Re:Factoring may be easier than we think (2016)
by williamstein on Sunday June 30, 2019 @11:52AM
(#20318823)
Also Andrew Wiles' six years of focused worked fundamentally depended on very deep work that Ken Ribet had just completed, which in turn relied on decades of highly nontrivial work by Mazur, Katz, and others on modular curves and modular forms, which made surprising connections with other areas of mathematics. Finally, Wiles' first announced proof of FLT was wrong, and Richard Taylor collaborated with him to find a correct and quite different proof. (Disclaimer: I published a book on modular forms, and cowrote papers with some of the people mentioned above.)
Re:Factoring may be easier than we think (2016)
by AlexCoventry on Sunday June 30, 2019 @12:00PM
(#20318869)
I'm going to read your book, because your book with Mazur on the Riemann Hypothesis was incredible.
Re:Factoring may be easier than we think (2016)
by williamstein on Sunday June 30, 2019 @01:08PM
(#20319187)
Free PDF: https://wstein.org/books/modform/
Re:Factoring may be easier than we think (2016)
by AlexCoventry on Sunday June 30, 2019 @01:17PM
(#20319253)
Thanks.
Re:Factoring may be easier than we think (2016)
by 0815test on Sunday June 30, 2019 @11:47AM
(#20318792)
> There were plenty of people who tackled this problem and who failed to make any headway.
There was also plenty of meaningful progress throughout the 20th century at least, showing that the FLT was implied by other statements which would be easier to prove. Wiles's work was a follow-on to this progress; it's quite misleading to say that it "took" a single guy working over six years to prove FLT.
Re:Factoring may be easier than we think (2016)
by garmaine on Sunday June 30, 2019 @02:19PM
(#20319601)
By his own report, it was a few months of tackling the problem from various angles until he found the pathway that would eventually bear fruit, and formalizing that and fixing little problems along the way was what the next six years were spent on.
Re:Factoring may be easier than we think (2016)
by pas on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @02:56AM
(#20332803)
He was the lucky one. Many many mathematicians thought they saw a path. And spent years. And it did not lead anywhere/there in the end.
See also the many P = NP proof attempts. (Sure, most of them are complete crackpot garbage, but that doesn't mean serious attempts are not made, and probably more serious attempts are made that then go nowhere so the author doesn't disclose it.)
Six years, not a couple of months.
There were plenty of people who tackled this problem and who failed to make any headway. {Edit: I phrased this last sentence really clumsily, sorry.}