News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by natrik on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @02:06PM (#20277055)
Still no compensation offer from the CEO/Co-founder Lisbeth Kaufman

https://medium.com/p/4530d0062e60/responses/show

https://medium.com/@lisbethkaufman_82625/im-one-of-the-cofou...

She also claims their assessment of people signing up to KitSplit is effective at blocking 99.99% of bad actors and stopping millions of dollars of theft on the platform, almost surely an exaggeration.

Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by rhino369 on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @02:31PM (#20277330)
>She also claims their assessment of people signing up to KitSplit is effective at blocking 99.99% of bad actors and stopping millions of dollars of theft on the platform, almost surely an exaggeration.

If this is true, they should easily be able to afford to self insure against theft by charging 10 cents per thousand dollars of gear rented.

Odd that they don't do that huh.

Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by usefulcat on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @03:08PM (#20277737)
That would be true if .01% of all rentals resulted in fraud, but that's not what that sentence says. It could be the case that such "bad actors" represent a disproportionately large share of all rentals.

Which makes sense--if you're planning on stealing the equipment, you'd probably expect to have your account banned so you'd probably try to steal as much as possible while the account is still considered legitimate. As in this case where the author alleges that the same person also stole someone else's gear on the same day.

Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by danShumway on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @04:46PM (#20278760)
> It could be the case that such "bad actors" represent a disproportionately large share of all rentals.

If it's not representative of the actual risk KitSplit will face, then it's also not representative of the actual risk users will face. And if it's not representative of user risk, then it's deceptive for KitSplit to bring it up as a way to defuse the situation or suggest that consumers shouldn't be worried.

Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by StreamBright on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @03:34PM (#20277997)
Not blocking 0.01% means how many bad actors exactly?
Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by heliodor on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @02:24PM (#20277239)
What a tone-deaf response from the cofounder!

The article paints in painful detail how the website claims one thing and the contractual terms do the opposite, resulting in the user being suckered by fine print. Literally, this is a problem of false advertising.

Instead of proper fixes to the problem, they will add more fine print and more reasons to rub it in your face when your gear gets stolen.

Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by theturtletalks on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @03:15PM (#20277795)
Yes, her response seems to assure people the company is legit, not actually trying to help the person in need. Shows a lot about the company.
Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by pixelbath on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @02:40PM (#20277432)
Not only no compensation, I see no actual apology, and aside from a quick note about how they'll re-vet users after they change their profile info (they weren't doing this already?), there's a whole lot of text explaining how it will still be your fault if the equipment gets stolen.

In the end, there's not even a "contact me to get this sorted" link; it's just another call to engage with first-tier support some more.

Just use Craigslist if you're looking to make money off your high-end gear; at least then, you can know with a higher likelihood that you're being scammed.

Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by droithomme on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @02:55PM (#20277593)
Craigslist legally is better. I can look at the person's driver's license myself, and have him sign a legally binding contract agreeing to return the item (like all rental shops do) and I can even collect a deposit that I won't return if he doesn't return.

That is much much much better than this scenario. It's a big mystery also how the company claims to take a deposit for the full value of the equipment, and then apparently just keeps the deposit themselves when the item is stolen? Really?

Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by adrr on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @04:47PM (#20278771)
$70(rental fee) / 30%(Kitsplit cut) = $21 revenue

99.99 means one stolen item out of 10,000. So they'll make $210,000(using articles info) but can't pay $3,500 to cover a stolen item out of that revenue. I bet the CEO is lying about the theft rate.

Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by kennywinker on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @05:34PM (#20279212)
They don’t even seem to acknowledge this as a theft (voluntary parting?!) so I have NO doubt that 99.99 number is fake as hell.
Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by optimuspaul on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @05:48PM (#20279344)
that's what I got from it, "voluntary parting" doesn't figure into the theft number because they can't/won't acknowledge those thefts as theft.
Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by Aleran on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @05:39PM (#20279265)
$70 was the camera owner's revenue after Kitsplit had taken their cut. The rental fee was higher than $70.
Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by iooi on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @02:24PM (#20277245)
> We have 6 different FAQs that warn KitSplit users about the risk of voluntary parting.

Ouch, so this isn't the first person to get bit by this on KitSplit, just the first one to get traction. These companies need to get called out way more.

Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by ddalex on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @02:30PM (#20277312)
They have automated emails for dealing with "voluntary parting". This is a stronger indication of trouble than anything else.
Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by Beefin on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @02:28PM (#20277290)
How can consumers review/evaluate platforms like this? Is there a Yelp meets Crunchbase for companies that operate worldwide?
Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by egman_ekki on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @04:15PM (#20278417)
You mean something like trustpilot, only without the possibility to remove negative reviews for money?
Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by kevin_b_er on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @02:56PM (#20277605)
They claim they've stopped "millions of dollars of theft", but how about "voluntary parting" since its apparently not "theft"? How much "voluntary parting" have they stopped?
Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by moxidize on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @03:22PM (#20277871)
So from what I gather, the only parties that can potentially become "bad actors" are owners who fail to deliver the product and renters who cause a "voluntary parting" of over $200,000 in equipment - and that's how they end up at their 1/10000 incidence rate.

