(Granted, buried somewhere in your contract for renting the "venue" you've probably agreed to such a thing but that doesn't make this analogy a good one)
If I hypothetically sleep with hundred people and they all show pics of me naked to their friends, I will still not expect penis enlargement companies mailing me their new catalog.
Also I think the analogy the lawyers brought up is misleading. Instead of renting out an arena, it's more like just one of those friends accepted a 1000-page terms of service a couple decades ago for a random forum, and instead of "rebroadcasting" what's "disclosed" at one party, it's more like the forum is now publishing their per-minute GPS location for the past year.
And we can already see this happening, with younger people moving to more and more personal spaces (like say Fortnite chats) instead of using facebook.
The goal of facebook, or anybody else who aims to be a digital public space, must be to give users granular control and transparent expectations about who they broadcast to, because if that isn't the case communities will not exist and the only thing that's left is highly curated, generic blogspam.
And even more importantly, the system must be designed in a way to stay at human-scale and to reign in the virality that destroys privacy expectations.
So they need to STOP using the term "Friends" and start using the term "Friends and Corporations" instead.
Yeah, no. Shall Not Be Infringed. You don't get your cake, and to eat it too.
Facebook needs to get itself in order. In fact, the tech community as a whole needs to realize that just because they can tap into some data source, doesn't mean they should.
Yet all is public information and happened in a location with no expectation of privacy.
It’s not socially acceptable to go and rummage through someone else trolley and confirm what’s in there.
> I go into a classroom and invite a hundred friends. This courtroom. I invite a hundred friends, I rent out the courtroom, and I have a party. And I disclose — And I disclose something private about myself to a hundred people, friends and colleagues. Those friends then rent out a 100,000-person arena, and they rebroadcast those to 100,000 people. I have no cause of action because by going to a hundred people and saying my private truths, I have negated any reasonable expectation of privacy, because the case law is clear.
Was there more context the article left out about the specific level of privacy the party expected?