News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by seiji on Friday December 17, 2010 @01:34PM (#2017156)
It's a joke parodying http://wikimediafoundation.org/wiki/WMFJA032/en/US

I can't imagine Scott or a tiny git website is in need of money.

Amusingly, if you try to enter an amount greater than $25000, google checkout just dies.

Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by klochner on Friday December 17, 2010 @01:42PM (#2017191)
Speaking of wikipedia, I'd be perfectly content if the "urgent appeal" banner were replaced with an ad.
Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by lambda on Friday December 17, 2010 @06:13PM (#2018265)
That would be horrible. Replacing it with an ad would mean that they are now beholden to the advertiser, as opposed to being beholden to their donors. Right now Wikipedia depends on their editors to provide content, and donors to provide money. If instead they relied on advertisers to provide money, they would lose an awful lot of credibility.

Also, why would you prefer an ad to the donation banner? Ads tend to promote excessive consumption or try and manipulate your baser desires to get you to part with your money. They tend to be animated, or play sounds, or dance all over your content. They provide vectors for malicious code to be injected into your site.

Instead, we have the founder of a highly useful collaborative educational resource (or sometimes some editors of same) asking for donations to support that without being beholden to corporate interests. Where's the problem?

Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by gojomo on Friday December 17, 2010 @10:23PM (#2018798)
The problems you cite depend on the implementation. Wikipedia could require ads to be unobtrusive, from a diverse set of advertisers, and placed via a system (perhaps completely automated) that insulates from advertiser meddling in content. And, anyone who's truly offended by ads could turn them off at their option, just like the [X] on the campaign ad.

Such a system might generate 10X the revenues. If Wikipedia doesn't need them all, either for current year operations or a lasting endowment, they could liberally fund other free-culture projects with the surplus.

The biggest risk I see -- and what I believe to be the de facto reason ads haven't been more seriously considered -- is that a large portion of the editor community shares your (IMHO irrational) fear of ads, and this fear could become self-fulfilling if the introduction of ads drives away editors.

Even this might be addressable with careful handling, though. For example, what if there was one official Wikipedia mirror that had ads -- rather than the hundreds of unofficial ad-drenched mirrors? The default site would still be ad-free, for all editors, users who opt to visit or link-to the ad-free site, and inlinks from ad-free or primarily non-commercial sites. But, inlinks from major commercial entities (like say Google) would go to the ad site, unless that user had opted differently.

Doesn't that give everyone what they want -- lots more money for free culture projects with a large default sphere insulated from the 'corrupting' influence of money?

Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by sandal on Saturday December 18, 2010 @02:19PM (#2020044)
Many of the things you describe here would make for a more palatable experience on an ad-based website. But you completely miss the boat by assuming that people 'fear' advertisement, some people just really dislike it on principle. This is especially true when it comes to free culture projects who wish to be self-sustainable and perhaps even feel as if their efforts are validated a bit by the willingness of their users to support their project.

Wikipedia is a huge project with tremendous social value. It is sad to me that you may be right that an advertisement would bring in 10x the revenue, because it means we're in a culture in which one expects to perpetually be in commercial relationships. This makes the user more likely to purchase a consumer good than they are to donate to a service that has been consistently offering them more value.

The reason for this is that any direct donation based system is deeply damaged by the mass tendency to assume that someone else is in a better position to donate. In fact, the more valuable (and successful) a project is, the more this becomes a problem. But this problem is cultural, in an ideal world people would have a greater social responsibility without the need for assuming someone else is going to take care of important services like these. To push us in that direction, we get a giant fucking picture of Jimmy Wales to make us feel guilty and give. Personally, this has about the same negative impact on me that an advertisement would, albeit for different reasons.

I think the real solution is for Wikipedia to find a better way to fund itself in a grassroots fashion. I have trouble seeing how the Wikimedia Foundation can't come up with other ways to fund themselves. They have a tremendous amount of content and data. I'd love to see them build something they can sell that would support Wikipedia's operations.

Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by storborg on Friday December 17, 2010 @07:31PM (#2018466)
Why would they lose credibility?

It seems like an ad could be much more profitable than the donation banner, because ads can be targeted, even with zero behavioral history. For example, if I'm visiting a page on the new Tron movie, show me ads for the Daft Punk album! Odds are I might buy it.

Also, all of the things you said about ads could be said about in-house donation banners.

    * Manipulate your baser desires to get you to part with your money
    * Tend to be animated... etc
    * Could provide vectors for malicious...
Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by lambda on Friday December 17, 2010 @09:26PM (#2018701)
They would lose credibility because there would be a conflict of interest. Advertisers would be able to manipulate Wikipedia by threatening to remove ads unless they received favorable coverage, or negative coverage were removed.

Yes, I'm sure that ads could be more profitable than a donation banner. This is why most websites have ads instead of donation banners. However, Wikipedia is not a for-profit enterprise. It is an educational non-profit. If it were a for-profit enterprise, people would trust it much less, not as many people would contribute to it since they'd wonder why they were donating time and effort to a for-profit enterprise, etc.

