News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Learning Chess at 40 (2016) by WalterBright on Friday June 14, 2019 @04:14AM (#20181279)
I can't say I understand devoting such time to learning a completely useless, extremely narrow, skill. Learning mathematics is useful. Learning to play a guitar is useful. Learning to program is useful.

I came to this conclusion in college. It was hard enough learning math, thermo, physics, etc., and seemed a complete waste of time to get better at chess. The former consumed my mental energies.

Re:Learning Chess at 40 (2016) by danielbarla on Friday June 14, 2019 @04:50AM (#20181436)
Chess is just about the most highly refined competitive intellectual task / "sport" you can ask for (by sheer weight of the number of serious players, and the level of play, though a similar argument can be made for Go). In and of itself, that could be an interesting concept to explore. And if we reject it, I suspect we'd also have to reject other competitive endaevours, like soccer, tennis, etc. To be honest, I sometimes do wonder why we as a species seems to be so intensely focused on silly, "useless" skills like running the 100m in under 10 seconds. I guess it's in our nature to be competitive.

(Obligatory "I didn't downvote you")

Re:Learning Chess at 40 (2016) by WalterBright on Friday June 14, 2019 @06:44AM (#20181902)
I long ago lost the remotest interest in who wins a baseball/tennis/football/olympic game, as it's meaningless. I know people get all wrapped around the axle on who wins, and the ludicrous propaganda of "medal counts" in the Olympics. But it's not for me.

I have found it interesting to write software to play chess for me. The last few times I tried to play chess, my mind would just drift off designing a program to do it so I wouldn't have to bother.

I don't play video games, either. It takes about 3 minutes for one to bore me to tears. Part of that is I had a job in college testing video games - that sure ruined it for me.

The universe is full of puzzles that mean something to solve. Why not work on those instead? Why would those be less interesting than a contrived set of rules?

Re:Learning Chess at 40 (2016) by lmm on Friday June 14, 2019 @07:52AM (#20182196)
> The universe is full of puzzles that mean something to solve. Why not work on those instead? Why would those be less interesting than a contrived set of rules?

Because those rules are designed (often iteratively) to be interesting. They have exactly the right rate of progress/reward to be engaging. In some research areas today it takes two years of postgrad work just to get to the point where you're capable of doing original research - and there's no guarantee that you'll produce anything useful even then.

Acquiring mastery of a skill is a fun experience, and drives a lot of human activity. Certainly most e.g. programming language designers seem to enjoy the skill and craft of doing it; I'm not at all convinced that that's not the real motivation for that activity, however much people claim to be driven by practical value or monetary reward.

Ultimately meaning is what we make it. People tend to enjoy games because they feel that they reflect something meaningful; a game is a "toy model" of reality, but toy models can be useful. There's a reason we consider these games to be interesting challenges and measures of progress for the same AIs that we also want to be able to e.g. drive cars.

Re:Learning Chess at 40 (2016) by otabdeveloper4 on Friday June 14, 2019 @08:31AM (#20182412)
> Why would those be less interesting than a contrived set of rules?

Because "contrived rules" are a kind of work of art. This is especially evident in modern board games as the concept of "contrived rules" is refined more and more and in ever branching variations.

Re:Learning Chess at 40 (2016) by Art9681 on Friday June 14, 2019 @12:25PM (#20184240)
Time enjoyed is not time wasted. Dedicating one's entire free time to solving the mysteries of the universe will likely lead to failure. You have to step away from the task every now and then and enjoy mindless entertainment. You have to reset every now and then. I have spent countless hours on difficult programming problems only for the solution to "come to me" while mindlessly gaming, or taking a shower, or smoking a cig. The solution becomes clear when you're not thinking of the problem sometimes. There is research that indicates this is a real phenomenon.
Re:Learning Chess at 40 (2016) by WalterBright on Friday June 14, 2019 @03:23PM (#20185902)
Oh, I agree that after working a long time on difficult problems, I need a rest with mindless entertainment. For example, after finals week in college I'd go home, and just veg in front of the TV for a few days. Then I'd get bored and was ready to start the next semester.

It's just like doing hard physical work. Ya need a rest afterwards.

