917)
I cut myself on my iMac just this morning while trying to reposition it on my desk...
Re:Jony Ive is departing Apple, but he started leaving years... by sundvor on Monday July 01, 2019 @07:11AM (#20324195)
Thanks for #4, that was a great read. I'm still on my 2012 X1 Carbon and it's surprising how not dated it looks.

I'll replace it with another when it breaks, but hoping it'll last until AMD gets properly into the laptop game.

Re:Jony Ive is departing Apple, but he started leaving years... by jorvi on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:40AM (#20324660)
Beauty really is in the eye of the beholder, I guess.

To me, pretty much any modern Thinkpad[0] looks like 90s laptops[1] made out of crappy, flexing plastic whereas something as sleek as a MacBook Air[2] from the same year looks positively futuristic.

If (when?) I jump ship I'll either get an XPS 13 or a T4XXs, and the only reason I'm undecided is because of Thinkpads their design, especially the gratuitous logo-ing.

[0] https://cnet3.cbsistatic.com/img/rR1UdxX-DdlR2hDEoq3jjC30Nho...

[1] https://i.ibb.co/Krb07X4/8-C061277-2-A27-4204-BFAE-03-CFDEFD...

[2] https://tweakers.net/i/4R_rvojQOTIskfm9fHVoeguxcPE=/1280x/fi...

Re:Jony Ive is departing Apple, but he started leaving years... by sfifs on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:21AM (#20324980)
So... form over function?

In my field (data analytics), a Mac indicates the user is in sales :-)

Re:Jony Ive is departing Apple, but he started leaving years... by jorvi on Monday July 01, 2019 @11:12AM (#20326103)
To some degree? Certainly.

Although there is research that people perform measurably better on attractive gear. Aside from that, I believe around a third of all GitHub commits originate from macOS. Perhaps form and function often go hand in hand :)

Re:Jony Ive is departing Apple, but he started leaving years... by tempguy9999 on Monday July 01, 2019 @11:35AM (#20326380)
> Although there is research that people perform measurably better on attractive gear

I've an interest in ergonomics, if you could ref this study I'd be very interested.

Re:Jony Ive is departing Apple, but he started leaving years... by jorvi on Monday July 01, 2019 @12:21PM (#20326901)
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S000368700...

and

https://www-users.cs.york.ac.uk/~pcairns/pubs/ChawdaCraftCai...

are good starting points. The essence is that people rate appealing devices as better performing, even if they factually work identical. Due to that halo effect they will perform on them better. The second source points out that if you measure something like 'type these 100 words' there will be no factual performance difference between appealing and unappealing devices, but on a higher level it does lead to things like more creative thinking.

My own guess would be pretty much what the studies say: people enjoy using appealing devices more, which leads to aggregate benefits: less stress which leads to more creative thinking, more use of the device, the device is better maintained, etc.

Re:Jony Ive is departing Apple, but he started leaving years... by tempguy9999 on Monday July 01, 2019 @01:13PM (#20327511)
That's new! And interesting. Thanks.
Re:Jony Ive is departing Apple, but he started leaving years... by TheOtherHobbes on Monday July 01, 2019 @05:15AM (#20323669)
Industrial design includes materials science and process design as well as aesthetics.

In fact the aesthetics are the easy part. Ive has always talked about materials and processes in interviews and videos, so it's unlikely his sole contribution has been doodling rounded rectangles on napkins.

The question is the extent to which Apple's recent missteps are his fault.

Jobs seems to have had veto power over bad or self-indulgent design. Cook isn't aesthetically sophisticated enough to do that with any flair.

That leaves complicated collective politics in charge of the design process. Promoting Ive out of the company may or may not improve that - time will tell.

Re:Jony Ive is departing Apple, but he started leaving years... by thom on Monday July 01, 2019 @07:14AM (#20324215)
I bought plenty of Apple hardware with fundamental thermal issues or other problems caused by overreaching design during Jobs' reign, so I'm not sure how much he exercised this veto.
Re:Jony Ive is departing Apple, but he started leaving years... by ksec on Monday July 01, 2019 @10:47AM (#20325777)
Again, purely from the thinness issue, ( and not the keyboard )

The current 2016 MBP design were likely done in 2014/2015, with Intel's roadmap pointing to 10nm in 2016 and 7nm in 2019. Intel over promised on 10nm super low power capability ( Well may be that is still true, but no one know it couldn't yield ), and you would naturally expect 7nm with EUV to be better.

The 2016 MBP design had 45W TDP for CPU in mind, Imagine the 2016 MBP came out with 10nm, and updated with 7nm this year. That is easily an 8 Core CPU with much better IPC. Even the 10nm Icelake offered 20% IPC improvement, who knows what Intel Promised for 7nm.

So I don't think it really was an overreaching issue. Intel had a 3 years delay in delivery, and now looking likely at 4 years as 45W 10nm wont come until 2020.

Re:Jony Ive is departing Apple, but he started leaving years... by michaelscott on Monday July 01, 2019 @07:35AM (#20324320)
Ives has led the entire design process for Apple's device range, at least until the relatively recent past. Like you I'm not sure to what degree Apple's problems as a whole are attributable to him (certainly not everything of course), but as a designer of his calibre he should be able to make the design decisions that produce a better UX in the product, with or without Jobs. It's why he earns the big bucks.

With that in mind, I'd say the issues in Apple's recent range (of a design nature) can be attributed to him. He's taken minimalism past its extreme in recent years, getting rid of things that are part of the device's essential nature in favour of aesthetics and creating something that has great UI but terrible UX.

Re:Jony Ive is departing Apple, but he started leaving years... by skohan on Monday July 01, 2019 @12:47PM (#20327186)
There are a couple of failures (trashcan mac for example, Macbook Pro butterfly keyboard to a degree) but it is hard to argue that Apple's product designs over the last decade haven't been a massive success in general.

Sure you can point out gripes (the touch bar, lack of ports, no headphone jack etc.) but in almost every product category there are at most a couple other products which can compete in terms of build quality, aesthetics, and functionality. And people have certainly bought a lot of units of most of these products, so it's hard to classify them as "failures" by any objective metric.

If anything I think Apple has such a strong reputation for having categorically the "best designs" that they can't help falling short of expectations, and there's a whole category of journalism dedicated to catastrophizing every perceived flaw.

In other words they're not perfect but they're undeny