News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by WorldMaker on Monday June 24, 2019 @01:28PM (#20266039)
Part of our trouble with climate change is that price is not strongly correlated with carbon, and our economic models are not carbon-sensitive. Cheaper does not mean "less carbon intensive", it just means presumably less demand and/or more supply of that model on the market.
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by tonyedgecombe on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @02:05PM (#20277034)
In this case it means less material in the car and less costs in the supply chain.

You just need to look at the dance the price of oil and the health of the economy go through to realise money and energy are deeply intertwined. It’s not obvious to me that we can completely decouple them.

Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by WorldMaker on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @03:42PM (#20278075)
Without something like carbon taxes the supply chains and economy will never correctly account for carbon because it is an externality.

The price of oil itself has no correlation with carbon output. (Total production numbers might tell you something, but that is only vaguely related to price in market economics, given the competing forces of supply and demand. Total usage numbers would tell you a lot more, but isn't a statistic even tracked by economics and if it has any correlation on price depends on the type of demand [elastic versus static] whether it is following/lagging or pushing the price.)

Sure money and energy can be considered intertwined, but not all energy is carbon, don't forget that as much as business tries to underprice it, a lot of the energy reflected in a supply chain is labor (which admittedly people do also produce carbon, but exhalation effort is not something I've ever seen properly reflected in someone's wages).

So again: higher prices in EVs and EV supply chains absolutely does not correlate with carbon costs. EVs generally have less material because a) weight matters a lot more, and b) fewer moving parts / simpler drive trains.

Price differences likely reflect other market realities such as supply/demand and things like perceived luxury.