They have generally had mixed success, from the ones I've read about. Pretty often there are side effects that aren't good (e.g. bricking some devices, excess traffic due to being too successful, that kind of thing)
But yea, in this case I think it's clearly too complex. There are thousands of different things hooked up to the internet, and you can't fix all of them at once.
If they wait too long, then the result is more sales, which increases profit for the whole ecosystem that produces these devices. But if it's more common and results in returns and exchanges, the result is less profit, which might finally put some pressure where it needs to be.
You'd need a JTAG cable and a fresh firmware image to fix that. Hardly something within the reach of a typical home user.
Let's hope this forces manufacturers to improve their security. That's the main good that needs to come out of this.