News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Facebook never happened in the UK. The case of FitFin... by gst on Monday December 20, 2010 @03:41AM (#2023776)
From the article linked within the linked article: "The site attracted five million hits in the month since its launch, but despite its success UCL asked Martell to shut it down. After he refused, the university fined him £300 for “bringing the college into disrepute”. If he doesn’t pay up, he risks not being allowed to graduate."

So do I get this correct?

1) The service is not hosted at or by the university

2) The service does not seem to violate any of the university's trademarks

But:

3) The university fines the student for £300

4) The university forces the student to shutdown the service

Maybe the culture here at my university is somewhat different - but for me this is a rather large WTF. Based on which facts should a university have the options to fine a student or to shutdown such a service?

Re:Why Facebook never happened in the UK. The case of FitFin... by derefr on Monday December 20, 2010 @04:03AM (#2023805)
And even then, if I was presented these options, I would take the third path: transfer to another university to finish my degree.
Re:Why Facebook never happened in the UK. The case of FitFin... by StavrosK on Monday December 20, 2010 @06:01AM (#2023960)
As an alum, I must say:

What the fuck, UCL?

Re:Why Facebook never happened in the UK. The case of FitFin... by iuygtrftghyujik on Monday December 20, 2010 @11:16AM (#2024718)
UCL has shifted a little from it's original founder's views.

the presence of students while bringing a certain youthful air to the surroundings does detract from it's professional image as a successful media and marketing organisation

Re:Why Facebook never happened in the UK. The case of FitFin... by DannoHung on Monday December 20, 2010 @06:43AM (#2024009)
Could be a mad-with-power office within the uni that decided to try and intimidate a student. Universities usually have review boards about this sort of thing before actually taking action though.
Re:Why Facebook never happened in the UK. The case of FitFin... by richardburton on Monday December 20, 2010 @10:18AM (#2024513)
I couldn't believe it when it was shut down. It spread like crazy across Edinburgh. I read an article saying that Richard Marttel wanted to go into bank programming. Why?