News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by lordnacho on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @04:01PM (#20278251)
Ex options MM / hedge fund manager / HFT guy here.

This is a really good article.

The net interest thing has a parallel in the HF world. CTAs, a type of hedge fund, used to do substantially the same thing. The margin requirement for holding a load of futures is quite low, but the customers of the fund have put cash into the fund. So back when interest rates were higher, a fair bit of a CTA's returns would be interest on the cash.

He's right about Robinhood. From the HFT side, the problem is if you're in the "real" institutional market, someone will run you over occasionally. With retail, that never happens, and the spread you can offer is thus tighter. There's no front running to it, just the ease of non toxic flow. So RH is trying to put forward zero comms as a way to get some deposits.

He's also right about options. It's tempting to think that you can just sell some options to collect premium, or do a combination of some sort (iron condors, butterflies, etc) to save yourself from wasting money. But keep in mind the costs when you're doing this, and the fact that you are simply paying up to squish some risk into an unfamiliar shape. It also has a gambling-like tendency to create occasional wins to keep you interested.

As for investment advice for retail people, if you are a coder there doesn't seem to be any reason to use anyone other than IB. They are the cheapest, and if you can code you can use their APIs to trade whatever it is you want. I'm not saying anyone can make a great trading strategy, but you can certainly manage some passive investments with barely any fees. Or just take advantage of RH and do it free I suppose.

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by fyz on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @06:05PM (#20279523)
I agree, this is a very good article.

One consequence of increasing order internalization (because it's a good business, read the article) has been the remaining order flow on the public market is getting more toxic over time, which is part of the reason some (generally higher frequency) hedge fund strategies have done less and less well over the years.

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by cs702 on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @10:46PM (#20281446)
Couldn't agree more on the quality and depth of the article.

I have only one (minor) issue with it. While it's true that the Citadels of the world have zero interest in using "a machine learning algorithm on your neighbor’s GM trades in their IRA to inform their thinking of the true value of GM as a business," I suspect there is value to them in being able to model and predict the aggregate behavior of a mass of retail investors, e.g., for use as an input to macro investing strategies. Retail investors have a reputation for being the last to join every party; there is value in knowing what they are doing in the aggregate.

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by patio11 on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @11:05PM (#20281528)
You don’t need to be an internalizer to capture that, though. Just read the tape: the order for 3 shares that got the sub penny price improvement is the retail one.

(There’s a paper on this somewhere that I think I remember reading when doing level design for Starfighter.)

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by cs702 on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @08:14AM (#20284164)
Good point. Maybe. I don't know if it's possible to discern retail trades in a mass of trades so accurately.
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by gruez on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @12:48AM (#20282012)
Do internalized orders show up on "the tape"? I would think not.
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by evanpw on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @07:04AM (#20283771)
Yes, they do, though it doesn't list the specific internalizer. It looks the same as any dark-pool trade.
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by gruez on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @08:46AM (#20284371)
Is this because of some sort of SEC requirement? Otherwise I can't think of any reason why trading companies would bother reporting it.
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by evanpw on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @09:23AM (#20284719)
Yes, virtually all trades have to be reported.
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by LiamMcCalloway on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @06:14PM (#20279596)
"tighter spread" is a description of the benefit for the retail buyer/seller. Can you elaborate on the benefits to the buyer of order flows?
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by squaresmile on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @06:25PM (#20279674)
This is explained in the article. You can find it in the section "Payment for order flow"

> If you could somehow make markets without informed traders—if you were guaranteed that Goldman could never trade with you—your risk (of being run over) would be lower and you could, therefore, provider tighter spreads. There is a way to do this; it is to trade exclusively with retail traders. They can’t run over you; they don’t have the informational edge or the capital to do so.

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by patio11 on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @07:09PM (#20280169)
Yep. If it isn't explicit enough: the reason you sell liquidity is that people pay for it, hopefully more than it costs you to provide.