And none of those things you list are true of a donation banner. Donating to an educational non-profit is not a "baser desire." I have never seen an animated banner asking for donations on Wikipedia, nor anywhere else that I can think of off the top of my head. And donation banners are coming straight from Wikipedia, not a third party; if they wanted to send malicious code, they could do so directly. The point is that ad networks are notorious vectors to allow malicious code to be injected by third parties into other people's sites.

Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by patrickaljord on Saturday December 18, 2010 @03:03AM (#2019139)
> If it were a for-profit enterprise, people would trust it much less

You'd be surprised to learn how many people have no idea wikipedia is non-profit. A lot have no idea that you can edit articles and just assume it's a regular encyclopedia written by paid people. I have witnessed people telling me this too many times, and yes, it's pretty depressing.

Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by gojomo on Friday December 17, 2010 @10:34PM (#2018811)
Whether advertisers would have that influence depends on the specifics of the implementation; I think Wikipedia has the smarts and culture to resist any attempt at advertiser (or donor) manipulation.

The decision to make money from advertising (or other services other than charitable donations) is independent of the decision to be a mission-oriented non-profit or a for-profit. A non-profit can still make most of its budget from selling considerations; see for example The Mozilla Foundation.

Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by tzs on Saturday December 18, 2010 @03:34AM (#2019168)
You are assuming a model where they would have something like an ad sales department that deals directly with advertisers and so might try to put pressure on the editorial side to keep big ad clients happy.

There are other advertising models. For instance, why not Google ads or Bing ads? I don't see how there is much danger of those influencing editorial content.

Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by ghshephard on Friday December 17, 2010 @03:48PM (#2017708)
They got my donation, but for some reason I can't keep the ad from coming back, and, I'm now getting email asking for a monthly donation.

I just wish there was some way I could pay money to turn off the Massive Banner Ad off for a year. I'm happy to pay around $100-$150/year for WIkipedia, but the user experience is starting to degrade when a signicant chunk of my screen is a Massive "Urgent Appeal" banner.

Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by stevvooe on Friday December 17, 2010 @09:35PM (#2018718)
I'll write you some JavaScript to get rid of it for small one time fee of $100.
Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by Zev on Saturday December 18, 2010 @01:20AM (#2019035)
If you have a custom CSS sheet, you can add the following to it to remove the banner:

  div#siteNotice {
      display: none !important;
  }
Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by bajsejohannes on Friday December 17, 2010 @02:28PM (#2017375)
I find it particularly bad that the banner is there even after you donate.
Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by sjs on Friday December 17, 2010 @03:05PM (#2017544)
On top of that, a few weeks after donating I got an "urgent" request from Jimmy Wales looking for a recurring monthly donation.
Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by jdp23 on Friday December 17, 2010 @03:03PM (#2017537)
The urgent appeal banner is an ad.
Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by steveklabnik on Friday December 17, 2010 @03:38PM (#2017680)
It is, but it's not bad in the way that an outside advertisement is bad: there's no conflict of interest.
Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by beoba on Friday December 17, 2010 @01:48PM (#2017214)
one potential issue there: what happens when the advertiser doesn't like what they see on the article about them?

even if such 'influence' is disallowed, just the possibility of it occurring would hurt the site

Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by mseebach on Friday December 17, 2010 @03:56PM (#2017735)
If an advertiser is dissatisfied, he withdraws his ads and is replaced. If noone wants to advertise on controversial topics, wikipedia has more than enough uncontroversial content to pay the bills. They might even just disable ads on controversial pages, which would go a long way towards avoiding even percieved conflicts of interest.
Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by moe on Friday December 17, 2010 @02:28PM (#2017372)
I don't think anything would happen.

They should just get one big sponsor per year to cover their costs and be done with it. Why not have a McDonalds or Pepsi banner somewhere in the corner? Bargain branding for them, free wikipedia for us.

And to limit the influence they could make it a rule to switch sponsor once a year. Why not auction the ad-spot and donate the overflow to charity?

Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by dantheman on Friday December 17, 2010 @02:55PM (#2017488)
or just keep the extra as an endowment and eventually just run off that
Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by tyree732 on Friday December 17, 2010 @04:24PM (#2017847)
What happens when Google says they won't donate to Wikipedia unless the Google article represents them more favorably?
Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by juanefren on Friday December 17, 2010 @02:54PM (#2017480)
I had to put the following with chrome scripts.

$("#siteNotice").hide();

Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by rl1987 on Friday December 17, 2010 @02:34PM (#2017402)
Same here, I could take care of it with AdBlock...
Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by jroes on Friday December 17, 2010 @02:06PM (#2017299)
I knew something was up when he said it costs >1mil/year to host the git-scm site.
Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by blutonium on Friday December 17, 2010 @02:30PM (#2017381)
Joke? Maybe you underestimate the number of us gitiots. All the same, the SFC supports great projects[1] (and Mercurial too).

[1] http://sfconservancy.org/members/current/

Re:An urgent appeal from git-scm.com maintainer Scott Chacon by recoil on Saturday December 18, 2010 @12:50AM (#2018992)
You shouldn't be being downvoted for this comment... The content of the page has completely changed from a parody of the wikipedia appeal to a real one asking for donations for sfconservancy. This is the version everybody's talking about: http://i.min.us/idDeBk.png

(TBH I didn't actually recognise the parody myself and thought it was just a fairly crass call for donations that made a couple of silly claims. I guess I should read the small print).