News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra by logfromblammo on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @11:04AM (#20213867)
Every mortal may be ousted from their offices; the wisest will provide a peaceful means for doing so.

As Zuckerberg has obviated any lawful means of removing him, by structuring the stock classes such that he holds the majority of votes, he should probably hire more personal security. If he's going to be someone that's completely unaccountable for his actions as head of the company from within the accepted structures, he should anticipate that someone will try to go outside those structures to get to him.

Ordinary people protect themselves from such attacks by not being untouchable jerkwads. He has already left that particular stratagem far behind.

Re:Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra by pyronite on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @11:13AM (#20213979)
With comments like this, I can understand why he would need personal security. I feel like this rhetoric is dangerous. It sounds to me as if you might be suggesting this sort of "solution" has some legitimacy. I apologize if that's not how you meant it.
Re:Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra by liopleurodon on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @11:29AM (#20214164)
Perhaps The French Revolution was illegitimate and the royal family should be ruling France right now.....
Re:Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra by GuiA on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @11:58AM (#20214517)
Well, the French Revolution certainly was illegitimate in that it was “not authorized by the law; not in accordance with accepted standards or rules“.

And it’s one of the best things that ever happened in human history.

Re:Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra by otakucode on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @12:56PM (#20215202)
I think they're being reasonable. Have a sense of history and of scale. Wars have been fought and millions died for issues much smaller and amounts of money much more meager. When you get to a certain size, when your actions literally affect over a billion human beings, and when there is more capital tied up in your venture than in many small nations... why on earth would you expect people to suddenly not treat you the exact same way nations are treated, up to and including armed insurrection? I don't support such a notion in Facebooks case, but I do think it would be wise for anyone dealing with numbers that big to consider history. Has a war ever been fought over the amount you are dealing with? Are you doing something a war was fought in the past to stop?
Re:Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra by ken on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @12:24PM (#20214790)
I don't think he's suggesting anyone should do anything violent. I think he's suggesting that if Zuckerberg continues down this road, he's going to face problems by whatever routes remain available. The only thing GP said anyone should do is Zuckerberg should "probably hire more personal security".

Would it have come across as less of a threat if he had quoted JFK ("Those who make peaceful revolution impossible will make violent revolution inevitable")? Was JFK threatening Latin America when he said that to their diplomats?

Re:Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra by freewilly1040 on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @12:36PM (#20214927)
This is a very common rhetorical tactic for people who wish to advocate violence. Parent comment is not advocating violence by asking someone to commit a violent act, they are advocating violence by arguing that violence is reasonable / inevitable.
Re:Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra by logfromblammo on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @02:05PM (#20216295)
Crime exists. I advocate that everyone apply whatever measures that fit within their means to ameliorate it, or avoid it altogether.

It applies on the small scale as easily as the grand. If you insult someone's mother, watch for and avoid the retaliatory punch. If you violate the privacy of a billion people, call them morons for trusting you, profit greatly from their personal information, and continue to demonstrate eroding ethics, then install a safe room in your house(s) and hire some bodyguards.

That said, individual violence is reasonable, after the non-violent and collectively-violent possibilities have been exhausted. There always has to be some way to effectively retaliate against anti-social behavior.

Re:Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra by joyeuse6701 on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @01:33PM (#20215771)
True, though I'd argue he doesn't need to use the rhetorical tactic. Tyrants invite violence implicitly when they exercise their power over the weak.
Re:Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra by logfromblammo on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @11:48AM (#20214397)
It is not "legitimate". That word shares a root with "legal". But we should not pretend that some people do not do illegal things when the stakes are high enough.

Rich people get kidnapped and held for ransom to fund rebellions or criminal cartels. It's a thing that happens. Even heads of state get assassinated from time to time. It's a thing that happens. At the level of super-rich that Zuckerberg inhabits, I'd guess he already gets at least 2 attempts at theft, robbery, blackmail, or extortion per year, and some of them might even be successful. It's a thing that happens. People don't like to talk about it, because the successes encourage further attempts.

There were even GTA 5 missions entirely about manipulating public stock prices by criminally compromising or killing a company's CEO. That's how the player can make all three of their player-characters multi-billionaires.

I'm simply saying that if the only way someone can get to you is via criminality, then that is the way someone will get to you. Most people would always try the "legitimate", peaceful option first, if there is one. That's the primary reason why people choose to leave themselves open to the law. Surrendering to the marshals or getting arrested by state professionals is a more favorable alternative than getting caught by an angry mob. Just ask Qaddafi.

It's just engineering. If your structure is designed to fail at one weak point, then you can monitor that possibility more carefully, and predict the behavior following that particular failure. You can purposefully put in a weak element, so that if the structure collapses at all, it will do so more slowly and in a safer direction. In a corporate structure, you allow yourself to be removed by majority vote, and the failure mode is that you get paid off and live on in semi-retirement. Remove that option, and you don't know how you'll leave your office. It might be a memento-mori-scale heart attack, or complete failure of the company, or a sudden black screen as "Don't Stop Believing" plays on the jukebox.