You collect, approximately, half the spread less your losses to adverse selection and hope to cover the (pretty formidably high at this point) essentially fixed costs of operating in the market by taking that small margin and parallelizing it over an _extremely_ high number of trades.

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by LiamMcCalloway on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @06:59AM (#20283738)
Let me see if I can rephrase.

Robinhood solves a collective action problem for its users. Unbeknownst to some people, they are unsophisticated and cheap to provide liquidity to: market makers can trade with them and reliably offload their positions, reducing the risk premium necessary to make market making profitable. Robinhood advertises in a fashion that enables self-selection of unsophisticated buyers. Once the platform is sufficiently large, they can auction off the liquidity business. By regulation, the users can never be worse off than they would have otherwise been, because liquidity providers must run their bid-ask spread within the larger market's spread.

So Robinhood earns the difference in risk premium between the larger market and that of its user base, minus operating costs and profits of the liquidity provider.

I suppose the question is: what is the mechanism by which that profit margin can be transferred to users?

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by treis on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @09:49AM (#20284960)
>By regulation, the users can never be worse off than they would have otherwise been, because liquidity providers must run their bid-ask spread within the larger market's spread.

But TFA clearly demonstrates how they are. By removing retail investors the order flow to public market makers is much riskier. Those market makers will respond by increasing the spread to account for the increased risk. So yes, the retail investors get a price that is (very slightly) better than public price but the public price is dramatically worse than it otherwise would be. It's a net loss for the retail investor and public market maker while being a win for the internalized market makers.

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by LiamMcCalloway on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @10:11AM (#20285157)
I don't know enough - merely rephrasing a blog post here - but it sounds fair to say that this reduces the primary benefit of network effects of market activity, higher liquidity/lower spread, at the expense of the rest of the market.

Could we construct a reasonable scenario where the liquidity from segregated order flow would have displaced the core business of liquidity providers, because the volume is so large?

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by usmannk on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @05:40AM (#20283336)
Is selling more liquidity at a tighter spread that much more advantageous than participating in some amount x fewer trades with a looser spread?

In other words, I don't understand if or why it is the case that HFTs would like to, in general, offer tighter spreads than looser ones.

Edit: is it just that volume decreases super linearly in relation to the price of liquidity?

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by evanpw on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @07:03AM (#20283763)
Market makers sell liquidity, and the spread is the price they sell it at, so they'd prefer to sell at a higher price (larger spread). The reason that spreads tighten is competition: there are a few wholesale market makers, and the brokerages send more of their orders to the MM willing to guarantee the smallest spread. In fact, there's been something of a price war for the last few years, and retail spreads have come way down.
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by minhaz23 on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @04:47PM (#20278768)
what do you do now if you dont mind me asking?

how can one as a developer get into that field? I dream of front office positions at those places but the reality seems grim

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by short_sells_poo on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @05:17PM (#20279057)
Find a developer job at a trading firm and gradually move from being a developer to being quant developer and finally to a researcher position. Specifically, aim for systematic trading firms as the sort of work you'll be doing is not that far from what the actual researchers are doing. In discretionary trading businesses, chances are you'll be stuck with some boring back office stuff that is far removed from the actual money making. Furthermore, it's at systematic trading firms that a CS background could add the most value to begin with.

Ninja edit: the business is very much based on personal connections and trust. Unless you have a stellar CV, it's your personal network that will get you to places. People who have worked together and have come to trust each other will tend to run into each other. E.g. you work for a PM who then moves on to another place, chances are they'll ask you to join them.

Out of all the industries, trading is the one where you rely most on others not to sink your career through ineptitude or malice. Hence the extreme emphasis on trust. If you are a PM, it doesn't matter if it's one of your traders and not you directly who fucks up, ultimately you are solely responsible for the PNL. Hence PM's are extremely picky who they let in their circle, but then if you are in good graces, the world is your oyster.

If you are the researcher/trader, you want the PM to be good and support you, because they are the primary multiplier of your performance. The PM's job is to devise the overall strategy and get money for your team. The more money the PM can secure, the more you can play with.

