News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Getting shot by a handgun by dkarl on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @12:41PM (#2028565)
About fifteen years ago I read a book summarizing research into the effects of different types and calibers of handguns and handgun ammunition. (Long story short: Clinton was trying to ban semiautomatic handguns or something, so my dad developed a sudden interest in buying a gun, and he borrowed some books from a friend who was quite an enthusiast.) The study was a survey of thousands of police reports on shootings, and it was done by a law enforcement guy to help law enforcement departments make an intelligent decision about what kinds of guns and ammo to standardize on.

He provided a lot of statistics and made some recommendations, but the overriding theme and message of the book was that the result of shooting someone, or being shot, is unpredictable no matter what kind of weapon is involved. Some examples:

A fatal bullet through the heart can leave a guy up and shooting for over ten seconds -- obviously an eternity for a law enforcement officer in a point-blank shootout.

A guy can get shot and not know it. Police officers are trained to check themselves carefully when any shots are fired, because it has happened that officers thought they were unharmed, went home, laid down to rest, and bled to death.

A guy can be in a shootout and THINK he got shot, and it turns out there's not a mark on him. They get knocked over, feel intense pain, cry out, etc. There were enough of these cases that the researchers were able to find some involving officers who were previously decorated for valor and had in fact been shot before.

A guy can get shot multiple times with a powerful weapon and get lucky, or he can get shot with a tiny weapon and get unlucky. I still remember the story used to illustrate this: a fight between roommates got ugly, and one guy shot the other six times in the chest with a .45. The second guy went to his attic, found his great-grandfather's Civil War-era relic small caliber revolver (something like a .22), went back downstairs, and shot his roommate through the heart, killing him. Forty-eight hours later, his desire for medical care overcame his aversion to getting caught, and he walked into an emergency room. He recovered completely.

The book had a lot of complicated reasoning about the trade-offs involved in choosing handguns and ammunition and made some strong recommendations, but I don't remember any of the specifics. I just remember the author stressing over and over again not to expect any particular result when you shoot somebody.

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by G_Wen on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @03:15PM (#2029170)
http://www.firearmstactical.com/pdf/fbi-hwfe.pdf

Here's a PDF analyzing the effectiveness of firearms. It was written in 1989 so it is a bit out of date. Perhaps someone with more experience with firearms can check to see if the article is still relevant.

It does confirm that "Even if the heart is instantly destroyed, there is sufficient oxygen in the brain to support full and complete voluntary action for 10-15 seconds".

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by jarin on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @04:54PM (#2029547)
So there might be something to the idea that you stay conscious for a bit after getting beheaded?
Re:Getting shot by a handgun by archon on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @05:15PM (#2029608)
Supposedly, the chemist Antoine Lavoisier[1], who was beheaded during the French Revolution, asked his assistant to quickly retrieve his head after the blade fell and count how long he could blink his eyes. The head blinked in the range of 12-15 times.

[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antoine_Lavoisier

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by archon on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @04:54PM (#2029545)
All I can offer is another anecdote, not a more recent study, but in the self-defense courses I've taken over the past couple years, my instructor has stressed that a shooting is always a gamble.

"The only way to ensure instantaneous incapacitation is to destroy enough important brain matter. Do you want to aim at a 2-inch square target on your opponent's fast-moving head, or do you want to take your chances aiming for center mass?"

So I don't know if this instructor is an oddball or if he represents the current popularly held wisdom, but this instructor at least acknowledges that the effects of gunshot wounds are extremely unpredictable, which lines up with that study.

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by giardini on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @06:38PM (#2029863)
I cannot help but believe that, in the story of the roommates' fight, the calibers of the handguns involved has been inadvertently swapped. The story then becomes much more credible.

Most civil war revolvers are .36 and .44 (very close to .45) and one shot to the heart would easily be fatal. It is not unheard of for someone to suffer multiple .22 shots to the chest yet suffer little injury. However it _is_ simply unheard of for someone to suffer six .45 shots to the chest yet walk around for days.

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by dkarl on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @09:11PM (#2030285)
It's pretty credible when you consider that the author picked the most vivid example he could find out of thousands of police and FBI reports to illustrate his point. Part of his point was that virtually nothing is unheard of.
Re:Getting shot by a handgun by giardini on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @10:23PM (#2030463)
I hate to do this, but...

Citation? Source?

You read the book "about fifteen years ago". Knowing something about guns (in particular .45's and .22's) and the fallibility of human memory, it is reasonable to remain skeptical.

