Here is where the article misses: No matter what, your numbers have to be right. I'm a firm believer in the invisible hand. If, as an Investor, you set your market rent too high - you may never find tenants. That's just one example.
Investors aren't the problem. Wholesalers (part of the group of Aggressive marketers) play a role in driving up prices taking aggressive finders fees (called Assignment Fees) for finding the properties for investors. Thing is, if they price their assignment fee too high, they may never find an Investor (flipper) to assign their contract to. Once again, market dictates it. If there is no meat left on the bone for the flipper to create their end product (based on current Retail comps) then they'll get stuck with the contract and a large majority can't close the deal on their own. Just join a wholesaler group on Facebook and you'll see the amount of inexperienced people trying to make a buck.
"Fix & Rent" is where the market is headed, for two reasons:
1. the market for single-family fix-and-flip projects is compressing, meaning the profit margin is getting slimmer.
2. the data points to younger people preferring to rent. my own opinion is that it points to them not being able to afford to buy, but regardless: house rentals is a big market, much bigger than many expected.
my take is that the main drawback is that within a certain price range this is bound to drive prices up, making it harder for normal people to purchase a home. and nearly impossible for normal people to find a deal.
Personally, though, I don't believe that younger people preferring to rent is making that big an impact. That's something you see in only a few cities in the US, and most investors who are trying to make money via rentals actively avoid those cities (saturated market).
Turnkey investing - where companies have worked it all out for you and you merely deal with the cash end of it - is usually not profitable for the investor. If you hang out around RE investors, they'll caution you on how it seems very alluring because you don't need much knowledge and someone else is managing everything else. But these companies need to make a profit, and so you'll get less of the pie - and they have every incentive to make a deal look better than it is.
The exception is in up and coming neighborhoods.
The article mentions this, but doesn't go into detail: Many of the houses being sold were never on the market. Aggressive marketers contact existing owners and ask if they want to sell, and some small percentage of owners will agree (need cash quickly, etc). Had this not happened, the houses would still not be available as the owner did not intend to put them on the market. It's like complaining that I am screwing up the used car market by asking people if they want to sell their car.
When someone makes $40K+ on a flip, it's almost always the case that the house was in a bad enough shape that a bank wouldn't finance it. So once again, had they not bought and flipped the house, none of the people profiled in the article would have been able to buy it anyway (nor would they want to, being in bad shape and all). They're not stealing houses to make a good profit. They are making it easier for people to buy that house, while they make a profit. It's not a zero sum game.
Almost all flippers hope to sell at market price, and probably at least half list the house at slightly below market price as they need to sell fast. Why? Because most flippers are not using much of their own money. They'll get a hard money loan at, say, 10 or 12% interest to buy the property, and possibly also to fund the repair. Every month they have the house is costing them big bucks. They aim to fix and sell fast to minimize their interest payments. So it's not a case that they are aiming to inflate housing prices. Quite the contrary, it often works out better for them to sell it quicker at a slightly lower than market price.
Now when it comes to investors sweeping up houses and renting them - yeah, that could be a long term problem.
But really: As someone who has an idea on how real estate investing works, my criticism is that one can read this whole article and still not have much of an idea.