This results in tight knit teams who tend to stick together through jobs. In case someone in your inner circle is starting a new venture, they'll by far prefer to fill in the positions among the most trusted connections before even thinking of looking outside.

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by minhaz23 on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @03:19AM (#20282596)
Thanks for the in depth answer, i truly do appreciate it.

What should I begin studying to put myself in that position in finance?

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by short_sells_poo on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @05:24AM (#20283257)
Contrary to how it is often painted, finance rarely goes above undergraduate level stats. If you have a reasonable handle on that, you are already well set on becoming a quantitative researcher. If not, doing a couple of courses will give you a good grasp on most of what you are likely to encounter. If you like math, that's 50% of the battle won, because learning about the various methodologies will be an exciting discovery and not a slog.

The well kept secret of the industry is that complicated stuff rarely works, and if it does, people often don't exactly know why. Put differently, a good algorithm has obvious and intuitive failure cases. That is, it is (relatively) easy to reason under which market conditions will it work well and when it will not. Extremely complex blackboxes are tricky because it's not obvious when and why they stop working. They are also very easy to overfit. Every single additional parameter you add to a model is an additional degree that you are likely to overfit just because of survivorship bias.

It is for this reason that the absolute vast majority of systematic trading relies more on intimate market knowledge than very secret sauce and super complex ML strategies. Sure, many funds run some token ML crap (which is often quite vanilla, like gaussian processes or decision trees) with very minor impact on PNL, but this is purely for marketing reasons.

There is a small handful of companies who have the manpower, expertise and infrastructure to run more complicated models, but even there, the fundamental ideas tend to be relatively simple, and the complexity arises from the amount of data and market idiosyncrasies.

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by jlelonm on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @04:08PM (#20288621)
> It is for this reason that the absolute vast majority of systematic trading relies more on intimate market knowledge

Aside from reading books about market segments and biographies of companies, what are some things you can do to gain "intimate market knowledge"?

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by short_sells_poo on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @06:09PM (#20289756)
Unfortunately the best (only?) true way is by doing. I suppose prospecting is the best analogy I found. You study geology and gain some theoretical foundations so you understand the relationships and can analyze the results, but you have to go out in the terrain and get your hands dirty so to speak to get true intuition and understanding.

Also, doing it on your own is tricky. You have to constantly talk and mingle with others or you quickly lose insight into current developments. Having a group of people to bounce ideas off of is incredibly important. On your own, every single small topic is a potential rabbit hole that you can spend endless time researching. In a crowd, someone has already explored that rabbit hole most likely and can give you practical pointers. At risk of sounding like a marketing prospectus, there's real synergy in being part of a team. I dare say the age of lone wolf traders is gone. They've been arbitraged away. Successful people have teams behind them.

So I'd say the best way to gain market knowledge is to join a systematic trading shop (in almost any technical capacity) and once inside, you just talk with the others. People in systematic firms tend to have a solid academic approach and are usually more than happy to teach and enlighten anyone interested.

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by minhaz23 on Thursday June 27, 2019 @02:25AM (#20292177)
That just brings us back to the beginning which is how can one break into a systematic trading shop?

What other name do they go by? Like what should I google if im looking for one in my city?

Is there no way for me to get a leg up on gaining that "intimate market knowledge" no insider books or reading/newsletters?

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by yellowstuff on Thursday June 27, 2019 @05:20PM (#20298889)
A recruiter can help you break into the industry. You can contact them directly or apply to jobs that they represent and they will contact you if they're interested. I'm not sure what the market is like these days for junior people, my guess is you need at least a few years of experience as a working programmer before a recruiter would be interested.

There are only a few big systematic funds. I think it's just Two Sigma, Jane Street, Citadel, Point 72/Cubist and AQR. Maybe a few others. You can apply to those yourself, but they're picky. Then you can look on LinkedIn for hedge funds looking for programmers, although it may not be obvious which are discretionary versus systematic.

