It's a fair system we should adopt everywhere.
What the GP was expliciting is that since paying 50% for an employee with low risk is absurd, a lot of companies won’t enforce the non compete.
In that case the only recourse would be to try sue/re-negociate under the angle that the non-compete is unfair (too low pay or too broad scope).
Otherwise, if you find another job in another field, you’d get the full job salary + the 50% from the non-compete. That’s usually fair enough.
Though, TBH, I'd like the comp to be 100% of the offer I'd be forced to forego. I.e. I go interview somewhere, negotiate an offer with them, and if my previous employer feels very strongly about me not working there, they can pay me 100% of the total package to not work there. That's the only set-up that'd be truly "fair" to the former employee, IMO.
They’d almost certainly lose, depending on circumstances, but the threat is enough to have a pretty strong chilling effect.
50% is an embarrassing amount. I'd accept 100% maybe.
Especially if you can stop some one after leaving there first low payed job to not work for 2 years on 50% of their starting salary - do you not see the potential to abuse young workers here
I agree that for interns the situation is not good but believe the "reasonable" provision is most likely to make a non-compete with an intern worthless in court.
You wouldn't get a 2 year non compete for a FSTE 100 CEO in the UK to stand up in court.
A
- max 2 years
- employer has to continue to pay at least 50% of the salary the employee last earned for the duration of the non-compete.
- cannot non-compete minors
- must provide reasonable argument for the non-compete (hard for interns)
I think this is a good balance.