Chess isn't mindless entertainment. I don't see it as rest.

Solutions to difficult problems often come to me while I'm jogging. Something something about increased blood flow to brain? Yesterday I went out for a long walk, and thought of a much simpler solution than one I was going to implement. A very worthwhile walk!

Re:Learning Chess at 40 (2016) by danielbarla on Friday June 14, 2019 @07:15AM (#20182031)
Nicely said, and I think I agree for the most part. I'm not necessarily sold on there being intrinsic meaning to the universe's puzzles, as opposed to more artificial ones. I suppose one could argue either fairly convincingly, and it'd very quickly become an abstract, philosophical discussion about the meaning of life and everything. In the end, I'd recommend everyone to do whatever is the most meaningful for them, personally. I don't think we can necessarily impose a strict ordering of correctness on their views, but who knows, I may be wrong.
Re:Learning Chess at 40 (2016) by projektir on Friday June 14, 2019 @09:45AM (#20182928)
> The universe is full of puzzles that mean something to solve. Why not work on those instead? Why would those be less interesting than a contrived set of rules?

Can you give some examples? Most things I'm aware of that could be classified as puzzles require, at the very least, enormous time investment, if not specialization, and there's often lots of drudgery along the way.

Re:Learning Chess at 40 (2016) by WalterBright on Friday June 14, 2019 @03:30PM (#20185971)
> Can you give some examples?

Sure.

How can I get the D programming language to generate even faster code?

How can I take this piece of existing, working, kludgy code, and make it simple and elegant?

How do I distill the advantages of D into an elevator pitch?

What is the right combination of aftermarket parts that will make the engine in my Dodge deliver the characteristics I want?

How do I salvage a relationship with a valued colleague that has gone awry?

How do I optimize my investments to maximize returns?

I could go on forever.

Re:Learning Chess at 40 (2016) by blacksmythe on Friday June 14, 2019 @12:44PM (#20184395)

  >>  last few times I tried to play chess, my mind would just drift off designing a program to do it so I wouldn't have to bother.
That describes exactly how I feel about Sudoku.

I do find a good game of chess to be enjoyable, though.

Re:Learning Chess at 40 (2016) by Yajirobe on Friday June 14, 2019 @06:18AM (#20181799)
How are guitar playing skills useful if you don't plan to be a professional musician?
Re:Learning Chess at 40 (2016) by pessimizer on Friday June 14, 2019 @10:15AM (#20183181)
You can entertain people around a campfire. Or even on plastic benches on a concrete patio outside of a Nowhere, Arkansas highway gas station that sells milkshakes.
Re:Learning Chess at 40 (2016) by Simon_says on Friday June 14, 2019 @06:32AM (#20181858)
Chicks dig musicians.
Re:Learning Chess at 40 (2016) by _carl_jung on Friday June 14, 2019 @05:12AM (#20181511)
Well, some people want to devote themselves to joy, rather than usefulness.
Re:Learning Chess at 40 (2016) by WalterBright on Friday June 14, 2019 @06:33AM (#20181865)
I find joy in programming, and it's useful, too! For example, the other day I was pretty excited to figure out a solution to a long standing programming problem.
Re:Learning Chess at 40 (2016) by _carl_jung on Friday June 14, 2019 @07:14AM (#20182025)
You'd do well to consider that variety of interests in our culture is what enriches it.
Re:Learning Chess at 40 (2016) by WalterBright on Friday June 14, 2019 @03:33PM (#20185991)
I'd bore you with a book on everything that's interesting to me. I mentioned programming because that's what I'm known for.
Re:Learning Chess at 40 (2016) by kurtisc on Friday June 14, 2019 @07:13AM (#20182021)
And the use is what? Maybe it brought you joy, (a perception of) respect, or money? 2 of those come with sport and the last just brings the other 2.
Re:Learning Chess at 40 (2016) by gauravphoenix on Friday June 14, 2019 @06:20AM (#20181814)
I see that you don't understand, does it imply that you disagree too?
Re:Learning Chess at 40 (2016) by icr0 on Friday June 14, 2019 @10:54AM (#20183490)
I mean, to be completely honest, I find playing chess very fun, even if it was a "waste of time"