Hedge funds are only in a few cities. About half are in NYC and Connecticut, then some are in Chicago, Boston, Houston and the Bay area. And maybe a few small ones elsewhere on the West coast, I'm not familiar with that area.

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by evanpw on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @07:18PM (#20280249)
(I'm a quant at a trading firm) On the quant side, the somewhat unfortunate answer is "get a STEM PhD". My firm is always looking to hire quants who are also good (Python / C++) developers, but you'll probably not get past the initial resume screen without a PhD or other serious research experience.
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by bovine3dom on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @07:48AM (#20284003)
In your experience, are quant firms bothered about whether the STEM PhD had anything to do with finance?

I'm considering trying to get into the field when I finish my Comp Sci PhD in a few months. I'm a little worried that my sole explicit financial qualification is that I really enjoyed a course on Black-Scholes towards the end of my undergraduate in Physics, although I probably would word that slightly differently on a CV.

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by evanpw on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @12:49PM (#20286738)
Probably a preference for non-finance fields of study. Might be different at hedge funds doing longer-term trading, but at the short end, academic finance is very far from anything being done in practice.
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by bovine3dom on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @01:43PM (#20287266)
Ah, that's great to know. Thanks for taking the time to reply!
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by chaosbutters on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @07:36AM (#20283946)
that's a pretty low bar (know python and have a STEM phd)
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by icedchai on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @09:44AM (#20284919)
Is this sarcasm? Getting a PhD takes many folks well into their 30's. It's not a "low bar" by any means.
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by skellera on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @04:17PM (#20278434)
If someone only uses Robinhood for normal stock trading (no options, crypto, etc), is it better than using other discount brokerages that charge fees or are there reasons the other ones are better?
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by hbosch on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @04:23PM (#20278504)
I think for usage like you describe, Robinhood is hard to beat considering you want to pick a single equity and buy/sell it. If the goal is to hold stock for a long period of time, what other brokerages offer on top of equities is their funds (some of which, I think, are also available to trade through Robinhood (?) but can also be traded for free on their own platforms).

The other thing you get with a typical brokerage that you don't get, as far as I know, with Robinhood is customer service.

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by hervature on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @04:41PM (#20278705)
As alluded to in his final point, with IB, you can loan your stocks for people to short. This can yield you a substantial revenue stream for stocks with high short interest like TSLA. IB splits it 50/50 (fact check me on this) whereas I assume RH doesn’t even give you the option and uses it for their revenue stream.
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by neural_thing on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @09:28PM (#20281084)
Tesla stock costs under 2% a year to borrow from IB to short it. (source: short TSLA, IB customer)
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by teej on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @09:05PM (#20280966)
TFA says a gain of 7bp. I wouldn’t call that “substantial” in any sense of the word.
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by thedufer on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @07:54AM (#20284033)
> This can yield you a substantial revenue stream for stocks with high short interest

(emphasis mine)

7bp is an average. The article also points out that the yield occasionally goes as high as 100% per year.

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by lordnacho on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @04:32PM (#20278598)
Free is hard to beat. Also keep in mind you could dump your excess cash elsewhere than the broker, right? As long as you're not margin trading, you don't need any cash buffer lying around.

If there's some savings account or bond that pays you a bit, you can stick your cash there.

Might be easier to access via IB, which seems to be a more complete offering, but I haven't actually checked what you can access there.

