Re:Open Letter to the Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees
by DanBC on Sunday June 30, 2019 @05:04PM
(#20320503)
It's not being used as a standalone reason. Fram wasn't booted for being white or male. He was booted for being toxic.
Re:Open Letter to the Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees
by the_duke on Sunday June 30, 2019 @03:22PM
(#20319937)
This particular - mostly US centric - discussion is something that is best kept off Hackernews, IMO.
While discussing an individual, nuanced community upheavel in a important part of the modern web is interesting, there are better public forums for generalized, socio-political topics.
(You also picked a single quote , while, as I stated, the article provides much more context)
I still don't have much insight into this issue, but I worry about "too white, too male" being used as a standalone reason that change is needed. When race and gender make-up leads to bias, conflicting interests, or myopia on some issue, then it's a problem that needs addressing. It very often is, but it has to be demonstrated --we can't reason by analogy that all things demographically imbalanced are unjust.