News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:HTML is the Web by dsr_ on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @07:20AM (#20283858)
The case against Flash was, I think, not so much about what it was, but everything around it.

- It wasn't visually scalable. (Today we say "responsive", mostly, but that's too easy to confuse.)

- It didn't integrate with HTML and CSS in any interesting way other than sitting there in the middle.

- Performance was mediocre to terrible.

- A rent-seeking company was in charge of it.

As you say, eventually JS supplanted it.

Re:HTML is the Web by meerita on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @07:33AM (#20283924)
JS didn't suplanted it from day to night. It was Steve Jobs who killed Flash, not letting Adobe from conquer their new iOS platform. They tried it so hard, even on Android back then, but they failed to deliver something solid. Eventually, both Google and Apple released their SDKs to develop apps, way more solid and faster than running a Adobe Flash player layer on top of the OS. This article shows the jump on technologies, from the CSS perspective http://minid.net/2019/04/07/the-css-utilitarian-methodology/
Re:HTML is the Web by mosdl on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @01:26PM (#20287098)
Flash was already mostly dead by the time the iphone came. Adobe was not investing much into it and it was mainly being used to show videos.
Re:HTML is the Web by meerita on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @03:42PM (#20288400)
I don't think so. Flash was strong in three scenarios: corporate websites, games and advertising. The agency I worked for made 95% of its revenue from Flash work, and most of the agencies in Barcelona, Madrid did the same.
Re:HTML is the Web by masswerk on Thursday June 27, 2019 @02:52AM (#20292267)
The case against Flash was (apart from the horrible security issues) mostly about stacked libraries, including Adobe's own UI library. You could code applications with remarkable performance and small footprint using the pure Flash Player target (neither Flash nor Flex, but pure AS3).

Regarding integration, some text elements featured basic HTML capabilities. Nothing terrific, but you could extend on this. (And, of course, XML parsing, but this is another story.) Also, later Flash Player applications (Air) featured a full-fledged WebKit element for rendering web views. That said, it was good thing that Flash had eventually to go, and, at times, the state of the web today is pretty reminding of this.