Re:Building an LTE Access Point with a Raspberry Pi
by voltagex_ on Monday June 24, 2019 @12:35AM
(#20260585)
Can you comment on Ethernet being more power hungry than Wifi? That's the first time I've heard that.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Building an LTE Access Point with a Raspberry Pi
by eigenloss on Monday June 24, 2019 @12:43AM
(#20260614)
Ethernet usually requires isolation magnetics and transformers, while WiFi is basically just a wire sticking out of an RFIC.
Re:Building an LTE Access Point with a Raspberry Pi
by pjc50 on Monday June 24, 2019 @07:59AM
(#20262597)
It's not so much that the transformers consume more power than just radiating it into the air, but that Ethernet is not designed with power efficiency as a goal. Ethernet devices that need more power usually get it from PoE instead.
Without doing any analysis at all, I suspect the idle behaviour is a big difference; Wifi goes silent if there's no traffic, apart from AP beacons, but Ethernet continuously transmits "fast link pulses" every 16 miliseconds to maintain autonegotiation and detect connection lost.
Re:Building an LTE Access Point with a Raspberry Pi
by KirinDave on Monday June 24, 2019 @06:56PM
(#20269393)
Honestly I dunno why it was the case for me. What I know is that I thought I'd save power pushing pulses over copper rather than using a radio. I didn't. In fact it was consistently about 40% worse than wifi.
That might be unique to the RPi hardware I used. It might not.
Maybe I should have written that article. :)
Re:Building an LTE Access Point with a Raspberry Pi
by londons_explore on Monday June 24, 2019 @07:38PM
(#20269671)
The Pi does Ethernet with a seperate and pretty power hungry chip.
If the ethernet cable is disconnected, that chip mostly powers down.
I think it's a Pi related thing rather than being inherent to Ethernet. In fact, if I were to guess, the energy per bit per meter of ethernet is probably far far lower than WiFi.