News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why nuclear energy is not the answer to solve climate change by fulafel on Sunday June 23, 2019 @06:00AM (#20254353)
Area in obviously linear vs PV power, not exponential. Yes, the difference vs nuclear gets exponential because nuclear reactors are 3D, but in practice the reactor core size is always so small that it takes trivial space in the land use sense.

There is no dearth of space in most countries to fit village / farm sized solar arrays. 1 hectare per 1 MWH approx works out to good numbers considering you can use the non arable land. You can google around about how land owners bargain about leasing land to pv farms, it's pretty obviosu that even at the current artificially low energy prices[1] it's working out well.

[1] meaning fossil plants mostly don't pay for externalities so electricity price is largely determined by just fossil plant fuel / equipment costs.

Re:Why nuclear energy is not the answer to solve climate change by candiodari on Sunday June 23, 2019 @02:51PM (#20257833)
Sorry to say, but that doesn't work. 1 hectare/Mwh, abstract over any issues. What happens when renewables actually achieve what they set out to do: what happens when PV gets used for 50% of power ? What happens when it's at 80% ?

1 hectare/Mwh = 1e-5 km2/kwh

1e-5 km2/kwh * 450 billion kwh / 650000 km2 = 7 times the area of France

Obviously this is not practical. At 10% you'd have to destroy significant amounts of the remaining nature in France. God help Belgium and the Netherlands should they try this, so France is definitely not a worst case scenario. You'd have to get the power from Africa. Yes, the US could (just barely, and only with a much bigger electricity grid). Russia could. China is actually dicey (at 7% growth per year it won't stay dicey for long and dive into "not happening" soon). Not many others.

Also: at any scale solar PV will displace so much nature it will be worse for the planet than fossil fuels. At 1% ? No problem. But at 1%, fossil fuels aren't a problem either. At 1%, coal would be tolerable. At 100% ? Nuclear works. Alternatives ... uh ... None (I mean, there's fusion when it starts working)

Simcity was right.

https://www.worlddata.info/europe/france/energy-consumption....

https://www.google.com/search?q=france+area

Re:Why nuclear energy is not the answer to solve climate change by fulafel on Sunday June 23, 2019 @04:21PM (#20258415)
I mixed the units, obviously it's per MW and not MWh.

Anyway, many people have done this calculation and the lamd required in an 100 % pv scenario seems pretty reasonable:

https://landartgenerator.org/blagi/archives/127

https://energy-age.blogspot.com/2017/04/how-much-land-area-d...

Doing my own napkin calc for 100% PV globally: using 2.5e6 MW world consumption, and 150 e6 sq km of land i get 60 km2 (6000 hectares) existing land for each MW consumed. So panels would take 1/6000 of land, or maybe 1/1000 if the 1 MW was for rated max power and we actually average 1/6 of that