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by somebodythere on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @05:51PM (#20279375)
You could always buy a ultra-short-term bond ETF within the account if you're planning to float a non-negligible amount of cash.
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by joncrane on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @10:07PM (#20281263)
That was going to be my next question: what kind of fund should the "cash" go into?
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by thedufer on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @07:56AM (#20284042)
Money market funds would likely be appropriate (I believe Vanguard actually does this for you, rather than keeping cash lying around).
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by icedchai on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @09:49AM (#20284968)
They do. Though note that VMMXX (Vanguard Prime Money Market) pays a bit more than VMFXX (Vanguard Federal Money Market.) VMFXX / Federal is their default settlement fund, so if you have large cash holdings it is still advantageous to put it into alternate funds.
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by jogjayr on Thursday June 27, 2019 @11:09AM (#20295092)
Unrelated question: VMMXX has a higher yield (2.35% currently) compared to VMFXX (2.29%) but also has a higher expense ratio (0.16% vs 0.11%). Do these cancel each other out?
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by icedchai on Thursday June 27, 2019 @12:56PM (#20296231)
No, the yields are net of expenses so VMMXX is still slightly higher performing.
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by yellow_postit on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @08:13PM (#20280663)
Not just margin trading as you also need cash available if you want to open a new position quickly since a new transfer/deposit takes a while to clear. This is not making a claim on whether trying to time the market is a good idea.
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by spyspy on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @05:31PM (#20279188)
I appreciate Schwab's other retail banking services, and like having my traditional checking/savings accounts under one roof. Makes moving money in and out of my brokerage account fast and simple. They have free checks and ATM fee rebates. Paying $5 per trade doesn't hurt much when you're 1) buying/selling very infrequently and 2) moving several thousand dollars at a time when you do.
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by brianpgordon on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @04:14AM (#20282870)
Robinhood doesn't have customer service. If you need any kind of service that isn't accessible through the app, you're pretty much out of luck. That's why I only use it for stock picking as a hobby, and not for retirement savings.

Also, you don't get paid interest on uninvested cash balances. Cash in my Schwab checking and brokerage accounts automatically earns interest. Vanguard sweeps cash balances into one of their money market funds. But Robinhood pays nothing, and pockets the money instead.

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by jldugger on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @11:04AM (#20285687)
> But Robinhood pays nothing, and pockets the money instead.

Obviously nothing stops them from paying interest, but they did try that whole Federally insured deposits with interest stunt a while back before the commissioner stepped in to say 'na bro.'

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by joyjoyjoy on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @04:06PM (#20278315)
What makes IB better then TOS?

IB is more international. But in the end you will need at least 3-4 Brokers for a decent international exposure.

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by throwaway9d0291 on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @04:33AM (#20282974)
For me:

- TOS (TD Ameritrade's ThinkOrSwim platform for those unfamiliar) has a much nicer platform but the commissions are so absurd that I just don't consider it.

- IB is cheap.

- IB is great for international exposure. I really don't think you do need another broker. What other broker is superior to IB in which markets?

- IB is amazing at handling multiple currencies. You can deposit and withdraw in any currency I've had need to care for and they're usually local accounts in the relevant country (e.g. USD in US, EU in EU, GBP in UK, CHF in Switzerland etc.). You can also easily and extremely cheaply convert between them.

- IB has an API you can use with low effort and zero cost. TDA does not.

Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by hbosch on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @04:17PM (#20278438)
In general, the top reason to pick IB is for it's customizability and it's super low commissions. TOS/TDA has some of the highest commissions in the industry at something like $7.95 per trade (before negotiating).
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by brianpgordon on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @04:08AM (#20282834)
IB's commission structure is great if you trade frequently, but not for the average "sock money away in index ETFs for retirement" kind of investor.
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by throwaway9d0291 on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @04:35AM (#20282987)
How so? Assuming you're buying say $3k of SPY each month, you'll pay $1/month. Why is that not great?
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by brianpgordon on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @05:04AM (#20283128)
If you have less than $100k in your account then you must spend at least $10/mo on commissions. If you fail to spend $10/mo then they'll just charge you the difference as an activity fee.
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by throwaway9d0291 on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @09:44AM (#20284911)
That's true but I suspect most retirement accounts are worth the $100k.
Re:How Discount Brokerages Make Money by naveen99 on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @08:33PM (#20290722)
i agree blindly selling iron condors / butterflies is asking for hurt. but i love options. the risk shape is perfectly predictable, and easy to become familiar.