Re:Shazam-like technology used to identify bars illegally st...
by cruano on Thursday June 13, 2019 @11:28AM
(#20175779)
I mean but say for example I want a promotion but my boss is deciding between two people. I could work harder and expect that he chooses me or I could go and murder the other person. I weight my options and turns out murdering him is the easy way out so I choose that. You can't say it's not a moral argument when one option is breaking the law
Re:Shazam-like technology used to identify bars illegally st...
by Can_Not on Thursday June 13, 2019 @02:49PM
(#20177588)
Morality is not defined by the law, there are lots of moral activities that are illegal, and there are lots of immoral activities being carried out by the law.
Re:Shazam-like technology used to identify bars illegally st...
by carlmr on Thursday June 13, 2019 @11:38AM
(#20175876)
A company is there to make a profit. People have preferences. From the perspective of the company your interest should lie in maximizing the profit, given your target groups preferences. This is what is essentially the argument here.
It's not about discussing what is or isn't moral, your example probably isn't regarded as moral in most moral frameworks. But that is built into your subjective preferences. The company has to operate in a world with various preferences given as fact.
Re:Shazam-like technology used to identify bars illegally st...
by dorian-graph on Friday June 14, 2019 @04:41AM
(#20181394)
If it's either illegal or a poor experience. Either choose the poor exprience or nothing.
It is very much a moral argument as well as economics.
I wonder if it's attitudes similar to this that have landed us in some of these ultra-capitalist situations around the world.
"It's not about saving the planet, that's just a moral thing, it's just basic economics"
The argument doesn't really depend on people finding they have to view something.
They want to view it, so they look at the offering, which is illegal with bad customer experience or legal with better customer experience. They weigh their options according to their preferences, illegal VS legal, ad riddled pages vs smooth experience, having to find out how it works vs having it work in the TV out of the box. And then they will check the price to see what is the better trade off for them.
A good customer experience like Netflix will increase the odds that someone won't go through the hassle. Then if the price is reasonable people won't on average decide for the illegal option.
The problem for Netflix now is that a lot of third parties like Disney retract their content. This raises the price and worsens the UX, because you have to go through multiple subscriptions. This again raises the probability of pirating.
This is all just basic economics, not a moral argument.