News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why nuclear energy is not the answer to solve climate change by candiodari on Sunday June 23, 2019 @02:51PM (#20257833)
Sorry to say, but that doesn't work. 1 hectare/Mwh, abstract over any issues. What happens when renewables actually achieve what they set out to do: what happens when PV gets used for 50% of power ? What happens when it's at 80% ?

1 hectare/Mwh = 1e-5 km2/kwh

1e-5 km2/kwh * 450 billion kwh / 650000 km2 = 7 times the area of France

Obviously this is not practical. At 10% you'd have to destroy significant amounts of the remaining nature in France. God help Belgium and the Netherlands should they try this, so France is definitely not a worst case scenario. You'd have to get the power from Africa. Yes, the US could (just barely, and only with a much bigger electricity grid). Russia could. China is actually dicey (at 7% growth per year it won't stay dicey for long and dive into "not happening" soon). Not many others.

Also: at any scale solar PV will displace so much nature it will be worse for the planet than fossil fuels. At 1% ? No problem. But at 1%, fossil fuels aren't a problem either. At 1%, coal would be tolerable. At 100% ? Nuclear works. Alternatives ... uh ... None (I mean, there's fusion when it starts working)

Simcity was right.

https://www.worlddata.info/europe/france/energy-consumption....

https://www.google.com/search?q=france+area

Re:Why nuclear energy is not the answer to solve climate change by fulafel on Sunday June 23, 2019 @04:21PM (#20258415)
I mixed the units, obviously it's per MW and not MWh.

Anyway, many people have done this calculation and the lamd required in an 100 % pv scenario seems pretty reasonable:

https://landartgenerator.org/blagi/archives/127

https://energy-age.blogspot.com/2017/04/how-much-land-area-d...

Doing my own napkin calc for 100% PV globally: using 2.5e6 MW world consumption, and 150 e6 sq km of land i get 60 km2 (6000 hectares) existing land for each MW consumed. So panels would take 1/6000 of land, or maybe 1/1000 if the 1 MW was for rated max power and we actually average 1/6 of that