So perhaps KitSplit's strategy of blocking bad actors is to redefine them as neutral ones, converting millions in theft into millions in "partings" - which might not be an exaggeration.

Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by robocat on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @06:29PM (#20279708)
The 1/10000 is only for theft. It doesn't include voluntary parting. Thanks kennywinker's comment in thread.
Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by usefulcat on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @02:57PM (#20277611)
> She also claims their assessment of people signing up to KitSplit is effective at blocking 99.99% of bad actors and stopping millions of dollars of theft on the platform

Interesting way to phrase it: "..effective at blocking 99.99% of bad actors". It sounds precise yet it is anything but because it says nothing about how many "bad actors" there are. Hundreds? Thousands? Millions? And over what period of time? A year? A day? 5 minutes? Any one of those factors could make orders of magnitude difference to the chance that one's property will be stolen.

If fraud were really as infrequent as they seem to suggest, then it seems like they should be able to absorb the losses. As it is, it appears they've so far concluded that the negative publicity will cost them less than the actual losses.

Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by droithomme on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @02:52PM (#20277559)
> She also claims their assessment of people signing up to KitSplit is effective at blocking 99.99% of bad actors

Elsewhere is the figure 0.1%, off by a factor of 10. It's not clear whether 1 in 1000 or 1 in 10000 rentals results in theft.

However, just because 1 in 1000 rentals results in theft doesn't mean one's assessment is 99.9% effective in blocking bad actors.

Bad actors are currently a tiny minority of their users. Apparently 1 in 1000. If you blocked 99.99% of them, then theft would drop to 1 in 10,000,000 rentals. Her claimed numbers make no sense in the context of their actual theft rates. And yes, legally under criminal law it is theft, it is not voluntary parting. Voluntary parting does not appear to be a principle from criminal law and instead is something invented by insurance industry contract attorneys to deny responsibility for insurance claims.

Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by differentView on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @03:00PM (#20277637)
Most likely that number was pulled out of her ass.
Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by ska on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @07:03PM (#20280100)
Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by bxio on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @07:09PM (#20280162)
Ooh, another opportunity to push product.

So you gotta purchase optional insurance in additional to the 22% platform fees. Certainly makes the prospect of renting out my kit worth thousands of dollars for literal tens of dollars all the more attractive.

Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by hisnameisjimmy on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @07:11PM (#20280186)
Very similar to AirBnB's realization and about-face after the destruction of someone's home. Good on her for coming around and doing the right thing.
Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by e_proxus on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @07:16AM (#20283833)
Perhaps good for future customers, but not really for all the ones that have been scammed before and left in the cold by the company.

I can't see this as anything other than "privatizing the profits, socializing the losses" approach that most new gig-economy startups use. First they try to get away with as much as possible, until negative PR or legal requirements forces them to change. And then it's suddenly "a new feature" that they're so proud to announce (even though they created the problem in the first place).

Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by differentView on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @04:34PM (#20278617)
99.99% of time when people say "99.99%" it's just made up.
Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by hotgoldminer on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @02:28PM (#20277283)
10 BPs.. Also if they're letting the fraudsters continue to use the service (why wouldn't they if they're generating risk-free fee income to KitSplit), the fraudsters are likely more active the typical users. So if 1/1000 users are fraudsters and fraudsters are 10x more active than regular users, odds are 1 in 100 that your gear gets stolen. Ludicrous.
Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by trhway on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @03:57PM (#20278209)
> This is because the renter is the client who purchases the policy and the insurance company can not file a claim against its client, the renter. That would force the insurance company to file a claim against itself, which is not how insurance works.

just a pile of incoherent absurd BS. Looks like that CEO has no idea what she is talking about. How for example does she think auto accidents are handled when both participants have the same insurance company?

Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by duiker101 on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @06:39PM (#20279826)
Well it seems like they don't consider this voluntary parting their problem so it's probably not in that statistic. I'm sure it would have a pretty big drop if it were included.
Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by go_ruby on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @06:33PM (#20279766)
Exaggeration is charitable, it's probably an outright lie.
Re:How I Got my $3500 Camera Kit Stolen on KitSplit by anth_anm on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @03:36PM (#20278012)
If it wasn't an exaggeration then I would think they apologize for the inconvenience and pay the guy back. 0.01% would mean 1 in 10000 have an issue.