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by dkarl on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @11:20PM (#2030554)
Your reaction is exactly the kind of thinking the author was trying to remedy. You should not be surprised at something that bizarre happening once in thousands of shootings. There are so many variables at play (what the person is wearing, their body composition, what exactly the bullet strikes in their body, at what angle, and so on) that trying to predict what happens based on the caliber of the gun is like trying to predict the relative performance of two computer programs based on what language they're implemented in. Sure, there are strong theoretical reasons for favoring one language or handgun over another, and you could easily discern patterns over a reasonable number of sufficiently similar cases, but there are so many other variables that in any particular case all you can offer is a statistically justified guess that could easily turn out to be wrong because of information you weren't given. If I told you Python beat C on six straight performance tests, you probably wouldn't be surprised; you'd just surmise that all six tests involved tasks for which Python has highly optimized libraries. Or you might guess that the Python programmers in all six tests were more skilled than their C counterparts. That would happen by chance from time to time. So why couldn't other variables in the roommate story align to create an outcome that would not be expected based solely on the caliber of the weapon? It could and does happen; that was the author's message. Maybe the second roommate was a huge guy wearing a thick jacket, and each of the bullets struck his ribcage at a lucky angle (after being slowed down by several inches of jacket, fat, and muscle.)
Re:Getting shot by a handgun by giardini on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @11:39PM (#2030584)
"So why couldn't other variables in the roommate story align to create an outcome that would not be expected based solely on the caliber of the weapon? It could and does happen; that was the author's message. Maybe the second roommate was a huge guy wearing a thick jacket, and each of the bullets struck his ribcage at a lucky angle (after being slowed down by several inches of jacket, fat, and muscle.)"

Because after 15 years it is more likely that you mis-remembered the story or erroneously conflated stories, etc.

And I understand the huge number of possibilities.

Such a remarkable story justifies a citation request: were it a more likely story, none would be required.

Let me turn the tables on you a bit: what is _your_ justification for the story as stated? I see no reason other than a 15-year old memory, possibly that of a child.

P.S. dkari - about your possible "urban legend" (that was downvoted) concerning the Israeli use of .22. I believe it far more likely to be true than the above story.

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by dkarl on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @02:10AM (#2030790)
I was in my late teens when I read the book and read it with the fascination a teenager has for such things. I certainly remember it better than I remember Jude the Obscure despite writing several papers plus a term paper on that book for my AP English class. The particular story of the roommates stuck out precisely because it exemplified the theme of the book perfectly.

I can't provide a citation because I don't remember the title or the author's name, but I can tell you that by expressing skepticism of the story you are in disagreement not just with an anecdote but with the book's overall message and consistent motif, which is not a detail I could have misremembered. You disagree with the author, in short, about whether the result of shooting someone with any particular caliber of handgun is consistent and predictable. The author felt strongly (based on the data he compiled) that it was a mistake to generalize about the effect of any type of gun or ammunition. The author seemed to fear after examining his data that the mere act of stating his conclusions on the relative merits of different types of handguns and ammunition would reinforce a more orderly and predictable vision of the world than the data justified. He said a lot of the appetite for research of the kind he was doing came from officers whose colleagues or subordinates were killed after placing a number of accurate shots on criminals who then lived to serve their sentences in comfort and good health, and he said he had no answers that would prevent that from happening again in the future, only recommendations that would make such incidents a little bit rarer. He took great pains to undermine the idea that the characterization of the real-world performance of any firearm or ammunition load is anything more than statistical, confounded by many other variables. He felt it was wrong to say about any kind of gun or ammunition that it penetrated well or consistently yielded a one-shot stop. He could say that a certain caliber of gun seemed to yield one-hit stops slightly more often than others, but regardless of the caliber you will still see a certain number of four-or-five-hit non-stops followed by the suspect emptying his gun at the officer and then drawing a knife. (I don't think the author put it exactly that way, but it's not snark or exaggeration on my part.) And of course any caliber of gun will yield a one-hit or even zero-hit stop a certain amount of the time, and the best-penetrating round will occasionally fail to penetrate when it matters.

To be more concrete, in a gunfight between (say) a .45 and a .22 fired with equal accuracy, any trained person would want to be holding the .45, but the very clear-cut and undeniable advantage a .45 has over a .22 does not translate to a predictable outcome, any more than having two aces in hold 'em guarantees that you will have the best hand after the flop. You can be 100% certain that a .45 is better than a .22 in that situation, but you can't predict with 100% confidence that the guy with the .45 is going to end up better off after the random confounding variables are figured in. You would bet on the .45, of course, but sometimes you'd be wrong, even measured by the long-term effect of the wounds (which as I understand it is more predictable than the short-term effect of being shot.)

And of course, as I pointed out before, he had excellent reason and opportunity to cherry-pick a perfect example that would surprise his readers and undermine their appetite for generalizations (which appetite many of them doubtless bought his book to feed.)

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by giardini on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @08:05AM (#2031203)
"You disagree with the author, in short, about whether the result of shooting someone with any particular caliber of handgun is consistent and predictable."

No, I merely don't trust that story! It is literally incredible. Human memory is fallible, conflatable, and we often confabulate unconsciously. Were you to provide a citation then I could research it. Perhaps you will remember the author or title after some pondering.

Your AP English classes were not wasted - you're a distractingly excellent writer. But please put down the red fish; you are among friends here (I think).