News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by crispyporkbites on Sunday June 30, 2019 @05:05PM (#20320513)
Facebook (or a consortium of companies, whatever this is) controlling a significant global currency feels like a dystopian nightmare. It's one of very few things that genuinely worry me.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by Grue3 on Monday July 01, 2019 @03:20AM (#20323157)
Replace "companies" with "governments" and you're already living in this "dystopian nightmare". Add to this the fact that two corporations (Visa and Mastercard) are controlling most of money transactions made by regular people.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by carlosdp on Sunday June 30, 2019 @06:02PM (#20320834)
I agree that a real global currency controlled by a group of corporations instead of (in many cases anyways) elected governments is a concerning concept that we need to really analyze.

My issue is that experts right now are instead just dismissing Libra is a dumb idea that will simply never work. It isn't dumb and it definitely could, I wish they would consider that for a second and talk about whether it SHOULD work.

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by djohnston on Sunday June 30, 2019 @05:16PM (#20320570)
really? libra is the thing that keeps you up at night?
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by save_ferris on Sunday June 30, 2019 @05:29PM (#20320647)
Not OP but sure. Having both a vast trove of data on user behavior, emotions, and financial background coupled with its own financial system is deeply concerning.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by bpfrh on Sunday June 30, 2019 @05:46PM (#20320739)
I don't really understand that point.

If facebook wants to control users and their financial data, wouldn't it be easier to simply make a fintech?

I mean, sure libra gives them more data, but the same could easily be reached if facebook founds a fintech?

With the current libra afaik they only have 1 seat out of 28 so less control than with a fintech.

With libra you could at least control more than with a fintech.

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by crispyporkbites on Sunday June 30, 2019 @05:47PM (#20320743)
Can you imagine getting a mortgage from Facebook? Or having your salary paid into your WhatsApp account directly? Having Zuckerberg maintain your pension? Now imagine doing that and being a non-US resident.

Who are you going to contact when something goes wrong? Facebook won’t pick up the phone, you can’t vote for regulation or changes, at best you’re a number.

Just try and use PayPal as a bank account and see what happens.

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by hombre_fatal on Sunday June 30, 2019 @06:16PM (#20320906)
Travelers such as myself do some of things all the time like use Paypal as a bank. Without credit history or a good score you can't do much either, and that's pretty frightening. In Vancouver you need a credit card (not debit card) just to park your car.

So yes, I'd love another competitor to all the holes that the existing system has. A lot of these comments just seem a bit... sheltered. Like wondering why people go to Mexico for dental care because your stellar white collar insurance covered 100% of your dental surgery.

The current system has major issues. And btw, I'd gladly compare mortgage terms from my bank vs from Zuckerberg.

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by ohiovr on Sunday June 30, 2019 @05:51PM (#20320764)
Lose your facebook account and you totally lose your ability to do business, get paid, or just participate in the economy. Facebook wants to be more powerful than governments. People that want that kind of power love to use it.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by root_axis on Sunday June 30, 2019 @06:06PM (#20320857)
Huh? Why would losing your Facebook account mean "you totally lose your ability to do business, get paid, or just participate in the economy"?
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by ohiovr on Sunday June 30, 2019 @06:24PM (#20320957)
We are talking about a global currency. Libra the thing we are talking about. If you dont need facebook at all for that I stand corrected right? If facebook does not have a monopoly on some critical aspect of it I could care less. tell me now so i can just ignore this story along with all the other crimecoins and extortion tools.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by root_axis on Sunday June 30, 2019 @06:28PM (#20320978)
The existence of Libra does not negate the existence of real money.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by djohnston on Sunday June 30, 2019 @06:44PM (#20321042)
you don't need facebook for libra. the two are disjoint.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by lightgreen on Sunday June 30, 2019 @10:44PM (#20322088)
You can use a wallet of any other provider from the network if you don’t trust Facebook.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by nikolay on Sunday June 30, 2019 @05:25PM (#20320621)
So, your craptocurrency, run by Chinese miners and exchanges, is less scary? Gimme a break!
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by d4rti on Sunday June 30, 2019 @05:34PM (#20320670)
My currency, run by the Bank of England, is much less scary, and far more useful.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by lightgreen on Sunday June 30, 2019 @11:06PM (#20322163)
It is definitely more useful at the moment while there’s no libra, because zonzero is greater than zero.

But it is much less useful than it could be. Just paying a small debt (like 20 pounds for a restaurant) to a friend who visited from another country is nightmarish now when your currency is run by Bank of England and your friend’s currency is run by eg FRS, in terms of both fee, time, and numbers of fields need to be filled in the forms. When you need to send these money to your parents in Moldova or Kenya, it’s 10 times more pain.

I could definitely use this currency.