Re:Earbuds are bad for your hearing
by sushisource on Monday June 24, 2019 @08:20PM
(#20269955)
Additionally, I think the marketing around active noise cancelling has been so good that most people have no clue a good pair of in-ear earbuds can do just as well (without causing the weird artifacting that active cancelling can) passively.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Properly fitted in-ear monitors do better, because they can block unpredictable sound sources. Active noise cancellation does a very good job of reducing the constant hum of aircraft engines, but very little to block the sound of a crying baby.
For the open office, my Sony XM3s are extremely easy to take on and off in an instant - and offer extremely good cancellation, and OK sound quality for programming.
My Audio Technica ATH-IM02 earbuds in comparison require very careful positioning, even though it offers far superior quality in a quiet environment.
I use the "palm on the side" feature a lot. It reduces the music volume and turns up the ambient noise. If I'm not mistaken, it also increases the volume of voices so you can hear conversations well.
Yep, the ambient function is great; Sony has really nailed it for use in the office. I'm seeing lots of coworkers picking this up.
What kind of earbuds do you mean? Those incredibly expensive custom molded ones? I have some foam tipped earbuds (Tinaudio T2) and the isolation seems pretty good compared to other earbuds I have previously owned but nowhere near the 1000XM3 active noise canceling.
Re:Earbuds are bad for your hearing
by plorkyeran on Monday June 24, 2019 @11:28PM
(#20270927)
Silicone tips work much better than foam tips for me. I currently use Shure SE215s and the passive noise blocking when using silicone tips seems similar to (but not better than) the old quietcomforts I've used.
Before using custom molded IEMs I used Etymotics with foam tips, which had much thicker foam than what I see on the Tinaudio product page. The isolation with foam is just as good, if properly inserted (same technique as with foam earplugs: roll to compress, insert deeply, and hold in place until fully expanded). But after only a few insertions the foam starts to lose its resiliency and sound-blocking effectiveness.
Custom IEMs can isolate noise almost as well as fully inserted foam earplugs, and they take only a second to insert or remove. The convenience and sound-blocking consistency are why I prefer them to "universal" tipped IEMs.
> Those incredibly expensive custom molded ones?
Cheapo shure se215 with triple flange or foam tips and you're golden. I have them on all day and I even manage to sleep with them (when I accidentally fall asleep while listening to a podcast)