In the wake of the vote to remove him, Zuckerberg could either step down voluntarily, or increase his security. He won't do the former, so he should do the latter.

Re:Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra by zergblush on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @11:30AM (#20214187)
He’s providing an economics type analysis.
Re:Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra by landryraccoon on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @11:37AM (#20214268)
Oh for crying out loud. If it bothers you that much, delete Facebook and all apps related to the FB ecosystem from your phone and install a tracking blocker. If enough people do this, then Facebook ceases to be relevant just as much as Myspace did.

If that won't work because everyone else is on Facebook, then obviously most people don't share your opinion that Zuck is that big of a threat that needs to be ousted right? So you either have to accept that the majority of people are ok with it or convince them to ditch Facebook also.

Re:Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra by MereInterest on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @12:01PM (#20214564)
Suppose a hundred people have my contact information. If any one of those hundred people decide that Facebook gets access to their phone, then Facebook gets my information. The "vote" of pro-facebook counts 100x that of a vote against facebook.

This is not to say that I condone corporate assassination, just to say that your appeal to the majority is woefully inaccurate.

Re:Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra by esoterica on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @12:15PM (#20214712)
All that proves is that you have no reasonable expectation of privacy wrt your phone number. Any piece of information that has to be disseminated to untrusted parties to be of any use (like a phone number or email address) is by definition not private.
Re:Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra by oarsinsync on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @12:37PM (#20214940)
Or anything else that goes in an address book entry associated with your phone number.

Like your full name, job title, employer, email address, physical address, date of birth, social media profiles, family relations... the list goes on.

All of that associated information is often stored alongside your phone number. If one person you know does that, and also uses a facebook property and shares their address book through that (e.g. whatsapp), facebook has all that information about you.

If you're curious, check the list of additional fields you can add to a contact in your address book for how much Facebook could get about you

Re:Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra by esoterica on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @01:49PM (#20215989)
None of those are private info. And if they are, why does your contact know it?
Re:Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra by oarsinsync on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @04:19PM (#20217949)
My contact knows my name, job title and employer because they’re a colleague. There is no public record of my employment. It is private information.

How do I keep it from Facebook if my colleague uses WhatsApp, by simply opting out from using Facebook myself?

Re:Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra by esoterica on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @05:15PM (#20218499)
Again, you have a misguided mental model of what it means for something to be private information. If several of your colleagues know your job title and employer then you have already surrendered control over the dissemination of those pieces of information to them and they are no longer private.
Re:Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra by oarsinsync on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @06:32AM (#20222159)
I feel like there's a line between private and public information that's getting lost here. Maybe 'non-public'? Just because I've shared something with someone (by necessity, in some cases - they work for the same employer as me, so they know I work here) doesn't mean it's public information.

Or to follow that on, if several people see what medication you've purchased in a shop, is that information now public information? Has the expectation of privacy gone out of the window because it was witnessed by another person? Does that then justify that information being shared with 1+ corporations to add to their profile of you?

Re:Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra by MereInterest on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @09:53AM (#20223342)
I'd definitely agree with that, and think that is what esoterica is missing. I don't think it is reasonable to have a strict binary line between public and private, because there exist many gradations. If I am in my home, I can reasonably expect that nobody is going to be watching through my windows with a telescope from a hundred yards away. If I am at the White House, I can reasonably expect that my every movement is going to be tracked. If I am at the grocery store, it is somewhere in-between. People can see me, what I am buying, and what I look at, but that is transient information.

This transient information is the category that modern surveillance is destroying. I think this is a useful category, as it allows for less stress of interaction, as each interaction is only relevant for a few days. Previously, it decayed over time as people forgot, or as tapes were overwritten. Soon, we are going to need mandatory data expiration policies to maintain this category of things that are public for a short time, and private afterward.

Re:Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra by bambax on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @11:57AM (#20214496)
The majority is not always right. In fact, it is often wrong. Corrupt politicians invariably argue that they should not be held accountable and that we should instead "let the people decide" (by voting). But that's not how society has worked up to that point (at least, it's not how it was supposed to work, even if practice differs from theory).

Nowadays we seem to argue that since Mark Zuckerberg has not actually killed people with his bare hands, everything's fine. Everything is not fine. Facebook is a threat to humanity.

Re:Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra by landryraccoon on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @04:46PM (#20218226)
The majority is not always right, but the majority almost always gets its way.

Let’s say you’re right. Even if you overthrow the majority they won’t like it. What are you advocating? That there’s a shortcut via authoritarianism because the majority can’t be trusted?

Democracy has no shortcuts. Convince the majority you are right or live with the majority opinion.

Re:Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra by bambax on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @07:24PM (#20219456)
I am advocating regulations, and their impassioned enforcement.
Re:Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra by givinguflac on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @12:06PM (#20214615)
Yes, because facebook users tend to be marvelously well informed and certainly don't exist in a narrative bubble.